Censorship Obligations of Internet Service Providers

The recent Draft Minister of Communication and Information Regulation on Multimedia Content - available via the website of the Directorate General of Post and Telecommunication - has been a source of much contention, from media activists to Indonesian internet service providers (ISPs). The draft would have ISPs as ‘Multimedia Service Organizers’ be responsible for supervising internet use and implementing forms of censorship on behalf of the state.

 

Beyond creating rules for - and subsequently monitoring - internet service use of customers, ISPs would also be tasked with blocking access to sites with governmentally-decided prohibited media content. ISPs would also be accountable for the dissemination of content complaint reports, evaluating whether it be ‘prohibited,’ ‘allowed,’ or ‘unclear’ content, and forwarding a recommendation to the multimedia content team established by the Minister. Sites hosting content to be censored would be invited to remove the content within 72 hours, otherwise ISPs would be ordered to block access to the service.

 

ISPs would be required to report their supervision tasks to the Director General charged with multimedia content supervision, who would then issue a letter detailing the level of an ISP’s compliance with the regulation. For ISPs whose compliance with governmental censorship mandates is deemed unsatisfactory, administrative sanctions would be imposed, including any combination of: written warnings, administrative fines, restriction of business activities, or license revocation.

 

Contents that can be categorized as prohibited content, as listed in Chapter II of the draft, include pornographic content and ‘content that violates morality’. Given the broad, self-referential, inherently subjective nature of ‘morality,’ activists have argued that a wide spectrum of interpretation is available to the Ministry’s censorship officials for the bludgeoning of democratic activity.

 

ISPs, on the other hand, have argued that by definition they are simply ‘connectors’ and have no role in - or control over - content uploaded by internet users, and that the obligations would be difficult to implement due to many (most) content being hosted in servers outside Indonesia. 

 

The Ministry of Communication and Information invited criticism on the draft from February 11 to 19, and the degree to which it attends to the public critique will be evident whenever it decides to issue the final regulation.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

The recent Draft Minister of Communication and Information Regulation on Multimedia Content - available via the website of the Directorate General of Post and Telecommunication - has been a source of much contention, from media activists to Indonesian internet service providers (ISPs). The draft would have ISPs as ‘Multimedia Service Organizers’ be responsible for supervising internet use and implementing forms of censorship on behalf of the state.

 

Beyond creating rules for - and subsequently monitoring - internet service use of customers, ISPs would also be tasked with blocking access to sites with governmentally-decided prohibited media content. ISPs would also be accountable for the dissemination of content complaint reports, evaluating whether it be ‘prohibited,’ ‘allowed,’ or ‘unclear’ content, and forwarding a recommendation to the multimedia content team established by the Minister. Sites hosting content to be censored would be invited to remove the content within 72 hours, otherwise ISPs would be ordered to block access to the service.

 

ISPs would be required to report their supervision tasks to the Director General charged with multimedia content supervision, who would then issue a letter detailing the level of an ISP’s compliance with the regulation. For ISPs whose compliance with governmental censorship mandates is deemed unsatisfactory, administrative sanctions would be imposed, including any combination of: written warnings, administrative fines, restriction of business activities, or license revocation.

 

Contents that can be categorized as prohibited content, as listed in Chapter II of the draft, include pornographic content and ‘content that violates morality’. Given the broad, self-referential, inherently subjective nature of ‘morality,’ activists have argued that a wide spectrum of interpretation is available to the Ministry’s censorship officials for the bludgeoning of democratic activity.

 

ISPs, on the other hand, have argued that by definition they are simply ‘connectors’ and have no role in - or control over - content uploaded by internet users, and that the obligations would be difficult to implement due to many (most) content being hosted in servers outside Indonesia. 

 

The Ministry of Communication and Information invited criticism on the draft from February 11 to 19, and the degree to which it attends to the public critique will be evident whenever it decides to issue the final regulation.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info