Competition Sharp and Legal Issues Relevant at National Rounds of Jessup Competition 2013

Andin Aditya Rahman

It was a mix of anticipation and intensity as some of Indonesia’s top law students, lawyers and professors gathered at Atma Jaya Catholic University last weekend for the 2013 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition.

The 12th Indonesian National Rounds were held between January 25 and 27, and brought fourteen teams together from universities across Indonesia to compete in what has come to be widely recognized as the world’s most prestigious law competition.

The University Indonesia team won this year, and will advance to the international rounds held in Washington D.C., the finals of which are judged by actual Judges from the International Court of Justice.

Although Universitas Indonesia was knocked out last year in the semi-finals, rivals showed consistency as Universitas Pelita Harapan again won 1st Runner Up, with Universitas Pahyarangan again clinching 2nd Runner Up.

Irene Mira, the National Administrator for the 2013 National Rounds, said that although this might be the lowest number of teams that entered the Indonesian National Rounds, the Indonesian Jessup teams have definitely improved every year, and the judges—many of which include Indonesia’s top lawyers—have seen continuous improvement year to year.

“During this year’s national rounds, they displayed their commitment, hard work, and excitement towards the event,” she told Hukumonline after the finals on Sunday (27/1).  And meanwhile, the quality of the competition keeps improving as the team’s intensity and preparation increases.

“As the committee, we are happy to see that.”

The Case
Although each year’s “moot court” case is technically “fictional,” the proceedings and memorandums closely mirror actual processes in the International Court of Justice, and each year’s case tends to have salient parallels with contemporary issues in international law.

This year was no exception.

This year’s case looked at the scenario of a state plagued and eventually submerged by extreme climate events, an issue troubling the Maldives, Tuvalu, Bangladesh, and perhaps even Indonesia.

At a legal level, the case addressed international law around climate change responsibility, displacement and immigration, sovereign debt, and state continuity.

This year’s Jessup Competition was titled Alfurna v. the State of Rutasia, “The Case Concerning the Alfurnan Migrants”. In short, Alfurna is—or was—a state that geographically comprised two low-lying islands that eventually disappeared.

The case concerned relations between Alfurna, the agro-centric island state, and Rutasia, a landed industrialized state some 350 miles away. Rutasia, a developed economy and a heavy polluter, had lent significant sums to Alfurna to build sea walls and other protections for climate change.

The seawalls turned out to be poorly built by, incidentally, a Rutasian company: the walls were destroyed by time and extreme weather events, Alfurna went broke and could not repay Rutasia, and its land submerged into the sea.

In a scenario that could soon be all too real, Alfurna’s population migrated largely to another island, which it leased from a neighboring country. A major question was thus whether the Alfurnan state could continue as a legal entity, given the loss of its original territory.

Another question related to sovereign debt: Rutasia decided to seize Alfurnan assets to repay the latter’s debts, and decided Alfurna was no longer a state and thus its appeals to international courts and organizations was illegitimate.

Yet the most heated debate centered upon issues of internal displacement and migration. What legal protections are to be afforded to migrants caused by climate change. Indeed, while most Alfurnans were able to re-settle together on a leased neighboring island, 2,978 Alfurnans found themselves in Rutasia as “refugees”—or were they?

Could the definition of “refugee” apply—with all its legal implications—in cases of internal displacement caused by climate change? Or does the “refugee” label—as loosely defined by the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees—merely include, basically, ‘distinct social groups persecuted in and thus unable to return to their home state’?

Indeed, the protections afforded to climate migrants by Rutasia ended up being a focal point of contention, suggesting that this is also a significant area of international law to be articulated and debated in coming years.

And that debate may not be far off for Indonesia.

lbertus Andhika, Vice National Administrator at this year’s National Rounds, noted to Hukumonline that there were many parallels with Indonesia, given that it is a climate-responsive archipelago state.

“We are now facing climate change where the level of water is increasing. Indonesia could lose some of its land.”

Andhika left an optimistic note, however, saying this was an excellent opportunity for Indonesian students to explore emerging, relevant climate change issues in international law, and that “…maybe in the future they can be an advisors to this country, to make this country a better place.”

Complements All Around from Judges of the Finals
Rather auspiciously, a member of Indonesia’s first team to compete in the Jessup International Rounds in 2001 came back as the President Judge at this year’s final rounds. Adhyanti S. Wirajuda, now a senior official with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told Hukumonline that since she competed, she has noticed constant improvement over the years, and that this year’s winners and future international contestants were “…better than my year.”

