Karen Agustiawan Corruption Case: Business Judgment Rule Invoked in Dissenting Opinion

  • On 10 June 2019, the ex-CEO of state oil company PT Pertamina, Karen Agustiawan, was convicted of corruption by Indonesia’s Special Court for Corruption Crimes in Jakarta in relation to the purchase of a participating interest (“PI”) in the Basker Manta Gummy (“BMG”) block in Australia. Agustiawan was handed an eight-year sentence, as well as IDR 1 billion in fines (or a further four months of imprisonment).
  • However, dissenting opinion emerged from the panel of judges during Agustiawan’s trial, specifically from Judge Anwar, who asserted that Agustiawan should be acquitted of all criminal charges due to the fact that her conduct was protected by business judgment rule (“BJR”) principles.  
  • Judge Anwar went on to assert that BJR principles should prevail in this case due to the fact that: 1) The purchase of the PI in the BMG was decided on a collegial basis by the entire Board of Directors (“BoD”) members and was also based on the approval of the Board of Commissioners (“BoC”) (although one BoC member raised an objection); 2) The clash of opinions that emerged between the BoD and BoC in this case did not constitute an unlawful act (melawan hukum); and 3) The IDR 568 billion in losses claimed by the prosecutors should not necessarily be construed as state losses, as the relevant payment was undertaken according to official procedures, while Agustiawan herself did not receive any transfers of funds.
  • For more information on the BJR, see ILD No. 580.
  • For more information, see: “Ajukan Dissenting Opinion dalam Putusan Karen, Hakim ini Gunakan Dalil Business Judgment Rule”
......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
  • On 10 June 2019, the ex-CEO of state oil company PT Pertamina, Karen Agustiawan, was convicted of corruption by Indonesia’s Special Court for Corruption Crimes in Jakarta in relation to the purchase of a participating interest (“PI”) in the Basker Manta Gummy (“BMG”) block in Australia. Agustiawan was handed an eight-year sentence, as well as IDR 1 billion in fines (or a further four months of imprisonment).
  • However, dissenting opinion emerged from the panel of judges during Agustiawan’s trial, specifically from Judge Anwar, who asserted that Agustiawan should be acquitted of all criminal charges due to the fact that her conduct was protected by business judgment rule (“BJR”) principles.  
  • Judge Anwar went on to assert that BJR principles should prevail in this case due to the fact that: 1) The purchase of the PI in the BMG was decided on a collegial basis by the entire Board of Directors (“BoD”) members and was also based on the approval of the Board of Commissioners (“BoC”) (although one BoC member raised an objection); 2) The clash of opinions that emerged between the BoD and BoC in this case did not constitute an unlawful act (melawan hukum); and 3) The IDR 568 billion in losses claimed by the prosecutors should not necessarily be construed as state losses, as the relevant payment was undertaken according to official procedures, while Agustiawan herself did not receive any transfers of funds.
  • For more information on the BJR, see ILD No. 580.
  • For more information, see: “Ajukan Dissenting Opinion dalam Putusan Karen, Hakim ini Gunakan Dalil Business Judgment Rule”
......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info