Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
During a National Legal Conference on Wednesday (31/10), Erman Radjagukguk, a law professor at Universitas Indonesia, spoke regarding the misconception that State-Owned Company (BUMN) assets are part of the Government treasury.
He explained that the Government owns BUMN only in terms of owning shares and does not directly own any BUMN assets.
Erman quoted Article 1 (2) of Law No. 19 of 2003 on State-Owned Companies (BUMN Law) that defines BUMN as a profitoriented company where the Government owns all or at least 51% of shares. However, this does not mean that the Government directly owns the assets.
He also referred to Article 11 of BUMN Law that stipulates that BUMN must comply with the limited liability company law regulated under Law No. 40 of 2007 (Company Law), which repeals and replaces Law No. 1 of 1995 on Limited Liability Company.
Meanwhile, based on Article 35 (2) of BUMN Law, BUMN that is formed as a public company (Perusahaan Umum – Perum) is declared to be a separate legal entity through the issuance of a Government Regulation, for example, Government Regulation No. 91 of 2000 on Jakarta Passenger Transportation Public Company.
After explaining why BUMN assets should not be considered as part of “state treasury,” he stated that this misconception also renders BUMN directors vulnerable to corruption charges.
He clarified that BUMN directors often face corruption charges when a BUMN suffers financial losses because these losses are also attributed to the Government losses.
Erman argues that even though Law No. 31 of 1999 on Corruption Eradication, as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001, explicitly states that all government-owned assets—separated or not—are a part of Government treasury, the Government still only owns BUMN shares and not the assets.
As a result of the fact that BUMN assets are not part of Government treasury, BUMN losses cannot be considered as losses to the Government treasury.
“The Government owns BUMN in terms of shares, not its assets,” said Erman.
However, he stated that the Government as a shareholder may still file a lawsuit against BUMN directors that commit crimes such as embezzlement, forging documents or financial statements, violating business-related laws, and other crimes.
Hambra, Head of the Legal Bureau of the Ministry of State-Owned Companies,confirmed that BUMN is currently facing several legal issues, including the Government treasury issue.
He pointed out that that there are some Government institutions that fight over control of BUMNs.
Hambra reminded the Government that BUMN is established based on the principle of limited liability. Consequently,BUMN assets and financials must be treated separately from its owners’ or shareholders’ assets.
“Government ownership of BUMN differs from BUMN ownership of its own assets. BUMN assets are not Government assets,” he explained.
If BUMN assets are considered to be Government assets, then the Government is responsible for every action carried out by BUMN, including losses, debts, and even bankruptcy.
(hot/jt)
Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
During a National Legal Conference on Wednesday (31/10), Erman Radjagukguk, a law professor at Universitas Indonesia, spoke regarding the misconception that State-Owned Company (BUMN) assets are part of the Government treasury.
He explained that the Government owns BUMN only in terms of owning shares and does not directly own any BUMN assets.
Erman quoted Article 1 (2) of Law No. 19 of 2003 on State-Owned Companies (BUMN Law) that defines BUMN as a profitoriented company where the Government owns all or at least 51% of shares. However, this does not mean that the Government directly owns the assets.
He also referred to Article 11 of BUMN Law that stipulates that BUMN must comply with the limited liability company law regulated under Law No. 40 of 2007 (Company Law), which repeals and replaces Law No. 1 of 1995 on Limited Liability Company.
Meanwhile, based on Article 35 (2) of BUMN Law, BUMN that is formed as a public company (Perusahaan Umum – Perum) is declared to be a separate legal entity through the issuance of a Government Regulation, for example, Government Regulation No. 91 of 2000 on Jakarta Passenger Transportation Public Company.
After explaining why BUMN assets should not be considered as part of “state treasury,” he stated that this misconception also renders BUMN directors vulnerable to corruption charges.
He clarified that BUMN directors often face corruption charges when a BUMN suffers financial losses because these losses are also attributed to the Government losses.
Erman argues that even though Law No. 31 of 1999 on Corruption Eradication, as amended by Law No. 20 of 2001, explicitly states that all government-owned assets—separated or not—are a part of Government treasury, the Government still only owns BUMN shares and not the assets.
As a result of the fact that BUMN assets are not part of Government treasury, BUMN losses cannot be considered as losses to the Government treasury.
“The Government owns BUMN in terms of shares, not its assets,” said Erman.
However, he stated that the Government as a shareholder may still file a lawsuit against BUMN directors that commit crimes such as embezzlement, forging documents or financial statements, violating business-related laws, and other crimes.
Hambra, Head of the Legal Bureau of the Ministry of State-Owned Companies,confirmed that BUMN is currently facing several legal issues, including the Government treasury issue.
He pointed out that that there are some Government institutions that fight over control of BUMNs.
Hambra reminded the Government that BUMN is established based on the principle of limited liability. Consequently,BUMN assets and financials must be treated separately from its owners’ or shareholders’ assets.
“Government ownership of BUMN differs from BUMN ownership of its own assets. BUMN assets are not Government assets,” he explained.
If BUMN assets are considered to be Government assets, then the Government is responsible for every action carried out by BUMN, including losses, debts, and even bankruptcy.
(hot/jt)