Marcell Sihombing, CR-20

Some areas in Sumatera and Kalimantan are covered by forest fires which cause smog. The administration of President Joko Widodo is urged to immediately resolve this situation immediately by improving law-enforcement measures towards forest fire perpetrators.
During a press conference which was held at the Ministry of Environmental Affairs and Forestry (Ministry) Office last week, Siti Nurbaya, the Minister of Environmental Affairs and Forestry, stated that the main cause of forest and land fires in Indonesia was the misappropriation of valid forestry licenses. Minister Nurbaya’s field investigations have revealed a pattern of misappropriation across several locations in which forest and land fires have taken place.
In November 2014, Minister Nurbaya became aware that the common modus operandi in Riau involves companies which disguise themselves as the representatives of local communities, but who are actually backed by investors. In January 2015, Minister Nurbaya subsequently uncovered a similar scam relating to several other forest-fire cases in West Kalimantan, Central Kalimantan and North Sumatra.
“Although there has not been any confirmation yet, I believe that the same pattern caused the fires in South Sumatra and Jambi,” Minister Nurbaya asserted.
Offering further insight, Minister Nurbaya explained that the misappropriation of valid forestry licenses meant that any companies engaged in forestry-related business based on a given Forestry Concession (
Hak Pengusahaan Hutan - HPH) or even illegal logging activities could first secure a Plantation Business License (
Izin Usaha Perkebunan - IUP). These companies then subsequently alter the function of their IUPs by converting their forest areas in accordance with existing spatial layout plans in order to secure the relevant Forest Borrow-to-Use License (
Izin Usaha Pinjam Pakai Kawasan Hutan - IPPKH). After this process has been completed, the companies in question can then engage in mining activities and the like.
Minister Nurbaya also recently released data originally uncovered by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) into the public domain which relates to various forest and land fire cases in Indonesia. According to this data, there are currently 447 forestry-related companies operating in Riau, 154 of which have secured official cultivation rights titles (
hak guna usaha), as issued by provincial or regional/municipal governments.
Meanwhile, 145 companies are currently in possession of IUPs which were issued by local Plantation Offices (
Dinas Perkebunan), while 21 companies have only obtained Location Permits, which are either non-definitive or for reservations only. This leaves 127 companies which are operating illegally, and without any licenses at all.
In the wake of Minister Nurbaya’s statement,
hukumonline decided to seek further clarification from a number of experts in the field of forestry policy. One of these experts was Hariadi Kartodihardjo, a forestry policy expert and KPK officer specializing in forestry-related corruption.
Hukumonline learned that Mr. Kartodihardjo once attended a meeting between the KPK and the Special Committee of Commission A of Riau province’s Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) in order to calculate the total government losses caused by illegal forestry operations.
“During the meeting, it was revealed that out of a total of 4.2 million hectares of palm oil plantations which are situated in the province of Riau, 1.8 million hectares are being cultivated illegally without the relevant licenses being held by anyone,” Mr. Kartodihardjo told
hukumonline on 9 September 2016.
Mr. Kartodihardjo went on to explain that these illegal operations had been ongoing in Riau for a long time now. Indeed, based on the results of research undertaken by Mr. Kartodihardjo in conjunction with the Riau Forest Rescue Network (
Jaringan Kerja Penyelamat Hutan Riau - Jikalahari) some seven years ago, at least 61 palm-oil plantations are continuing to operate within the Tesso Nillo National Park, in spite of the fact that the HPHs for these locations have already been revoked.
As a result of this finding, suspicions have arisen regarding the identity of the owners of these plantations. Mr. Kartodihardjo has raised the possibility that companies applying for Timber Utilization Business Permits for Industrial Plantation Forest in Areas of Production Forest (
Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Hasil Hutan Kayu Dalam Hutan Tanaman Industri – “
IUPHHK-HTI”) have been illegally utilizing their designated work areas in order to set up palm-oil plantations. If this is indeed the case, then any such companies must have gone through a lengthy administration process, including the formulation of annual plans and five-year plans before they could actually commence business operations.
The conclusion that Mr. Kartodihardjo has drawn from all this is that this situation is not the result of mere independent actions which are solely undertaken by corrupt companies, especially in light of the fact that such practices have now been going on for years. Indeed, Mr. Kartodihardjo believes that it is impossible that such long-term companies could just slip off the edge of the government’s monitoring radar. Although technically Mr. Kartodihardjo considers this situation to be one of negligence, he stressed that more detailed facts would have to be uncovered by any investigations into this matter, as each company will have a different story to tell.
In a bid to clarify matters, Mr. Kartodihardjo also explained the process underlying the conversion of HPHs into industrial plantations. To begin with, an HPH can initially be secured via the Ministry after a recommendation has first been secured from the relevant regional level government. Any such concessions can be used for operations in either natural forests or other designated areas (
area peruntukan lain – APL).
Mr. Kartodihardjo went on to explain that during the formulation of any spatial layout plans, the relevant regional-level governments can decide that the APL must no longer be regarded as forest areas and should be allocated for palm-oil plantations instead. Procedurally, an HPH can be directly converted into a palm-oil plantation via an APL. If an APL is damaged however, then any such area can only be converted into an industrial plantation.
In addition to Mr. Kartodihardjo,
hukumonline also spoke with Jikalahari Coordinator, Woro Supratinah, who expounded upon the actual conditions on the ground in Riau’s forests. According to Mrs. Supratinah, many areas in Riau’s forests are owned by locals who frequently set fires in order to clear their plots, as they don’t have any other alternative. However, Mrs. Supratinah questioned how much of a contribution such clearing makes to deforestation as a whole, as it is generally local in nature and involves plots which are very small in comparison with those which are utilized by big companies.
Mrs. Supratinah further revealed that there are many organized groups from other regions who live around company concession areas and who work for the companies in question. In several cases, forest fires that have taken place within such areas were in fact planned beforehand, in a bid to expand a company’s concession area through the hiring of third parties.
“Such planned forest fires include the creation of pathways in advance, or the setting up of land plots in areas which have been earmarked for burning. Some areas have even been discovered to already contain palm-oil seeds ready for planting. Usually, a planned forest fire aims to chase any conflicting groups of locals away, so that the company can then expand freely,” Mrs. Supratinah explained.
Mrs. Supratinah’s explanation largely squares with that provided by Minister Nurbaya’s statement, and it seems clear that the arrest of forest-fire perpetrators usually results in only individual offenders ever being caught, who will then more often than not confess that they are actually in the employ of other parties. However, these so-called “other parties” are rarely tracked down and have usually already escaped by the time that any direct individual offenders are arrested. Thus, investigations into forest fires usually meet a dead end.
In conclusion, any attempts at law enforcement and efforts to bring the perpetrators of forest fires to justice will continue to face obstacles, so long as no improvements in licensing procedures, field verifications and monitoring efforts are made, and if criminal responsibility continues to only be pursued at an individual level.
(cd/sp)