Businesses Respond Negatively to Outsourcing Limitation

Ady Thea Dian Achmad,Mahinda Arkyasa

Sofyan Wanandi, Chairman of Indonesian Business Association,said that outsourcing companies have complained about the policy to limit positions that may be outsourced.

The plan itself will be stipulated under a new Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Regulationand it will classify positions that may be outsourced into five categories, including janitors/cleaning service and security.

Outsourcing companies argue that this policy will contradict Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (Labor Law)and Sofyan confirmed that outsourcing companies will file for a request to review immediately after the Minister issues the regulation.

During a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (30/10), Sofyan admitted that many outsourcing companies do not comply with the prevailing laws and regulations.

However, he argued that outsourcing misconduct was caused by lack of supervision from the Government.

“The Government,” Sofyan said, “only focuses on labor unions’ arguments in drafting the new regulation.”

The Chairman further asserted that the Government should focus on reorganizing outsourcing implementation instead of limiting positions that may be outsourced.

“It is the defective outsourcing practices that must be addressed,” Sofyan explained.

He urged the Minister to discuss the new regulation draft in a National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit) in order to accommodate every stakeholder’s interests.

Endang Susilowati, member of Apindo’s representatives in the LKS Tripartit, explained that outsourcing has been regulated under Labor Law and other implementing regulations, including Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Decree No. 101/MEN/VI/2004 on Licensing Procedures for Outsourcing Companies and Minister of Manpower and Transmigration No. KEP.220/MEN/X/2004 on Requirements for Outsourcing.

Endang explained that based on the abovementioned laws and regulations, businesses have the right to determine positions that may be outsourced.

Similar to Sofyan, Endang stated that by limiting outsourcing, the new regulation will contradict Labor Law.

Therefore, Endang said that it is fair if outsourcing companies file for a judicial review at the Supreme Court immediately after the Minister issues it.

 

Djoko Heriyono, National Labor Union (Serikat Pekerja Nasional – SPN) representative in the LKS Tripartit, admitted that outsourcing cannot be removed, however, it can be improved via revision of outsourcing-related regulations.

Meanwhile, regarding labor supervision, Djoko asserted that labor supervisors and investigators should be centrally organized.

In response to the various statements, Sri Nurhaningsih, Director of Work Requirements and Discrimination Analysis at the Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration (Ministry), explained that the Ministry has taken several steps to organize outsourcing implementation.

One of those steps is issuing a letter to regional heads to list and evaluate outsourcing companies in their regions. 

Sri reported that manpower and transmigration offices in several regions have responded to the letter by applying a moratorium on outsourcing.

(hot/jt)

Ady Thea Dian Achmad,Mahinda Arkyasa

Sofyan Wanandi, Chairman of Indonesian Business Association,said that outsourcing companies have complained about the policy to limit positions that may be outsourced.

The plan itself will be stipulated under a new Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Regulationand it will classify positions that may be outsourced into five categories, including janitors/cleaning service and security.

Outsourcing companies argue that this policy will contradict Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor (Labor Law)and Sofyan confirmed that outsourcing companies will file for a request to review immediately after the Minister issues the regulation.

During a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (30/10), Sofyan admitted that many outsourcing companies do not comply with the prevailing laws and regulations.

However, he argued that outsourcing misconduct was caused by lack of supervision from the Government.

“The Government,” Sofyan said, “only focuses on labor unions’ arguments in drafting the new regulation.”

The Chairman further asserted that the Government should focus on reorganizing outsourcing implementation instead of limiting positions that may be outsourced.

“It is the defective outsourcing practices that must be addressed,” Sofyan explained.

He urged the Minister to discuss the new regulation draft in a National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit) in order to accommodate every stakeholder’s interests.

Endang Susilowati, member of Apindo’s representatives in the LKS Tripartit, explained that outsourcing has been regulated under Labor Law and other implementing regulations, including Minister of Manpower and Transmigration Decree No. 101/MEN/VI/2004 on Licensing Procedures for Outsourcing Companies and Minister of Manpower and Transmigration No. KEP.220/MEN/X/2004 on Requirements for Outsourcing.

Endang explained that based on the abovementioned laws and regulations, businesses have the right to determine positions that may be outsourced.

Similar to Sofyan, Endang stated that by limiting outsourcing, the new regulation will contradict Labor Law.

Therefore, Endang said that it is fair if outsourcing companies file for a judicial review at the Supreme Court immediately after the Minister issues it.

 

Djoko Heriyono, National Labor Union (Serikat Pekerja Nasional – SPN) representative in the LKS Tripartit, admitted that outsourcing cannot be removed, however, it can be improved via revision of outsourcing-related regulations.

Meanwhile, regarding labor supervision, Djoko asserted that labor supervisors and investigators should be centrally organized.

In response to the various statements, Sri Nurhaningsih, Director of Work Requirements and Discrimination Analysis at the Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration (Ministry), explained that the Ministry has taken several steps to organize outsourcing implementation.

One of those steps is issuing a letter to regional heads to list and evaluate outsourcing companies in their regions. 

Sri reported that manpower and transmigration offices in several regions have responded to the letter by applying a moratorium on outsourcing.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info