Foreign Ownership of Indonesian Banks Won't Improve Efficiency in the Long Run

Fitri Novia Heriani / Mahinda Arkyasa

Although Indonesia allows 99% foreign ownership of Indonesian banks—as stipulated under the Banking Law—an economics expert said that this policy will not improve banks’ efficiency.

“Foreign ownership will only improve banks’ efficiency for a short term, but in the long run, such effect will diminish,” said Dony Abdul Chalid, lecturer from Universitas Indonesia faculty of economics to hukumonline, Tuesday (11/12).

However, Dony admitted that the 99% ownership policy has increased foreign investors’ interest in investing their funds in Indonesia. If the Government decided to change it, Dony said that foreign investors will become reluctant to invest in the Indonesian banking sector.

Fauzi Ichsan, a banking analyst, provides a different perspective. He stated that 99% foreign ownership of a bank will improve the bank’s efficiency because foreign parties are proven to have good corporate governance.

Fauzi explained that bad corporate governance and mismanagement within the banking industry, which was dominated by Indonesian conglomerates, has been proven to be the cause of the 1998 economic crisis.

“The [Indonesian conglomerates] used banks to fund their private businesses and, as a result, the 1998 monetary crisis occurred,” Fauzi said.

Despite their differing opinions, Dony and Fauzi agree that it is possible for the Government to reduce the portion of foreign ownership of banks.

In order to do so, the Government must be certain that local investors have the financial capability to make investments in the banking sector in addition to the ability to make long-term commitments.

“The question is whether the local investors are ready. Do they have adequate funds and are they able to make long-term commitment? These issues are important, considering that investment will involve huge capital and long-term commitment,” Fauzi concluded.

(hot/jt)

Fitri Novia Heriani / Mahinda Arkyasa

Although Indonesia allows 99% foreign ownership of Indonesian banks—as stipulated under the Banking Law—an economics expert said that this policy will not improve banks’ efficiency.

“Foreign ownership will only improve banks’ efficiency for a short term, but in the long run, such effect will diminish,” said Dony Abdul Chalid, lecturer from Universitas Indonesia faculty of economics to hukumonline, Tuesday (11/12).

However, Dony admitted that the 99% ownership policy has increased foreign investors’ interest in investing their funds in Indonesia. If the Government decided to change it, Dony said that foreign investors will become reluctant to invest in the Indonesian banking sector.

Fauzi Ichsan, a banking analyst, provides a different perspective. He stated that 99% foreign ownership of a bank will improve the bank’s efficiency because foreign parties are proven to have good corporate governance.

Fauzi explained that bad corporate governance and mismanagement within the banking industry, which was dominated by Indonesian conglomerates, has been proven to be the cause of the 1998 economic crisis.

“The [Indonesian conglomerates] used banks to fund their private businesses and, as a result, the 1998 monetary crisis occurred,” Fauzi said.

Despite their differing opinions, Dony and Fauzi agree that it is possible for the Government to reduce the portion of foreign ownership of banks.

In order to do so, the Government must be certain that local investors have the financial capability to make investments in the banking sector in addition to the ability to make long-term commitments.

“The question is whether the local investors are ready. Do they have adequate funds and are they able to make long-term commitment? These issues are important, considering that investment will involve huge capital and long-term commitment,” Fauzi concluded.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info