The Draft Bill on Tax Amnesty was thrust into the spotlight once more during a hearing held by Commission IX of the House of Representatives (House) on Monday, 25 April 2016. During the hearing, Agus Dermawan Wintarto Martowadojo, the Governor of Bank of Indonesia (BI), underlined the important role that the proposed tax amnesty would play in the development of the financial sector.
According to Mr. Martowardojo, any funds which are ultimately collected through the tax-amnesty mechanism have the potential to increase state revenue derived from the taxation sector and can ultimately be channeled into investment within Indonesia. Moreover, any improvements made to the tax-administration system will eventually increase the country’s tax base.
Mr. Martowardojo further explained that the underlying thinking behind the tax amnesty was a reflection of the country’s development goals, including the development of the financial sector, which has been delegated to BI. Mr. Martowardojo also asserted that tax amnesties were common practice in many countries around the world and that countries such as India, Ireland, and Italy had been relatively successful in their implementation of tax-amnesty policies during the 2009 and 2015 period.
“In essence, the formulation of a Tax-Amnesty Law should enable companies or individuals who usually evade their income-tax obligations to enjoy the benefits of economic development,” asserted Mr. Martowardojo.
The proposed tax amnesty will quash any sanctions which would have been levied upon taxpayers who have been avoiding their obligations to report and pay tax. The tax amnesty will instead encourage tax offenders to report their various income and financial assets to the government.
During his statement at the recent hearing, Mr. Martowardojo revealed what he believes to be the keys to a successful implementation of the tax-amnesty policy. Firstly, any tax amnesty should be designed as a foundation upon which a new taxation system can be established via a process of tax reform. According to Mr. Martowardojo, the establishment of any new taxation system should first be preceded by a tax amnesty. Secondly, the Directorate General of Tax should already be in possession of accurate data prior to the effective implementation of any tax amnesty, as well as put together an effective and solid administration system capable of accurately overseeing the various taxpayers eligible to enjoy a tax amnesty.
Thirdly, there should be a definitive and binding implementation mechanism applicable to all taxpayers who decide to apply for tax amnesty. Fourthly, any tax amnesty should be able to be implemented at a moment’s notice, stretching up to a maximum period of one year. This measure should also be accompanied by improvements to the auditing regime, as well as the imposition of harsh sanctions upon any taxpayers who refuse to make use of the tax amnesty. And finally, there must be a strict law-enforcement mechanism which can be employed as a last resort.
In addition, any proposed tax amnesty should only be implemented once without any possibility of a second chance for tax evaders. This measure should ensure the effectiveness of a tax-amnesty policy, as any such policy would surely be compromised if it was implemented too often by separate government institutions. This is primarily because law-abiding taxpayers who meet their tax obligations in accordance with all of the prevailing laws and regulations would deem the whole exercise to be unfair. Indeed, if law-abiding taxpayers are subject to sanctions should they fail to fulfill their obligations while tax offenders, in contrast, are able to enjoy a tax amnesty, then the policy could ultimately run into serious problems.
“Moreover, we [BI] also understand that it is difficult for any tax-amnesty process to bring in funds which are the result of corruption, money laundering, and narcotics trading, unless the underlying crimes through which such funds were generated are also nullified. It is important therefore that relevant government institutions should be willing to drop cases involving corruption, money laundering, and narcotics trading, so that a greater amount of funds can be collected under through a tax-amnesty program,” asserted Mr.Wartomardojo.
And finally, Mr. Martowardojo expressed his belief that legal certainty would end up playing a vital role in the implementation of any tax-amnesty policy, as such certainty will ultimately reflect upon the government’s credibility, and affect capital flows both into and out of Indonesia.
“A tax amnesty is clearly not an independent undertaking which has no relation to other macroeconomic policies. Indeed, such a policy must conform consistently to the country’s macroeconomic regulations,” concluded Mr. Wartomardojo.
Also commenting upon the issue, lawmaker Johnny G. Plate (Commission XI) pledged his support for the government’s policy. However, Mr. Plate also suggested that the government should ensure that the country’s taxation system is both solid and fit for purpose, and that this should include strengthening the implementation of various regulations in the tax-revenue sector.
“Without this [the establishment of implementing regulations], the Draft Bill will ultimately be hampered by weak law-enforcement mechanisms.”
Eva Kusuma Sundari, also a Commission XI lawmaker, asserted that the government should not only focus its energies upon issues of liquidity, but should also be looking to make systemic improvements. According to Mrs. Sundari, banks and the Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) must ensure that taxpayers meet their tax obligations on a long-term basis.
“We need to think about the kinds of systemic transformations which will be necessary in order to implement a successful tax-amnesty policy which looks to the future. If the Draft Bill passes into law without significant structural reforms being implemented, then a huge opportunity will have been missed,” Mrs. Sundari concluded.
