Foreign Citizens Living in Indonesia Struggle to Obtain Mortgages


Marcell Sihombing, Fitri N. Heriani

ojk

Foreigners in Indonesia. Photo by: RES

The issuance of Government Regulation No. 103 of 2015on the Ownership of Residential Property by Foreign Citizens Domiciled in Indonesia (2015 Regulation) clearly stipulates that foreign citizens are allowed to own property in Indonesia under right-to-use (hak pakai) land titles. Moreover, the 2015 Regulation also allows foreign citizens to take possession of houses (rumah tapak) or apartment units for periods of decades. 

Unfortunately however, the banking sector is showing an ongoing reluctance to finance the construction of residences for foreign citizens under the right-to-use land title. This particular issue was discussed during a recent seminar titled How the Implementation of Government Regulation No. 103 of 2015 Affects the Development of the Indonesian Property Market, which was held on Thursday, 18 February 2016. The event, which was jointly organized by the Land Study and Consultation Forum (FK2P) and Trisakti University’s Faculty of Law, aimed to shed a little light on whether right-to-use land titles are ultimately bankable or not, i.e. able to attract loans from banks.
 
Of high relevance here as regards this thorny issue is Article 4 of Law No. 4 of 1996 on Mortgages for Land and Land-Related Objects (Mortgage Law). Article 4 (1) of the Mortgage Law listed the various types land-titles open for mortgages (hak tanggungan), including freehold titles (hak milik), as well as right-to-exploit (hak guna usaha), and right-to-build (hak guna bangunan) titles. As regards right-to-use titles, Article 4 (1) stipulates that the right-to-use for state-owned lands must involve a registration process conducted according to prevailing laws, while ownership can be transferred to another party in order to secure a mortgage.
 
Based upon the above-mentioned stipulations set out in Article 4 (1) and (2) of the Mortgage Law, Arie Sukanti Hutagalung, a professor from the University of Indonesia’s Faculty of Law asserted that the right-to-use title can be used in order to secure mortgages. However, according to the prevailing laws and regulations, the object of a given right-to-use title must either encompass state-owned land or the right to manage (hak pengelolaan).
 
“However, no stipulations regarding the right-to-use over freehold titles are set out under any of the prevailing laws and regulations,” Mr. Hutagalung told hukumonline on Thursday, 18 February 2016.
 
Are Right-to-Use Titles Bankable?

It is currently common for residential projects built on land held under right-to-use titles to experience severe difficulties as regards obtaining bank loans. However, this doesn’t mean that such loans are prohibited. According to Imam Subarkah, Director of Bank Indonesia’s Legal Department, there are no prohibitions against banks granting loans to foreign parties. Indeed Bank Indonesia (BI) Regulation No. 17/14/PBI/2015 on Foreign Currencies against the Rupiah, specifically Article 15, part (d), makes this matter quite clear. Therefore, according to Mr. Subarkah, a right-to-use title may indeed be used in order to secure a mortgage.
 
However, Mr. Subarkah underlined the fact that each bank had its own policy regarding the acceptability of right-to-use titles for mortgages. The reason for this general reluctance is that banks are obliged to implement prudentiality principles whenever they grant loans or financing to their customers.
 
“Where loans are concerned, a bank holds discretionary power [regarding whether to accept right-to-use titles or not]. The prevailing laws indeed allow for such loans to be granted, but what about the risks? Many banks therefore turn down proposals relating to the utilization of right-to-use titles for mortgages, because they consider such loans to be too risky,” asserted Mr. Subarkah.
 
Chairul Basri Achmad, an expert in agrarian law, told hukumonline that he understands why banks so often refuse to finance residential projects for foreigners hoping to secure loans under right-to-use titles. According to Mr. Achmad, the primary problem here is the general perception and image of right-to-use titles that stems from provisions set out in the Core Agrarian Law (Undang-Undang Pokok Agraria - UUPA).
 
As an example, Mr. Achmad stated that right-to-use titles are usually not registered, which violates the Articles 19, 23, 32, and 38 of the UUPA. Moreover, right-to-use titles for land in direct possession of the government can only be transferred to other parties after approval from the relevant government officials has first been secured.
 
However, according to Minister of Agrarian Affairs Regulation No. 9 of 1965, which is also supported by Government Regulation No. 40 of 1996 on the Right-to-Exploit, Right-to-Build, and Right-to-Use Land, a right-to-use title must be registered and this registration must be proven through the possession of a relevant ownership certificate, as prescribed by Articles 19, 23, 32, and 38 of the UUPA. Moreover, such transfers of ownership no longer require that approval first be granted by a relevant government official, and in fact such provision is likely to be repealed altogether.
 
“The present validity periods for right-to-use titles are almost the same as the validity periods for the right-to-build, and also require the necessary ownership certificate owing to the mandatory registration provision. [The status of right-to-use titles] should thus be considered be the same as that of right-to-build titles,” asserted Mr. Achmad.
 
Mr. Achmad further admitted that not all banks understood these matters clearly, with the result that owners of right-to-use land titles are largely unable to secure loans or financing. “In order that banks no longer deny loans and mortgages to holders of right-to-use titles, BI should disseminate the necessary information throughout the banking sector through the issuance of a Circular Letter,” Mr. Achmad concluded.
 