Another Judge, Jaikanth Shankar, Associate Director at Drew & Napier LLP, told Hukumonline that he had come up against the Indonesian Jessup team when participating in the International Rounds of the 2004 Jessup Competition. He too noticed that the Indonesian Jessup teams have significantly sharpened their skills over the years.

Finals Judge Ramesh Selvaraj, a Partner at Allen & Gledhill LLP, highlighted as well that the Jessup Competition raises awareness of critical issues in international law, with contestants developing valuable expertise on current issues and contexts.

Pascal A. Bourgeois, a recent Juris Doctor graduate from the University of Houston, said that although this was his first time judging the Indonesian National Rounds, “the contestants are superbly skilled,” and indeed, this year’s case highlights a problem in international law that does not have a procedure or convention yet formulated to address it.

Jason Chan Tai-Hui, a Partner at Allen & Gledhill LLP, affirmed that “The value of this competition is that it highlights a problem in international law and brings people together to discuss a problem, and debate.”

He continued to state that at the end of the competition, those people will still be friends, and that “…some of these relations last long after the meeting.”

The Results
Pahrayangan University team won 2nd Runner Up. Brinanda Lidwina Kaliska, Captain of the Pahrayangan University team, was pleased with her team’s performance.

“Compared to last year, we got the same position; second runner up,” she told Hukumonline.

While last year they won the Best Memorial award, Brinanda was happy that “this year we won Best Oralist, which is a pretty good achievement,”

She encouraged every law student in Indonesia to compete in the Jessup Competition, not only to pursue English speaking skills, but also to improve general knowledge and logical thinking, and to establish networks with law students throughout Indonesia.

Pelita Harapan University team won 1st Runner up. Roselyn Prima Winata, Captain of the Pelita Harapan University team, was satisfied “…because for me, it’s a victory in its own way.” She noted that the team had done its research, and was recognized for the Best Memorial award this year.

“The team worked pretty hard to get the best memorial award,” she added.

The University of Indonesia team will advance to the International Rounds in March to represent Indonesia.  

Theodore Amarenda, a member of the University of Indonesia team, said that they were grateful to be proclaimed champions, and highlighted that it was truly a team effort.

“We worked really hard for the last five to six months together as a team, and this is really a team effort that paid off,” he stated.

He continued to state the most valuable lesson from this competition is learning to be disciplined in achieving goals.

“And work as a team, that’s the most important thing,” he emphasized.

(eli)

Andin Aditya Rahman

It was a mix of anticipation and intensity as some of Indonesia’s top law students, lawyers and professors gathered at Atma Jaya Catholic University last weekend for the 2013 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition.

The 12th Indonesian National Rounds were held between January 25 and 27, and brought fourteen teams together from universities across Indonesia to compete in what has come to be widely recognized as the world’s most prestigious law competition.

The University Indonesia team won this year, and will advance to the international rounds held in Washington D.C., the finals of which are judged by actual Judges from the International Court of Justice.

Although Universitas Indonesia was knocked out last year in the semi-finals, rivals showed consistency as Universitas Pelita Harapan again won 1st Runner Up, with Universitas Pahyarangan again clinching 2nd Runner Up.

Irene Mira, the National Administrator for the 2013 National Rounds, said that although this might be the lowest number of teams that entered the Indonesian National Rounds, the Indonesian Jessup teams have definitely improved every year, and the judges—many of which include Indonesia’s top lawyers—have seen continuous improvement year to year.

“During this year’s national rounds, they displayed their commitment, hard work, and excitement towards the event,” she told Hukumonline after the finals on Sunday (27/1).  And meanwhile, the quality of the competition keeps improving as the team’s intensity and preparation increases.

“As the committee, we are happy to see that.”

The Case
Although each year’s “moot court” case is technically “fictional,” the proceedings and memorandums closely mirror actual processes in the International Court of Justice, and each year’s case tends to have salient parallels with contemporary issues in international law.

This year was no exception.

This year’s case looked at the scenario of a state plagued and eventually submerged by extreme climate events, an issue troubling the Maldives, Tuvalu, Bangladesh, and perhaps even Indonesia.

At a legal level, the case addressed international law around climate change responsibility, displacement and immigration, sovereign debt, and state continuity.

This year’s Jessup Competition was titled Alfurna v. the State of Rutasia, “The Case Concerning the Alfurnan Migrants”. In short, Alfurna is—or was—a state that geographically comprised two low-lying islands that eventually disappeared.

The case concerned relations between Alfurna, the agro-centric island state, and Rutasia, a landed industrialized state some 350 miles away. Rutasia, a developed economy and a heavy polluter, had lent significant sums to Alfurna to build sea walls and other protections for climate change.