The Draft Bill on Tax Amnesty was thrust into the spotlight once more during a hearing held by Commission IX of the House of Representatives (House) on Monday, 25 April 2016. During the hearing, Agus Dermawan Wintarto Martowadojo, the Governor of Bank of Indonesia (BI), underlined the important role that the proposed tax amnesty would play in the development of the financial sector.
According to Mr. Martowardojo, any funds which are ultimately collected through the tax-amnesty mechanism have the potential to increase state revenue derived from the taxation sector and can ultimately be channeled into investment within Indonesia. Moreover, any improvements made to the tax-administration system will eventually increase the country’s tax base.
Mr. Martowardojo further explained that the underlying thinking behind the tax amnesty was a reflection of the country’s development goals, including the development of the financial sector, which has been delegated to BI. Mr. Martowardojo also asserted that tax amnesties were common practice in many countries around the world and that countries such as India, Ireland, and Italy had been relatively successful in their implementation of tax-amnesty policies during the 2009 and 2015 period.
“In essence, the formulation of a Tax-Amnesty Law should enable companies or individuals who usually evade their income-tax obligations to enjoy the benefits of economic development,” asserted Mr. Martowardojo.
The proposed tax amnesty will quash any sanctions which would have been levied upon taxpayers who have been avoiding their obligations to report and pay tax. The tax amnesty will instead encourage tax offenders to report their various income and financial assets to the government.
During his statement at the recent hearing, Mr. Martowardojo revealed what he believes to be the keys to a successful implementation of the tax-amnesty policy. Firstly, any tax amnesty should be designed as a foundation upon which a new taxation system can be established via a process of tax reform. According to Mr. Martowardojo, the establishment of any new taxation system should first be preceded by a tax amnesty. Secondly, the Directorate General of Tax should already be in possession of accurate data prior to the effective implementation of any tax amnesty, as well as put together an effective and solid administration system capable of accurately overseeing the various taxpayers eligible to enjoy a tax amnesty.
Thirdly, there should be a definitive and binding implementation mechanism applicable to all taxpayers who decide to apply for tax amnesty. Fourthly, any tax amnesty should be able to be implemented at a moment’s notice, stretching up to a maximum period of one year. This measure should also be accompanied by improvements to the auditing regime, as well as the imposition of harsh sanctions upon any taxpayers who refuse to make use of the tax amnesty. And finally, there must be a strict law-enforcement mechanism which can be employed as a last resort.
In addition, any proposed tax amnesty should only be implemented once without any possibility of a second chance for tax evaders. This measure should ensure the effectiveness of a tax-amnesty policy, as any such policy would surely be compromised if it was implemented too often by separate government institutions. This is primarily because law-abiding taxpayers who meet their tax obligations in accordance with all of the prevailing laws and regulations would deem the whole exercise to be unfair. Indeed, if law-abiding taxpayers are subject to sanctions should they fail to fulfill their obligations while tax offenders, in contrast, are able to enjoy a tax amnesty, then the policy could ultimately run into serious problems.
“Moreover, we [BI] also understand that it is difficult for any tax-amnesty process to bring in funds which are the result of corruption, money laundering, and narcotics trading, unless the underlying crimes through which such funds were generated are also nullified. It is important therefore that relevant government institutions should be willing to drop cases involving corruption, money laundering, and narcotics trading, so that a greater amount of funds can be collected under through a tax-amnesty program,” asserted Mr.Wartomardojo.
And finally, Mr. Martowardojo expressed his belief that legal certainty would end up playing a vital role in the implementation of any tax-amnesty policy, as such certainty will ultimately reflect upon the government’s credibility, and affect capital flows both into and out of Indonesia.
“A tax amnesty is clearly not an independent undertaking which has no relation to other macroeconomic policies. Indeed, such a policy must conform consistently to the country’s macroeconomic regulations,” concluded Mr. Wartomardojo.
Also commenting upon the issue, lawmaker Johnny G. Plate (Commission XI) pledged his support for the government’s policy. However, Mr. Plate also suggested that the government should ensure that the country’s taxation system is both solid and fit for purpose, and that this should include strengthening the implementation of various regulations in the tax-revenue sector.
“Without this [the establishment of implementing regulations], the Draft Bill will ultimately be hampered by weak law-enforcement mechanisms.”
Eva Kusuma Sundari, also a Commission XI lawmaker, asserted that the government should not only focus its energies upon issues of liquidity, but should also be looking to make systemic improvements. According to Mrs. Sundari, banks and the Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) must ensure that taxpayers meet their tax obligations on a long-term basis.
“We need to think about the kinds of systemic transformations which will be necessary in order to implement a successful tax-amnesty policy which looks to the future. If the Draft Bill passes into law without significant structural reforms being implemented, then a huge opportunity will have been missed,” Mrs. Sundari concluded.