Lion Air Loses Baggage Handling Lawsuit, but Escapes Paying Full Compensation Claims

Happy Rayna Stephany, Andin Aditya Rahman

The Central Jakarta District Court decided that Lion Air should pay IDR 4 million in compensation for having lost a passenger’s luggage—although the passenger claimed to have lost IDR 2.9 billion worth of goods.

The passenger, Umbu S. Samapaty, filed the lawsuit after Lion Air misplaced his luggage on a flight to Kupang, Eastern Nusa Tenggara.

The judges decided that Lion Air was negligent and should pay compensation; however, they did not agree to nearly the sum that was being asked by the plaintiff.

Speaking about Lion Air at the Central Jakarta District Court (2/1), the Presiding Judge, Noer Ali, agreed that “The defendant was careless in performing their responsibilities.”

However, because the valuables were never reported or insured, the plaintiff apparently could not sufficiently prove that the contents of the luggage were worth billions of rupiah, despite presenting several witnesses.

The judges reasoned that, according to Article 6, paragraph 1 and 2 of Minister of Transport Regulation No. PM 77 of 2011 on Responsibilities of Airline Carriers, valuables contained in luggage must be reported and insured. If not, the carrier is not held responsible to compensate the total cost of losses if the luggage is misplaced.

The judges did however reason that, based on Article 5, paragraph 1 in the same regulation, airline companies must compensate at a rate of IDR 200,000 per kilogram in lost luggage, up to a maximum of IDR 4,000,000.

“The council declares that the defendant must pay the maximum compensation, which is 4 million rupiah,” stated Noer Ali.

Although Lion Air had tried to submit a defamation suit against Umbu, the judges rejected the claims on the basis that filing a case according to civil procedural law could not possibly be viewed as defamation.

After the judgement, when asked about appealing the decision or taking further action, both parties’ lawyer’s agreed that they must first consult with their clients before taking further steps.  

(eli)

Happy Rayna Stephany, Andin Aditya Rahman

The Central Jakarta District Court decided that Lion Air should pay IDR 4 million in compensation for having lost a passenger’s luggage—although the passenger claimed to have lost IDR 2.9 billion worth of goods.

The passenger, Umbu S. Samapaty, filed the lawsuit after Lion Air misplaced his luggage on a flight to Kupang, Eastern Nusa Tenggara.

The judges decided that Lion Air was negligent and should pay compensation; however, they did not agree to nearly the sum that was being asked by the plaintiff.

Speaking about Lion Air at the Central Jakarta District Court (2/1), the Presiding Judge, Noer Ali, agreed that “The defendant was careless in performing their responsibilities.”

However, because the valuables were never reported or insured, the plaintiff apparently could not sufficiently prove that the contents of the luggage were worth billions of rupiah, despite presenting several witnesses.

The judges reasoned that, according to Article 6, paragraph 1 and 2 of Minister of Transport Regulation No. PM 77 of 2011 on Responsibilities of Airline Carriers, valuables contained in luggage must be reported and insured. If not, the carrier is not held responsible to compensate the total cost of losses if the luggage is misplaced.

The judges did however reason that, based on Article 5, paragraph 1 in the same regulation, airline companies must compensate at a rate of IDR 200,000 per kilogram in lost luggage, up to a maximum of IDR 4,000,000.

“The council declares that the defendant must pay the maximum compensation, which is 4 million rupiah,” stated Noer Ali.

Although Lion Air had tried to submit a defamation suit against Umbu, the judges rejected the claims on the basis that filing a case according to civil procedural law could not possibly be viewed as defamation.

After the judgement, when asked about appealing the decision or taking further action, both parties’ lawyer’s agreed that they must first consult with their clients before taking further steps.  

(eli)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info