It is not yet a feature, hopefully it will not become a trend, where the Legislation Drafting Agency (Baleg / Badan Legislasi) is asked to embargo the release of certain finalized Draft Bills by private sponsoring interests, in this case a Non-Government Organization (NGO), and then complies with the request. This appears to be contrary to principles of transparency and accountability, the very ideals that Indonesia's growing democracy aspires to in every sense.
For a Nation dominated by its seas and ocean resources with islands as far as the eye can see, it is little wonder that a comprehensive regulatory framework over such matters as shipping, ports, transportation, maritime claims, and ship mortgages (hypothec) is a question of priority.
As an archipelagic nation, Indonesia relies heavily on commercial shipping and the ports that service this industry. Yet, despite the existence of two Draft Bills; one on Ports and one on Shipping, the debate still rages as to whether the best means of regulating these two critical sectors is through separate laws or through one law and a series of Government Regulations. Nevertheless, there are two drafts (see ILB 27/4/2006 and ILD 28/4/2006) and it is the Draft Bill on Shipping along with 3 others (Railways, Aviation, and Roads) that are currently before the House of Representatives (DPR) and in particular are currently being debated by Commission V of the DPR.
The provision of public services is an essential component in the efficient and effective management and organization of communities by governments the world over. In this regard Indonesia is no different from any other nation; there is a continuing need to improve not only the quality of public services but there is also a need to improve levels of efficiency and effectiveness as well as the provision of greater legal certainty for the community at large in the use of these public services.
The Constitutional Court is not adverse to issuing decisions that give rise to a great deal of controversy and public debate regarding the legal reasoning used in reaching decisions or the application of those decisions in the real world.
The law on industrial relations has been on the books for some time and after an emergency delay for a lack of infrastructure and human resources, the Industrial Relations Court (IRC) created by the law is in full force and effect (see ILB 8/8/2006 and ILD 7/9/2005). Considering this reality it makes a great deal of sense for the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to issue a set of guidelines to govern how the law and the court are to operate. Law No. 2 of 2004 on Industrial Relations' Dispute Settlement Law (IRDS Law), as are most laws in Indonesia, a general statement agreed by the House of Representatives (DPR) on the basic premises and provisions of the law.
Before looking forward it is always a good idea to look back to see where one has come from. The clich that hindsight is 20/20 tells only half the story as it is this hindsight that allows for some general predictions of what the future holds to be made and to get a grasp of what direction, in this case the House of Representatives (DPR) is heading. This should be no different for the DPR than for any one else or any other institution, perhaps even more so for the DPR as it is the peak peoples representative institution, at least in terms of developing, debating, and passing legislation.
The Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR) has finally passed the Citizenship Bill. It has been a long and tortuous road and the result is possibly not what was expected from all sides of the debate. Nevertheless, the bill is being hailed as a breakthrough on the dual citizenship front, at least for the children of transnational or mixed marriages, yet at the same time being roundly criticized for the mechanisms installed to revoke and grant citizenship in certain circumstances.
The tax legislation currently being discussed and debate in and around the House of Representatives (DPR) and specifically the Special Committee (Pansus) set up to formulate the discussion and debate is not without controversy. However, the controversies relate more to the method and mechanisms of the submission of the draft legislation to the DPR and what has happened to that legislation since its submission rather than with respect to the substance of the legislation itself.
PT. Lapindo Brantas ('Lapindo') has come under intense media scrutiny over the past several weeks as one of its natural gas exploration wells at Banarpanji-1 in Porong, Sidoarjo, East Java, has begun leaking an uncontrollable and steady stream of hot mud into surrounding areas destroying not only fertile agricultural lands but also threatening transportation in the region as the main Surabaya - Malang toll road has been cut by the ever-flowing hot mud. The hot mud has a high sulphur content which only serves to heighten the risks and damage not only to property but to people as well. The mud has inundated 3 villages that surround the drilling site and resulted in the mass evacuations of residents from the surrounding areas and the hospitalization of some 300 people. The mud has also been allegedly the cause of 2 deaths relating to respiratory failure. However, these allegations relating to deaths attributable to the mud remain to be proved.