Clarification from LSP for Lawyers regarding BNSP Decision on the Certification of Lawyers



 
Marcell Sihombing, Rofiq Hidayat, Tri Yuanita Indriani

 
The issuance of Head of the National Professional Certification Authority (BNSP) Decision No. Kep.0562/BNSP/V/2016(2016 BNSP Decision) on 24 May 2016 has caused considerable uproar among members of the Indonesian Advocates Association (PERADI). The 2016 BNSP Decision grants the Indonesian Professional Certification Agency for Lawyers (LSP for Lawyers) the authority to undertake certification processes for any individuals who are intending to become professional lawyers.
 
Attempts made by Hukumonline to obtain official clarification from the BNSP regarding this issue initially proved unsuccessful. However, on Saturday, 4 June 2016, Hukumonline attended the 8th Anniversary of the Indonesian Advocates Congress (Kongres Advokat Indonesia - “KAI”), which was held in Solo under the ministration of Tjoetjoe S. Hernanto. During the event, Hukumonline successfully obtained an explanation regarding the issue of certification for lawyers from Mr. Urbanisasi, Director of the LSP for Lawyers.
 
Mr. Urbanisasi told Hukumonline that the establishment of the LSP for Lawyers approximately six months ago was recommended by KAI, and that his institution would only conduct certification processing for lawyers which are affiliated with KAI. Mr. Urbanisasi further emphasized that the LSP for Lawyers was an independent institution which is separate from KAI’s organizational structure.
 
“This is because all competency assessments must be conducted independently. We [the LSP for Lawyers] must not become integrated into KAI’s organizational structure, so that the fairness principle can be upheld. There are certain guidelines that we must uphold and comply with,” asserted Mr. Urbanisasi.
 
Mr. Urban also revealed that the LSP for Lawyers followed competency standards based upon BNSP guidelines, adding that despite its primary focus of assessing the competency of lawyers affiliated with KAI, the LSP for Lawyers would not turn down non-KAI lawyers who are intending to secure the competency certificates issued by his institution.
 
“Nonetheless, our competency certification represents exclusive competency standards which are only applicable to KAI members. Ultimately, they are not national competency standards which must be satisfied by all lawyers across the country,” Mr. Urbanisasi asserted.
 
Summing up his position, Mr. Urbanisasi stressed that lawyers who are affiliated with other bar organizations should not concern themselves with the certification process offered by the LSP for Lawyers, as it does not represent another hurdle which has to be overcome by lawyers in relation to the provision of their professional services, be they inside or outside of the courtroom.
 
From a slightly different perspective, Mr. Urbanisasi also explained why the term “lawyer” has been used in this context. According to Mr. Urbanisasi, his institution was originally registered with the Directorate General of General Legal Administration at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights (Ministry) as the “LSP for Advocates.” However, the application was ultimately rejected because the Ministry was no longer accepting the registration of any institutions which contained the word “advocate” in their official titles. Thus the organization became the LSP for Lawyers.
 
“The Ministry has decided that the term ‘advocate’ can no longer be registered,” Mr. Urbanisasi concluded.
 
Three PERADI Factions Join Forces to Challenge 2016 BNSP Decision

Meanwhile, the issuance of the 2016 BNSP Decision as led all three PERADI factions to make a stand. The factions are demanding nothing less than the total revocation of the 2016 BNSP Decision. In fact, when separately asked for confirmation by Hukumonline, all three factions reminded their members not to take this particular matter seriously.
 
“There’s no need for [my] lawyer colleagues to become anxious. They should consider it nothing and continue with business as usual,” asserted Hasanuddin Nasution, the General Secretary of the PERADI Juniver Girsang faction.
 
Mr. Nasution further revealed that he and the other management personnel from the Juniver Girsang faction working for the PERADI National Management Board would immediately take all measures that they deem necessary should the 2016 BNSP Decision end up causing any inconvenience to the faction’s members. However, Mr. Nasution stressed that he would first discuss the matter with the BNSP before doing so.
 
In line with Mr. Nasution, Junaedi Sirait, the Vice-Chair of PERADI’s National Management Board and a member of the Luhut Pangaribuan faction, also reminded his fellow members not to become anxious. Mr. Sirait believes that the 2016 BNSP Decision is a legal fallacy, as Law No. 18 of 2003 (Advocate Law) already grants certification authority to PERADI. Moreover, it is PERADI which organizes the various Professional Legal Courses for Lawyers (Pendidikan Khusus Profesi Advokat - PKPA), as well as the bar exam. PERADI was also responsible for the introduction of the mandatory two-year internship for prospective lawyers, a mandatory step which has to be completed before they are allowed to take the official oath and become fully fledged professional lawyers.
 
“All of these processes already satisfy the definition of lawyer certification, which was delegated to lawyer associations in the first place. With this in mind, where did the LSP for Lawyers get its license to engage in the same practice [the certification of lawyers]?” asked Mr. Sirait.
 
Jamaslin James Purba, Vice-Chair of PERADI’s National Management Board and a member of the Fauzie Hasibuan faction expressed his broad agreement with Mr. Nasution and Mr. Sirait. Mr. Purba also added that the 2016 BNSP Decision was not legally binding on lawyers, due to the fact that there are no sanctions for lawyers who do not follow the certification process conducted by the LSP for Lawyers.
 
“We have already reviewed the text of the 2016 BNSP Decision and it does not stipulate any sanctions for non-compliance, which means that it is fine if lawyers do not end up following the LSP for Lawyers certification process. In this context, it is obvious why lawyers have rejected this new certification process, as it outlines no sanctions and has merely ended up causing uproar,” Mr. Purba concluded.

