Overview
The Supreme Court's decision to overturn the verdict that it had upheld earlier in 2005 has been roundly criticized from a number of different directions, all interesting and all with some degree of merit. Nevertheless, there does not seem to be a clear-cut yes or no answer to the question of legal certainty.
The decision has been criticized for bringing law enforcement and the judiciary into disrepute, weakening Indonesia's image internationally, and highlighting in the almost 10 years since the fall of the authoritarian regime of the former President Soeharto, reformasi has been at best lip service to a greater ideal rather than a comprehensive and successful drive to a better more legally certain future.
......