M AgusYozami, MahindaArkyasa
IsranNoor, Regent of East Kutai Regency of East Kalimantan, is certain that the Government will win the case against Churchill Mining Plc (Churchill) at the International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in Washington, DC.
“The dispute over the mining license in Kutai Timur Regency is merely a business issue between Churchill and PT Ridlatama [Indonesian company]. Therefore, it is incorrect for Churchill to sue the Government,” said Isran, on Wednesday (26/9).
Isran explained that East Kutai Regency Government revoked Ridlatama’s mining license, not Churchill’s. However, Churchill insisted on suing the Government because it claims to own 75% of shares in four Ridlatama’s subsidiaries, which include PT Ridlatama Mineral, PT Investama Resources, PT Ridlatama Trade Powerindo, and PT Investmine Nusa Persada.
Isran asserted that despite Churchill’s investment claim, this company was never registered as an investor at the East Kutai Mining Office. He explained that Churchill emerged in 2009, when it announced that it invested in the mining sector.
Churchill tried to overturn Isran’s decision in Indonesian courts for the last two years. The London-based company sued East Kutai Regent at the District Court, Court of Appeal, State Administrative Court, and the Supreme Court. The result, however, did not satisfy Churchill. For example, on 15 June 2012, the Supreme Court of Indonesia affirmed Isran’s decision to revoke Ridlatama’smining license in 2010.
Churchill’s defeat at the Supreme Court did not stop them from continuing to challenge Isran’s decision. After the decision from the Supreme Court, Churchill filed an international investment arbitration claim at ICSID on grounds of asset appropriation. Churchill also included President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board in the claim filed with ICSID.
Consequently, the President requested a report from a related institution on Indonesia’s preparation to face Churchill at ICSID. He expects that Indonesia will win the case and considers that it should be a lesson for the Government, especially for the Regent of the East Kutai Regency.
The President also stated that multinational corporations like Churchill must not be allowed to oppress developing countries, like Indonesia, with their international powers. Therefore, it is an obligation for State Officials to defend their country’s honor.
In regards to the process at ICSID, Isran asserted that the government will use Indonesian lawyers instead of foreign counsel. He said that Indonesian lawyers have better understanding of Indonesian laws and regulations. “Not only that, Indonesia lost three times at ICSID when using foreign lawyers as its counsel,” Isran asserted.
(antara/hot/jt)
M AgusYozami, MahindaArkyasa
IsranNoor, Regent of East Kutai Regency of East Kalimantan, is certain that the Government will win the case against Churchill Mining Plc (Churchill) at the International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in Washington, DC.
“The dispute over the mining license in Kutai Timur Regency is merely a business issue between Churchill and PT Ridlatama [Indonesian company]. Therefore, it is incorrect for Churchill to sue the Government,” said Isran, on Wednesday (26/9).
Isran explained that East Kutai Regency Government revoked Ridlatama’s mining license, not Churchill’s. However, Churchill insisted on suing the Government because it claims to own 75% of shares in four Ridlatama’s subsidiaries, which include PT Ridlatama Mineral, PT Investama Resources, PT Ridlatama Trade Powerindo, and PT Investmine Nusa Persada.
Isran asserted that despite Churchill’s investment claim, this company was never registered as an investor at the East Kutai Mining Office. He explained that Churchill emerged in 2009, when it announced that it invested in the mining sector.
Churchill tried to overturn Isran’s decision in Indonesian courts for the last two years. The London-based company sued East Kutai Regent at the District Court, Court of Appeal, State Administrative Court, and the Supreme Court. The result, however, did not satisfy Churchill. For example, on 15 June 2012, the Supreme Court of Indonesia affirmed Isran’s decision to revoke Ridlatama’smining license in 2010.
Churchill’s defeat at the Supreme Court did not stop them from continuing to challenge Isran’s decision. After the decision from the Supreme Court, Churchill filed an international investment arbitration claim at ICSID on grounds of asset appropriation. Churchill also included President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board in the claim filed with ICSID.
Consequently, the President requested a report from a related institution on Indonesia’s preparation to face Churchill at ICSID. He expects that Indonesia will win the case and considers that it should be a lesson for the Government, especially for the Regent of the East Kutai Regency.
The President also stated that multinational corporations like Churchill must not be allowed to oppress developing countries, like Indonesia, with their international powers. Therefore, it is an obligation for State Officials to defend their country’s honor.
In regards to the process at ICSID, Isran asserted that the government will use Indonesian lawyers instead of foreign counsel. He said that Indonesian lawyers have better understanding of Indonesian laws and regulations. “Not only that, Indonesia lost three times at ICSID when using foreign lawyers as its counsel,” Isran asserted.
(antara/hot/jt)