 
(rs/sp)


 
Marcell Sihombing, Rofiq Hidayat, Tri Yuanita Indriani

 
The issuance of Head of the National Professional Certification Authority (BNSP) Decision No. Kep.0562/BNSP/V/2016(2016 BNSP Decision) on 24 May 2016 has caused considerable uproar among members of the Indonesian Advocates Association (PERADI). The 2016 BNSP Decision grants the Indonesian Professional Certification Agency for Lawyers (LSP for Lawyers) the authority to undertake certification processes for any individuals who are intending to become professional lawyers.
 
Attempts made by Hukumonline to obtain official clarification from the BNSP regarding this issue initially proved unsuccessful. However, on Saturday, 4 June 2016, Hukumonline attended the 8th Anniversary of the Indonesian Advocates Congress (Kongres Advokat Indonesia - “KAI”), which was held in Solo under the ministration of Tjoetjoe S. Hernanto. During the event, Hukumonline successfully obtained an explanation regarding the issue of certification for lawyers from Mr. Urbanisasi, Director of the LSP for Lawyers.
 
Mr. Urbanisasi told Hukumonline that the establishment of the LSP for Lawyers approximately six months ago was recommended by KAI, and that his institution would only conduct certification processing for lawyers which are affiliated with KAI. Mr. Urbanisasi further emphasized that the LSP for Lawyers was an independent institution which is separate from KAI’s organizational structure.
 
“This is because all competency assessments must be conducted independently. We [the LSP for Lawyers] must not become integrated into KAI’s organizational structure, so that the fairness principle can be upheld. There are certain guidelines that we must uphold and comply with,” asserted Mr. Urbanisasi.
 
Mr. Urban also revealed that the LSP for Lawyers followed competency standards based upon BNSP guidelines, adding that despite its primary focus of assessing the competency of lawyers affiliated with KAI, the LSP for Lawyers would not turn down non-KAI lawyers who are intending to secure the competency certificates issued by his institution.
 
“Nonetheless, our competency certification represents exclusive competency standards which are only applicable to KAI members. Ultimately, they are not national competency standards which must be satisfied by all lawyers across the country,” Mr. Urbanisasi asserted.
 
Summing up his position, Mr. Urbanisasi stressed that lawyers who are affiliated with other bar organizations should not concern themselves with the certification process offered by the LSP for Lawyers, as it does not represent another hurdle which has to be overcome by lawyers in relation to the provision of their professional services, be they inside or outside of the courtroom.
 
From a slightly different perspective, Mr. Urbanisasi also explained why the term “lawyer” has been used in this context. According to Mr. Urbanisasi, his institution was originally registered with the Directorate General of General Legal Administration at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights (Ministry) as the “LSP for Advocates.” However, the application was ultimately rejected because the Ministry was no longer accepting the registration of any institutions which contained the word “advocate” in their official titles. Thus the organization became the LSP for Lawyers.
 
“The Ministry has decided that the term ‘advocate’ can no longer be registered,” Mr. Urbanisasi concluded.
 
Three PERADI Factions Join Forces to Challenge 2016 BNSP Decision

Meanwhile, the issuance of the 2016 BNSP Decision as led all three PERADI factions to make a stand. The factions are demanding nothing less than the total revocation of the 2016 BNSP Decision. In fact, when separately asked for confirmation by Hukumonline, all three factions reminded their members not to take this particular matter seriously.
 
“There’s no need for [my] lawyer colleagues to become anxious. They should consider it nothing and continue with business as usual,” asserted Hasanuddin Nasution, the General Secretary of the PERADI Juniver Girsang faction.
 
Mr. Nasution further revealed that he and the other management personnel from the Juniver Girsang faction working for the PERADI National Management Board would immediately take all measures that they deem necessary should the 2016 BNSP Decision end up causing any inconvenience to the faction’s members. However, Mr. Nasution stressed that he would first discuss the matter with the BNSP before doing so.
 
In line with Mr. Nasution, Junaedi Sirait, the Vice-Chair of PERADI’s National Management Board and a member of the Luhut Pangaribuan faction, also reminded his fellow members not to become anxious. Mr. Sirait believes that the 2016 BNSP Decision is a legal fallacy, as Law No. 18 of 2003 (Advocate Law) already grants certification authority to PERADI. Moreover, it is PERADI which organizes the various Professional Legal Courses for Lawyers (Pendidikan Khusus Profesi Advokat - PKPA), as well as the bar exam. PERADI was also responsible for the introduction of the mandatory two-year internship for prospective lawyers, a mandatory step which has to be completed before they are allowed to take the official oath and become fully fledged professional lawyers.
 
“All of these processes already satisfy the definition of lawyer certification, which was delegated to lawyer associations in the first place. With this in mind, where did the LSP for Lawyers get its license to engage in the same practice [the certification of lawyers]?” asked Mr. Sirait.
 
Jamaslin James Purba, Vice-Chair of PERADI’s National Management Board and a member of the Fauzie Hasibuan faction expressed his broad agreement with Mr. Nasution and Mr. Sirait. Mr. Purba also added that the 2016 BNSP Decision was not legally binding on lawyers, due to the fact that there are no sanctions for lawyers who do not follow the certification process conducted by the LSP for Lawyers.
 
“We have already reviewed the text of the 2016 BNSP Decision and it does not stipulate any sanctions for non-compliance, which means that it is fine if lawyers do not end up following the LSP for Lawyers certification process. In this context, it is obvious why lawyers have rejected this new certification process, as it outlines no sanctions and has merely ended up causing uproar,” Mr. Purba concluded.

 
(rs/sp)
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info