Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
During a National Legal Conference on Wednesday (31/10), Arifin P. Soeria Atmadja, a law professor at Universitas Indonesia, spoke on the issue of state finance definition.
He explained that while state finance is regulated under Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance (State Finance Law “or” Law), which derives directly from Article 23C of the 1945 Constitution, this law does not actually clarify state finance matters.
Instead, Arifin said that the Law stipulates provisions on drafting State and Regional Budget (APBD/APBN), as well as on the financial relationship between the Government and government/regional-owned enterprises (BUMN/BUMD), private companies, and other public financial agencies.
“It seems that lawmakers do not understand the difference between state finance, regional finance, and BUMN/BUMD finance. Even private company finance is regulated under the State Finance Law,” said Arifin.
He further stated that financial matters of institutions mentioned above (BUMN, BUMD, and private company) have been regulated under separate laws and regulations.
The law professor added that there are several articles in the State Finance Law that create problems for the state. One of these articles is Article 2 (i), which defines “state finance” as “other party’s assets that are acquired using Government facilities.”
“The Article suggests that the Government is liable for bankruptcy of a private party that utilizes a Government facility,” Arifin stated.
To make his point, Arifin brought up an example of the Karaha Bodas case. The case involved the Government halting a Geothermal Power Plant project carried out by PT Karaha Bodas Company (KBC) – an independent energy contractor that was the counterpart of National Oil and Gas Company (PT Pertamina). KBC filed a lawsuit against PT Pertamina and was awarded USD 261 million in damages.
Arifin elaborated that PT Pertamina is a BUMN, meaning that the company’s assets are not Government assets. However, because of Article 2 (i) of the Law, the Government is also liable for the awarded damages.
“Therefore, Article 2 (i) of State Finance Law needs to be revised immediately,” he urged.
Another problematic Article of the State Finance Law, according to Arifin, is Article 34. Article 34 stipulates that Ministers, Heads of Institutions, or Regents/Mayors that violate any policy on State/Regional Budget are subject to criminal sanctions in form of imprisonment or fines in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations.
Arifin explained that within the scope of the State Administrative Law (Law No. 5 of 1986), criminal sanctions cannot be imposed for the act of violating a policy.
In the same event, Hendar Ristriawan, Secretary General of the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (BPK), confirmed that the State Finance Law fails to provide a clear definition and distinction on state finance.
He added that state finance definition often refers to Article 23 (1) of the 1945 Constitution. In general, Article 23 (1) of the 1945 Constitution states that APBN, as a form of state finance administration, will be determined annually for the people’s welfare.
Based on Article 23 of the 1945 Constitution, Hendar asserted that only APBN can be considered as state finance. He argued that it excludes BUMN and BUMD assets and other government-established enterprises/agencies assets.
Meanwhile, State Finance Law defines state finance as any right and obligation that has monetary value, including both goods and money that can be declared as ‘state-owned’ for the purpose of implementing the state’s rights and obligations.
“The definition of state finance under the State Finance Law is just too broad,” he concluded.
(ds/jt)
Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
During a National Legal Conference on Wednesday (31/10), Arifin P. Soeria Atmadja, a law professor at Universitas Indonesia, spoke on the issue of state finance definition.
He explained that while state finance is regulated under Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance (State Finance Law “or” Law), which derives directly from Article 23C of the 1945 Constitution, this law does not actually clarify state finance matters.
Instead, Arifin said that the Law stipulates provisions on drafting State and Regional Budget (APBD/APBN), as well as on the financial relationship between the Government and government/regional-owned enterprises (BUMN/BUMD), private companies, and other public financial agencies.
“It seems that lawmakers do not understand the difference between state finance, regional finance, and BUMN/BUMD finance. Even private company finance is regulated under the State Finance Law,” said Arifin.
He further stated that financial matters of institutions mentioned above (BUMN, BUMD, and private company) have been regulated under separate laws and regulations.
The law professor added that there are several articles in the State Finance Law that create problems for the state. One of these articles is Article 2 (i), which defines “state finance” as “other party’s assets that are acquired using Government facilities.”
“The Article suggests that the Government is liable for bankruptcy of a private party that utilizes a Government facility,” Arifin stated.
To make his point, Arifin brought up an example of the Karaha Bodas case. The case involved the Government halting a Geothermal Power Plant project carried out by PT Karaha Bodas Company (KBC) – an independent energy contractor that was the counterpart of National Oil and Gas Company (PT Pertamina). KBC filed a lawsuit against PT Pertamina and was awarded USD 261 million in damages.
Arifin elaborated that PT Pertamina is a BUMN, meaning that the company’s assets are not Government assets. However, because of Article 2 (i) of the Law, the Government is also liable for the awarded damages.
“Therefore, Article 2 (i) of State Finance Law needs to be revised immediately,” he urged.
Another problematic Article of the State Finance Law, according to Arifin, is Article 34. Article 34 stipulates that Ministers, Heads of Institutions, or Regents/Mayors that violate any policy on State/Regional Budget are subject to criminal sanctions in form of imprisonment or fines in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations.
Arifin explained that within the scope of the State Administrative Law (Law No. 5 of 1986), criminal sanctions cannot be imposed for the act of violating a policy.
In the same event, Hendar Ristriawan, Secretary General of the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (BPK), confirmed that the State Finance Law fails to provide a clear definition and distinction on state finance.
He added that state finance definition often refers to Article 23 (1) of the 1945 Constitution. In general, Article 23 (1) of the 1945 Constitution states that APBN, as a form of state finance administration, will be determined annually for the people’s welfare.
Based on Article 23 of the 1945 Constitution, Hendar asserted that only APBN can be considered as state finance. He argued that it excludes BUMN and BUMD assets and other government-established enterprises/agencies assets.
Meanwhile, State Finance Law defines state finance as any right and obligation that has monetary value, including both goods and money that can be declared as ‘state-owned’ for the purpose of implementing the state’s rights and obligations.
“The definition of state finance under the State Finance Law is just too broad,” he concluded.
(ds/jt)