Ady Thea Dian Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa
On behalf of labor unions, Sahat Butar-Butar, the labor representative for the National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit), argued that the Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Regulation No. 19 of 2012 on Requirements for Outsourcing (Regulation) is discriminative.
During a seminar held by the Indonesian Worker Union Confederation (KSPI), Thursday (29/11), Sahat asserted that out of the 36 Articles in the Regulation, there are more articles that concern labor outsourcing as opposed to pemborongan orbusiness process outsourcing (BPO).
Sahat explained that the Regulation favors laborers working under a labor outsourcing company because it only provides limitations for labor outsourcing and not for BPO.
The Regulation strictly limits labor outsourcing to five business supporting activities, including janitor/cleaning services, catering services, security, oil and mining supporting activities, and labor transport services.
For BPO, the Regulation does not explicitly stipulate what types of activities may be outsourced. Instead, the Regulation stipulates several criteria to qualify what business process may be outsourced (see ILB No. 2038).
Sahat also claimed that the Regulation is not in accordance with the Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011 that states that the laborers’ rights must be transferred and protected if an outsourcing company is replaced by another outsourcing company.
He continued to argue that Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (Labor Law) does not stipulate any distinction between labor outsourcing and BPO. The Labor Law only states that core business functions cannot be outsourced.
“In [the Regulation], protection for laborers is even weaker,” he stated to hukumonline on Thursday (29/11).
Sahat further complained that only labor outsourcing companies are obliged to take the form of a limited liability company as a legal entity. Meanwhile, BPO companies are allowed to take other forms of legal entities.
He is concerned that this will be utilized as a loophole for outsourcing companies to outsmart the Regulation by converting to BPO companies.
Sahat argued that the Labor Law does not stipulate any obligations to distinguish the difference between a labor outsourcing company and a BPO company.
During the same event, Chairman of KSPI Sjaiful DP warned laborers to observe the Regulation closely, because some articles have the potential to harm laborers.
Sjaiful referred to Articles 3, 4, and 5 of the Regulation, which stipulate that business associations of each industrial sector are obliged to inform businesses of their respective industry regarding the entire production process of their industry, as well as categorize core business functions and supporting business functions.
The Regulation, according to Sjaiful, fails to elaborate how a business association must be established. The Regulation also fails to state which laws and regulations form the legal basis for establishing such organization. This, he said, may lead to multi interpretation among stakeholders.
Sjaiful is also concerned about the manpower and transmigration offices’ ability to evaluate the production process of each industry because of the lack of available officials.
Meanwhile, Hasanuddin Rachman, Chairman of Industrial Relation and Advocacy at the Indonesia Employers Association (Apindo), stated that Apindo is strongly against the Regulation. He argued that the Regulation violates Labor Law, especially on the limitation of business activities that can or cannot be outsourced.
Apindo’s Chairman Sofjan Wanandi confirmed that several outsourcing companies plan to file a judicial review request on the Regulation to the Supreme Court.
On a separate occasion, Sahat Sinurat, Director for Prevention and Settlement of Industrial Relation Disputes at the Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration, denied any allegations of discrimination between labor outsourcing companies’ workers and BPO companies’ workers.
He confirmed that legal protections for workers in both companies are similar and are in accordance with prevailing laws and regulations.
Regarding the forms of legal entities, Sinurat explained that the distinction was made to maximize labor outsourcing companies’ responsibility in protecting workers.
He stated that workers working in a BPO company should not be concerned about their rights because they will still be protected in accordance with the Manpower Law.
(hot/jt)
Ady Thea Dian Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa
On behalf of labor unions, Sahat Butar-Butar, the labor representative for the National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit), argued that the Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Regulation No. 19 of 2012 on Requirements for Outsourcing (Regulation) is discriminative.
During a seminar held by the Indonesian Worker Union Confederation (KSPI), Thursday (29/11), Sahat asserted that out of the 36 Articles in the Regulation, there are more articles that concern labor outsourcing as opposed to pemborongan orbusiness process outsourcing (BPO).
Sahat explained that the Regulation favors laborers working under a labor outsourcing company because it only provides limitations for labor outsourcing and not for BPO.
The Regulation strictly limits labor outsourcing to five business supporting activities, including janitor/cleaning services, catering services, security, oil and mining supporting activities, and labor transport services.
For BPO, the Regulation does not explicitly stipulate what types of activities may be outsourced. Instead, the Regulation stipulates several criteria to qualify what business process may be outsourced (see ILB No. 2038).
Sahat also claimed that the Regulation is not in accordance with the Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011 that states that the laborers’ rights must be transferred and protected if an outsourcing company is replaced by another outsourcing company.
He continued to argue that Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (Labor Law) does not stipulate any distinction between labor outsourcing and BPO. The Labor Law only states that core business functions cannot be outsourced.
“In [the Regulation], protection for laborers is even weaker,” he stated to hukumonline on Thursday (29/11).
Sahat further complained that only labor outsourcing companies are obliged to take the form of a limited liability company as a legal entity. Meanwhile, BPO companies are allowed to take other forms of legal entities.
He is concerned that this will be utilized as a loophole for outsourcing companies to outsmart the Regulation by converting to BPO companies.
Sahat argued that the Labor Law does not stipulate any obligations to distinguish the difference between a labor outsourcing company and a BPO company.
During the same event, Chairman of KSPI Sjaiful DP warned laborers to observe the Regulation closely, because some articles have the potential to harm laborers.
Sjaiful referred to Articles 3, 4, and 5 of the Regulation, which stipulate that business associations of each industrial sector are obliged to inform businesses of their respective industry regarding the entire production process of their industry, as well as categorize core business functions and supporting business functions.
The Regulation, according to Sjaiful, fails to elaborate how a business association must be established. The Regulation also fails to state which laws and regulations form the legal basis for establishing such organization. This, he said, may lead to multi interpretation among stakeholders.
Sjaiful is also concerned about the manpower and transmigration offices’ ability to evaluate the production process of each industry because of the lack of available officials.
Meanwhile, Hasanuddin Rachman, Chairman of Industrial Relation and Advocacy at the Indonesia Employers Association (Apindo), stated that Apindo is strongly against the Regulation. He argued that the Regulation violates Labor Law, especially on the limitation of business activities that can or cannot be outsourced.
Apindo’s Chairman Sofjan Wanandi confirmed that several outsourcing companies plan to file a judicial review request on the Regulation to the Supreme Court.
On a separate occasion, Sahat Sinurat, Director for Prevention and Settlement of Industrial Relation Disputes at the Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration, denied any allegations of discrimination between labor outsourcing companies’ workers and BPO companies’ workers.
He confirmed that legal protections for workers in both companies are similar and are in accordance with prevailing laws and regulations.
Regarding the forms of legal entities, Sinurat explained that the distinction was made to maximize labor outsourcing companies’ responsibility in protecting workers.
He stated that workers working in a BPO company should not be concerned about their rights because they will still be protected in accordance with the Manpower Law.
(hot/jt)