Overview
As an archipelagic nation, Indonesia relies heavily on commercial shipping and the ports that service this industry. Yet, despite the existence of two Draft Bills; one on Ports and one on Shipping, the debate still rages as to whether the best means of regulating these two critical sectors is through separate laws or through one law and a series of Government Regulations. Nevertheless, there are two drafts (see ILB 27/4/2006 and ILD 28/4/2006) and it is the Draft Bill on Shipping along with 3 others (Railways, Aviation, and Roads) that are currently before the House of Representatives (DPR) and in particular are currently being debated by Commission V of the DPR.
The Draft Bill on Ports (Draft Bill) has recently been submitted by the House of Regional Representatives (DPD) to the DPR. The DPD in its evaluation of the Draft Bill focused on issues relating to driving national economic growth, disparity between regions, and enhanced regional autonomy. The other interesting feature of the DPD evaluation was the insistence that there be a separate Draft Bill on Ports as a means of minimizing the number of Government Regulations that would be required to facilitate implementation in the future. The original analysis of the Draft Bill on Shipping, which includes the regulation of Indonesian ports, showed that approximately 86 Government Regulations would have been necessary to fully implement the Bill once it had been passed. There is an expectation that with two separate bills that the number of Government Regulations required can be significantly reduced. The current Draft Bill on Ports includes provision for just 11 Government Regulations.
......