The seawalls turned out to be poorly built by, incidentally, a Rutasian company: the walls were destroyed by time and extreme weather events, Alfurna went broke and could not repay Rutasia, and its land submerged into the sea.

In a scenario that could soon be all too real, Alfurna’s population migrated largely to another island, which it leased from a neighboring country. A major question was thus whether the Alfurnan state could continue as a legal entity, given the loss of its original territory.

Another question related to sovereign debt: Rutasia decided to seize Alfurnan assets to repay the latter’s debts, and decided Alfurna was no longer a state and thus its appeals to international courts and organizations was illegitimate.

Yet the most heated debate centered upon issues of internal displacement and migration. What legal protections are to be afforded to migrants caused by climate change. Indeed, while most Alfurnans were able to re-settle together on a leased neighboring island, 2,978 Alfurnans found themselves in Rutasia as “refugees”—or were they?

Could the definition of “refugee” apply—with all its legal implications—in cases of internal displacement caused by climate change? Or does the “refugee” label—as loosely defined by the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees—merely include, basically, ‘distinct social groups persecuted in and thus unable to return to their home state’?

Indeed, the protections afforded to climate migrants by Rutasia ended up being a focal point of contention, suggesting that this is also a significant area of international law to be articulated and debated in coming years.

And that debate may not be far off for Indonesia.

lbertus Andhika, Vice National Administrator at this year’s National Rounds, noted to Hukumonline that there were many parallels with Indonesia, given that it is a climate-responsive archipelago state.

“We are now facing climate change where the level of water is increasing. Indonesia could lose some of its land.”

Andhika left an optimistic note, however, saying this was an excellent opportunity for Indonesian students to explore emerging, relevant climate change issues in international law, and that “…maybe in the future they can be an advisors to this country, to make this country a better place.”

Complements All Around from Judges of the Finals
Rather auspiciously, a member of Indonesia’s first team to compete in the Jessup International Rounds in 2001 came back as the President Judge at this year’s final rounds. Adhyanti S. Wirajuda, now a senior official with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told Hukumonline that since she competed, she has noticed constant improvement over the years, and that this year’s winners and future international contestants were “…better than my year.”

Another Judge, Jaikanth Shankar, Associate Director at Drew & Napier LLP, told Hukumonline that he had come up against the Indonesian Jessup team when participating in the International Rounds of the 2004 Jessup Competition. He too noticed that the Indonesian Jessup teams have significantly sharpened their skills over the years.

Finals Judge Ramesh Selvaraj, a Partner at Allen & Gledhill LLP, highlighted as well that the Jessup Competition raises awareness of critical issues in international law, with contestants developing valuable expertise on current issues and contexts.

Pascal A. Bourgeois, a recent Juris Doctor graduate from the University of Houston, said that although this was his first time judging the Indonesian National Rounds, “the contestants are superbly skilled,” and indeed, this year’s case highlights a problem in international law that does not have a procedure or convention yet formulated to address it.

Jason Chan Tai-Hui, a Partner at Allen & Gledhill LLP, affirmed that “The value of this competition is that it highlights a problem in international law and brings people together to discuss a problem, and debate.”

He continued to state that at the end of the competition, those people will still be friends, and that “…some of these relations last long after the meeting.”

The Results
Pahrayangan University team won 2nd Runner Up. Brinanda Lidwina Kaliska, Captain of the Pahrayangan University team, was pleased with her team’s performance.

“Compared to last year, we got the same position; second runner up,” she told Hukumonline.

While last year they won the Best Memorial award, Brinanda was happy that “this year we won Best Oralist, which is a pretty good achievement,”

She encouraged every law student in Indonesia to compete in the Jessup Competition, not only to pursue English speaking skills, but also to improve general knowledge and logical thinking, and to establish networks with law students throughout Indonesia.

Pelita Harapan University team won 1st Runner up. Roselyn Prima Winata, Captain of the Pelita Harapan University team, was satisfied “…because for me, it’s a victory in its own way.” She noted that the team had done its research, and was recognized for the Best Memorial award this year.

“The team worked pretty hard to get the best memorial award,” she added.

The University of Indonesia team will advance to the International Rounds in March to represent Indonesia.  

Theodore Amarenda, a member of the University of Indonesia team, said that they were grateful to be proclaimed champions, and highlighted that it was truly a team effort.

“We worked really hard for the last five to six months together as a team, and this is really a team effort that paid off,” he stated.

He continued to state the most valuable lesson from this competition is learning to be disciplined in achieving goals.

“And work as a team, that’s the most important thing,” he emphasized.

(eli)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info