| Issue Number : 287

2012 Indonesian Laws in Review: We Find Laws In A Hopeless Place

Pirhot Nababan

OVERVIEW

Though the face of Indonesia changes daily, driven by the momentum of economic development and foreign investment, much continuity remains between years 2011 and 2012. GDP growth continues at upwards of 6%; last year being 6.5%, while this year was recorded at 6.3%. Indonesia continues to climb to the top of investment charts and remains a market saturated with opportunity.

Legal and political reforms have lagged behind. The enforcers of Indonesian law, as well as politicians and top decision-makers, remain in poor standing with the public. News was for example focused on a conflict between the Corruption Eradication Commission (“KPK”) and the National Police, regarding the alleged corruption regarding purchases of driving simulation machines, tests on which are used to issue licenses across the country. A remarkable code of conduct violation by Justice Achmad Yamanie also garnered much attention.

Much the same extends to the House of Representatives (“House”), the organization with the single-most number of KPK suspects. Yet the House remains at center stage for Indonesia’s legal developments, and has indeed continued to pass many new laws, producing changes for citizens, the economy, and the legal system.

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest (“ILD”) will review some headlining laws of 2012. Analysis will elaborate upon significant draft bills, the 2012 National Legislation Program (“Prolegnas”), 2012 Laws, and the 2013 National Legislation Program.

 

Finding Laws in a “Hopeless Place”?

While Hukumonline takes a broadly optimistic outlook on legal reform, this ILD sought to  highlight 2012 deep issues - including what appears to be near-systemic corruption - within the House, which absent intervention at times can seem a “Hopeless Place”.

In the KPK annual report, 16 members of the legislative body have been listed as corruption suspects; although that list includes regional legislative houses, the list is larger than that of the private sector (15 suspects), as well as that for the state bureaucracy (7 suspects).

Some in the legal community might joke that, if anything ever gains a semblance of broad consensus within the House, it is typically when seeking to reduce the KPK’s authority. Yet the laws generated within the House affect lawyers, businesspeople, investors, and indeed all stakeholders in Indonesia, and so, playing on a popular song from this last year, this ILD is titled “We Find Laws in a Hopeless Place”.

 

Types of Draft Bills

There are three types of draft bills under the National Legislation Program (Program Legislasi Nasional): draft bills prepared by ministries within the President’s executive branch of government (Government initiatives), draft bills prepared by the House of Representatives (House initiatives), and draft bills categorized as open for discussion.

Bills categorized as open for discussion include ratification of international treaties, the state budget, the establishment of new regions, enactment of government regulations in lieu of a law, and the impact of Constitutional Court Decisions. Additionally, this analysis categorizes three types of laws based on whether they are: newly introduced, amendments, or improvements that repeal and replace a previous law.

 

The 2012 National Legislation Program (Prolegnas)

According to Article 16 and 17 of Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Establishment of Laws and Regulations, plans to enact a new law must be included in a National Legislative Program, so defined as a priority list of bills that should be passed. It is drafted by both the House and executive branch of government.

According to House of Representatives Decree No. 08/DPR-RI/II/2011-2012 on The National Legislation Program - 2012 Prioritized Draft Bills, the 64 legislative priorities to be passed as bills in 2012 are as follows:

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Pirhot Nababan

OVERVIEW

Though the face of Indonesia changes daily, driven by the momentum of economic development and foreign investment, much continuity remains between years 2011 and 2012. GDP growth continues at upwards of 6%; last year being 6.5%, while this year was recorded at 6.3%. Indonesia continues to climb to the top of investment charts and remains a market saturated with opportunity.

Legal and political reforms have lagged behind. The enforcers of Indonesian law, as well as politicians and top decision-makers, remain in poor standing with the public. News was for example focused on a conflict between the Corruption Eradication Commission (“KPK”) and the National Police, regarding the alleged corruption regarding purchases of driving simulation machines, tests on which are used to issue licenses across the country. A remarkable code of conduct violation by Justice Achmad Yamanie also garnered much attention.

Much the same extends to the House of Representatives (“House”), the organization with the single-most number of KPK suspects. Yet the House remains at center stage for Indonesia’s legal developments, and has indeed continued to pass many new laws, producing changes for citizens, the economy, and the legal system.

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest (“ILD”) will review some headlining laws of 2012. Analysis will elaborate upon significant draft bills, the 2012 National Legislation Program (“Prolegnas”), 2012 Laws, and the 2013 National Legislation Program.

 

Finding Laws in a “Hopeless Place”?

While Hukumonline takes a broadly optimistic outlook on legal reform, this ILD sought to  highlight 2012 deep issues - including what appears to be near-systemic corruption - within the House, which absent intervention at times can seem a “Hopeless Place”.

In the KPK annual report, 16 members of the legislative body have been listed as corruption suspects; although that list includes regional legislative houses, the list is larger than that of the private sector (15 suspects), as well as that for the state bureaucracy (7 suspects).

Some in the legal community might joke that, if anything ever gains a semblance of broad consensus within the House, it is typically when seeking to reduce the KPK’s authority. Yet the laws generated within the House affect lawyers, businesspeople, investors, and indeed all stakeholders in Indonesia, and so, playing on a popular song from this last year, this ILD is titled “We Find Laws in a Hopeless Place”.

 

Types of Draft Bills

There are three types of draft bills under the National Legislation Program (Program Legislasi Nasional): draft bills prepared by ministries within the President’s executive branch of government (Government initiatives), draft bills prepared by the House of Representatives (House initiatives), and draft bills categorized as open for discussion.

Bills categorized as open for discussion include ratification of international treaties, the state budget, the establishment of new regions, enactment of government regulations in lieu of a law, and the impact of Constitutional Court Decisions. Additionally, this analysis categorizes three types of laws based on whether they are: newly introduced, amendments, or improvements that repeal and replace a previous law.

 

The 2012 National Legislation Program (Prolegnas)

According to Article 16 and 17 of Law No. 12 of 2011 on the Establishment of Laws and Regulations, plans to enact a new law must be included in a National Legislative Program, so defined as a priority list of bills that should be passed. It is drafted by both the House and executive branch of government.

According to House of Representatives Decree No. 08/DPR-RI/II/2011-2012 on The National Legislation Program - 2012 Prioritized Draft Bills, the 64 legislative priorities to be passed as bills in 2012 are as follows:

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info