(rfs/sp)

Marcell Sihombing, Fitri N. Heriani

ojk

Foreigners in Indonesia. Photo by: RES

The issuance of Government Regulation No. 103 of 2015on the Ownership of Residential Property by Foreign Citizens Domiciled in Indonesia (2015 Regulation) clearly stipulates that foreign citizens are allowed to own property in Indonesia under right-to-use (hak pakai) land titles. Moreover, the 2015 Regulation also allows foreign citizens to take possession of houses (rumah tapak) or apartment units for periods of decades. 

Unfortunately however, the banking sector is showing an ongoing reluctance to finance the construction of residences for foreign citizens under the right-to-use land title. This particular issue was discussed during a recent seminar titled How the Implementation of Government Regulation No. 103 of 2015 Affects the Development of the Indonesian Property Market, which was held on Thursday, 18 February 2016. The event, which was jointly organized by the Land Study and Consultation Forum (FK2P) and Trisakti University’s Faculty of Law, aimed to shed a little light on whether right-to-use land titles are ultimately bankable or not, i.e. able to attract loans from banks.
 
Of high relevance here as regards this thorny issue is Article 4 of Law No. 4 of 1996 on Mortgages for Land and Land-Related Objects (Mortgage Law). Article 4 (1) of the Mortgage Law listed the various types land-titles open for mortgages (hak tanggungan), including freehold titles (hak milik), as well as right-to-exploit (hak guna usaha), and right-to-build (hak guna bangunan) titles. As regards right-to-use titles, Article 4 (1) stipulates that the right-to-use for state-owned lands must involve a registration process conducted according to prevailing laws, while ownership can be transferred to another party in order to secure a mortgage.
 
Based upon the above-mentioned stipulations set out in Article 4 (1) and (2) of the Mortgage Law, Arie Sukanti Hutagalung, a professor from the University of Indonesia’s Faculty of Law asserted that the right-to-use title can be used in order to secure mortgages. However, according to the prevailing laws and regulations, the object of a given right-to-use title must either encompass state-owned land or the right to manage (hak pengelolaan).
 
“However, no stipulations regarding the right-to-use over freehold titles are set out under any of the prevailing laws and regulations,” Mr. Hutagalung told hukumonline on Thursday, 18 February 2016.
 
Are Right-to-Use Titles Bankable?

It is currently common for residential projects built on land held under right-to-use titles to experience severe difficulties as regards obtaining bank loans. However, this doesn’t mean that such loans are prohibited. According to Imam Subarkah, Director of Bank Indonesia’s Legal Department, there are no prohibitions against banks granting loans to foreign parties. Indeed Bank Indonesia (BI) Regulation No. 17/14/PBI/2015 on Foreign Currencies against the Rupiah, specifically Article 15, part (d), makes this matter quite clear. Therefore, according to Mr. Subarkah, a right-to-use title may indeed be used in order to secure a mortgage.
 
However, Mr. Subarkah underlined the fact that each bank had its own policy regarding the acceptability of right-to-use titles for mortgages. The reason for this general reluctance is that banks are obliged to implement prudentiality principles whenever they grant loans or financing to their customers.
 
“Where loans are concerned, a bank holds discretionary power [regarding whether to accept right-to-use titles or not]. The prevailing laws indeed allow for such loans to be granted, but what about the risks? Many banks therefore turn down proposals relating to the utilization of right-to-use titles for mortgages, because they consider such loans to be too risky,” asserted Mr. Subarkah.
 
Chairul Basri Achmad, an expert in agrarian law, told hukumonline that he understands why banks so often refuse to finance residential projects for foreigners hoping to secure loans under right-to-use titles. According to Mr. Achmad, the primary problem here is the general perception and image of right-to-use titles that stems from provisions set out in the Core Agrarian Law (Undang-Undang Pokok Agraria - UUPA).
 
As an example, Mr. Achmad stated that right-to-use titles are usually not registered, which violates the Articles 19, 23, 32, and 38 of the UUPA. Moreover, right-to-use titles for land in direct possession of the government can only be transferred to other parties after approval from the relevant government officials has first been secured.
 
However, according to Minister of Agrarian Affairs Regulation No. 9 of 1965, which is also supported by Government Regulation No. 40 of 1996 on the Right-to-Exploit, Right-to-Build, and Right-to-Use Land, a right-to-use title must be registered and this registration must be proven through the possession of a relevant ownership certificate, as prescribed by Articles 19, 23, 32, and 38 of the UUPA. Moreover, such transfers of ownership no longer require that approval first be granted by a relevant government official, and in fact such provision is likely to be repealed altogether.
 
“The present validity periods for right-to-use titles are almost the same as the validity periods for the right-to-build, and also require the necessary ownership certificate owing to the mandatory registration provision. [The status of right-to-use titles] should thus be considered be the same as that of right-to-build titles,” asserted Mr. Achmad.
 
Mr. Achmad further admitted that not all banks understood these matters clearly, with the result that owners of right-to-use land titles are largely unable to secure loans or financing. “In order that banks no longer deny loans and mortgages to holders of right-to-use titles, BI should disseminate the necessary information throughout the banking sector through the issuance of a Circular Letter,” Mr. Achmad concluded.
 
(rfs/sp)
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info