Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
The Constitutional Court (MK) has rejected judicial review of Articles 7 (6a), 7 (1), 15A, and 15B of Law No. 4 of 2012 on the Amendment of Law No. 22 of 2011 on the 2012 State Budget (Amendment Law). MK’s decision was stipulated under Decision No. 43/PUU-X/2012 (Decision) and rendered on Thursday (13/12).
The request for review was filed by a group of labor unions, organizations, and activists that claimed that the Government should not have the ability to determine the fuel price based on the free market (see ILD on Subsidized Fuel Price Increase).
However, MK found that the procedure to determine subsidized fuel price under the 2012 State Budget Amendment Law is not based solely on the free market mechanism because that has not been discussed by the Government and the House of Representatives.
“[The procedure for determining fuel price] is in accordance with MK Decision No. 002/PUU-I/2003 dated 21 December 2004. In addition, there is no increase in Indonesian Crude Price within the six months period since the 2012 State Budget Amendment Law was issued, pursuant to Article 7 (6a),” Constitutional Judge Muhammad Alim explained.
Alim added that Article 7 (6a) was not reviewed because the Government’s authority to change subsidized fuel price has expired.
Ari Lazuardi, one of the applicants, explained that MK should have examined the request—which was submitted in May 2012—as soon as possible. “However, there is an impression that MK intentionally postponed the process so the articles in question would expire,” Ari stated.
Despite the fact that MK denied the request for review, he explained that the applicants respect MK’s decision. “We accept [the decision] because it is final and binding,” he concluded.
It should be noted that the Government and the House agreed on the articles in early April 2012, following massive protests held in Jakarta. The articles give the Government the authority to increase the subsidized fuel price, as long as the Indonesian Crude Price exceeds the price set in the State Budget by at least 15 percent for six months.
When the House passed the Amendment Law, many parties protested the aforementioned articles because MK had previously rendered a decision on the Oil and Gas Law in 2003, which revoked Article 28 (2) of Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas. The revoked article stated that fuel prices are determined by market mechanisms, so the price follows the world oil prices.
In that decision, MK held that Article 28 (2) of Oil and Gas Law contradicts Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution. Oil and gas, according to MK, are natural resources that have an enormous impact on many people and should be controlled by the state and not the free market.
(hot/jt)
Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
The Constitutional Court (MK) has rejected judicial review of Articles 7 (6a), 7 (1), 15A, and 15B of Law No. 4 of 2012 on the Amendment of Law No. 22 of 2011 on the 2012 State Budget (Amendment Law). MK’s decision was stipulated under Decision No. 43/PUU-X/2012 (Decision) and rendered on Thursday (13/12).
The request for review was filed by a group of labor unions, organizations, and activists that claimed that the Government should not have the ability to determine the fuel price based on the free market (see ILD on Subsidized Fuel Price Increase).
However, MK found that the procedure to determine subsidized fuel price under the 2012 State Budget Amendment Law is not based solely on the free market mechanism because that has not been discussed by the Government and the House of Representatives.
“[The procedure for determining fuel price] is in accordance with MK Decision No. 002/PUU-I/2003 dated 21 December 2004. In addition, there is no increase in Indonesian Crude Price within the six months period since the 2012 State Budget Amendment Law was issued, pursuant to Article 7 (6a),” Constitutional Judge Muhammad Alim explained.
Alim added that Article 7 (6a) was not reviewed because the Government’s authority to change subsidized fuel price has expired.
Ari Lazuardi, one of the applicants, explained that MK should have examined the request—which was submitted in May 2012—as soon as possible. “However, there is an impression that MK intentionally postponed the process so the articles in question would expire,” Ari stated.
Despite the fact that MK denied the request for review, he explained that the applicants respect MK’s decision. “We accept [the decision] because it is final and binding,” he concluded.
It should be noted that the Government and the House agreed on the articles in early April 2012, following massive protests held in Jakarta. The articles give the Government the authority to increase the subsidized fuel price, as long as the Indonesian Crude Price exceeds the price set in the State Budget by at least 15 percent for six months.
When the House passed the Amendment Law, many parties protested the aforementioned articles because MK had previously rendered a decision on the Oil and Gas Law in 2003, which revoked Article 28 (2) of Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas. The revoked article stated that fuel prices are determined by market mechanisms, so the price follows the world oil prices.
In that decision, MK held that Article 28 (2) of Oil and Gas Law contradicts Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution. Oil and gas, according to MK, are natural resources that have an enormous impact on many people and should be controlled by the state and not the free market.
(hot/jt)