Responding to the rapid growth of trading activities on the internet (“e-commerce”), the government is currently discussing a Draft Government Regulation on Transactions trough Electronic Systems (“Draft Regulation”). The Minister of Trade (“Ministry”) is the responsible for preparing the Draft Regulation with the support of the Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Communications and Information Technology.
In essence, the Draft Regulation aims to strengthen consumer protection for e-commerce transactions, and at the same time improve compliance in terms of taxation and excise. To this end, the Draft Regulation sets out provisions on the following matters:
|
a.
|
Business in e-commerce transaction;
|
|
b.
|
E-commerce transaction procedures (covering: online advertising; offer and acceptance; payment; delivery of goods; and refund policies);
|
|
c.
|
Protection of personal data and information;
|
|
d.
|
Supervisory measures by the Ministry;
|
|
e.
|
Dispute resolution; and
|
|
f.
|
Sanctions for non-compliance.
|
The Draft Regulation is in relevant to business engaged in e-commerce and the public in general as consumers.
BUSINESS IN E-COMMERCE
The Draft Regulation provides for three types of business for e-commerce transactions (“Business”):[1]
|
a.
|
Seller (merchant);
|
|
b.
|
Organizer of E-Commerce Transactions through Electronic Systems (Penyelenggara Transaksi perdagangan melalui Sistem Elektronik/”PTPMSE”); and
|
|
c.
|
Intermediary Services Organizers (Penyelenggara Sarana Perantara).
|
Sellers
A seller or merchant refers to individual or business that utilizes electronic systems for trading transactions.[2] In offering their goods or services, the seller must provide details of their identity such as identification information and business license.[3]
A seller must secure the following licenses from the Ministry:[4]
|
a.
|
Registration Certificate as an E-Commerce Business;
|
|
b.
|
Special business license for trading through electronic systems if the seller has their own electronic system to sell their goods/services; and/or
|
|
c.
|
Business license if the seller is a foreign seller.
|
It is important to note that, any Seller who executes a transaction with an Indonesian customer is deemed to be performing business in Indonesia despite their location.[5] As a consequence, an Indonesian customer may bring a legal action to national consumer dispute resolution institution or file a lawsuit against the seller.[6]
PTPMSE
PTPMSE refers to a business that provides an electronic trading communication system between a seller and a buyer that covers information on offer and acceptance, confirmation of acceptance, agreement between the seller and buyer, etc.[7]
The Draft Regulation, however, is inconsistent regarding PTPMSE’s legal form. Pursuant to Article 12 (2), a PTPMSE must be in the form of an Indonesian incorporated entity. Moreover, the majority of shares of a PTPMSE must be held by an Indonesian citizen or incorporated entity. Article 18 (4), however, states that a foreign PTPMSE may engage in business in Indonesia, without requiring it to be established as an Indonesian entity.
Disputes with a PTPMSE can be settled through a national consumers dispute resolution institution or the district court where the PTPMSE is located (if the PTPMSE is located overseas, the lawsuit is submitted to the Central Jakarta District Court).[8]
Similar to a seller, a PTPMSE is required to secure a number of licenses from the Ministry or related official, namely:[9]
|
a.
|
Registration Certificate as an E-Commerce Business;
|
|
b.
|
Special business license for trading through electronic systems;
|
|
c.
|
Business license, if the PTPMSE is a foreign business entity; and/or
|
|
d.
|
Business license for conducting transactions through electronic systems.
|
A PTPMSE must notify and take necessary measures to respond to any report of illegal content in their electronic services. The PTPMSE is responsible for losses resulting from illegal content in their services, unless the following criteria are satisfied:[10]
|
a.
|
The PTPMSE is only acting as an intermediary to convey information between the seller and the buyer (does not initiate, verify, or modify any information);
|
|
b.
|
The PTPMSE only acts as the host of the electronic service;
|
|
c.
|
The PTPMSE only provides search engine services.
|
Intermediary Services Organizer
An intermediary service organizer is business that acts as an intermediary between senders and recipients in an electronic communication.[11] Unlike PTPMSE, the involvement of an intermediary service organizer in an e-commerce transaction is limited to providing search engine, hosting, or caching facilities.[12]
An intermediary service organizer must be registered at the Ministry, unless:[13]
|
a.
|
The organizer is not a beneficiary to the party in the e-commerce transaction; or
|
|
b.
|
The organizer is not directly involved in the contractual relation between parties to the e-commerce transaction.
|
E-COMMERCE TRANSACTIONS
Offer and Acceptance
An agreement between a seller/PTPSME and a buyer for an e-commerce transaction is considered established if the buyer accepts the technical, substantial, and conditional requirements stated by the seller/PTPSME. There is no agreement if the acceptance does not match with the offer.[14]
Upon receiving acceptance from the buyer, the seller/PTPSME must deliver electronic confirmation to the buyer.[15] Note that proof of the transaction must be maintained by the PTPSME and will be treated as an admissible written and authentic agreement before the court.[16]
Payment
Payment for e-commerce transactions can be conducted through banking payment systems or another electronic system that has been approved by Bank Indonesia.[17] Alternatively, a PTPSME may engage in cooperation with another entity to provide the electronic payment system.[18]
Delivery
The seller must deliver the ordered goods upon receiving acceptance from the buyer. If the payment process is settled between the buyer and the PTPMSE, the PTPMSE is responsible for delivering the goods to the buyer.[19] This responsibility covers the obligation to inform the buyer about information on delivery period and delivery status.[20]
Refund, Exchange, and Cancelation Policy
A buyer has the right to change or cancel a purchase within 15 days of receiving the purchase goods if one of the following conditions is met:[21]
|
a.
|
The goods do not match the description;
|
|
b.
|
Defect or damage to the goods; or
|
|
c.
|
The goods have expired.
|
Note that the seller or PTPMSE is prohibited from imposing any cost or fee for the exchange or cancelation of a purchase item except for the delivery costs.[22]
TAXATION OBLIGATIONS
A business that performs e-commerce transactions with Indonesian consumers is considered to have conducted physical trading activities in Indonesia.[23] In other words, the business is subject to all taxation obligations under prevailing laws and regulations, such as income tax, value added tax, etc.
The Draft Regulation is currently being discussed by the government and may subject to change. RFS
[1]Art. 11, Draft Regulation.
[2]Art. 1 (9), Draft Regulation.
[3]Art. 8 (1) and Elucidation of Art. 8 (1), Draft Regulation.
[4]Art. 18 (1) (2) and (4), Draft Regulation.
[5]Art. 13, Draft Regulation.
[6]Art. 5 (3), Draft Regulation.
[7]Art. 1 (11), Draft Regulation. Example of PTPSME in Indonesia such as Lazada.co.id, bukalapak.co.id, tokopedia.com.
[8]Art. 5 (3) and 14, Draft Regulation.
[9]Art. 18 (1) (2) and (4) and Art. 25 (e), Draft Regulation.
[10]Art. 27 (1) (2) and 28, Draft Regulation.
[11]Art. 1 (12), Draft Regulation.
[12]Elucidation Art. 11 (c), Draft Regulation.
[13]Art. 18 (3), Draft Regulation.
[14]Art. 50, Draft Regulation.
[15]Art. 53, Draft Regulation.
[16]Art. 35 (a) (b) and 36 (1), Draft Regulation.
[17]Art. 59 (2) (3), Draft Regulation.
[18]Art. 59 (4), Draft Regulation.
[19]Art. 62 and 63, Draft Regulation.
[20]Art. 65 (1), Draft Regulation.
[21]Art. 77 (1) (2), Draft Regulation.
[22]Art. 77 (3), Draft Regulation.
[23]Art. 68, Draft Regulation.
...