Telkomsel?s Attorney Says that Commercial Court Decision Was Flawed

Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa

PT Telkomsel’s (Telkomsel) attorney Ricardo Simanjuntak held a press conference, Friday (21/9), on Jakarta Commerical Court’s decision to declare Telkomsel as bankrupt. It should be noted that Telkomsel filed for cassation at the Supreme Court on that day as well.

Ricardo explained that the decision was seriously flawed because Commercial Court was only concerned with the purchase order (PO) agreement when establishing that there was a debt owed by Telkomsel to PT Prima Jaya Informatika (PT PJI) and that it ignored several material facts when rendering the bankruptcy decision.

Ricardo argued that it was incorrect for the Panel of Judges to use Article 1458 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPer) as the legal basis for confirming Telkomsel’s debt to PT PJI.

Article 1458 of KUHPer stipulates that “a purchase exists between parties to the agreement if there is a consensus over the goods and price, notwithstanding that the goods have not been rendered or that payment has not been made.”

In order to have a valid purchasing agreement, both parties have to reach a consensus, which is established under Article 1457 of KUHPer. Ricardo argued that Telkomsel never agreed to render goods (e.g special edition telephone credit vouchers) to PT PJI. Therefore, the consensus required under Article 1457 was never established.       

Furthermore, Ricardo said that Commercial Court ignored certain provisions in the agreement when examining the case. He said that based on the agreement, if PT PJI failed to carry out its obligations, Telkomsel preserved the rights to evaluate, apply restrictions, or even cancel the agreement.

 “The panel of judges considered selective statements and information that justified bankruptcy,” he stated.

On another note, even though Telkomsel has been declared bankrupt, Ricardo explained that the company will continue to operate. The only difference is that any activities conducted by the company, such as entering into an agreement or contract with a third party, will be supervised by an administrator (Kurator).

Asli Brahmana, Head of Corporate Secretary of Telkomsel Group, also hoped that Supreme Court will examine the case in a fair manner. He stated that Telkomsel is determined to provide the best service to its customers and investors.

“We will remain operational regardless of the current situation,” he said.

(ds/jt)

Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa

PT Telkomsel’s (Telkomsel) attorney Ricardo Simanjuntak held a press conference, Friday (21/9), on Jakarta Commerical Court’s decision to declare Telkomsel as bankrupt. It should be noted that Telkomsel filed for cassation at the Supreme Court on that day as well.

Ricardo explained that the decision was seriously flawed because Commercial Court was only concerned with the purchase order (PO) agreement when establishing that there was a debt owed by Telkomsel to PT Prima Jaya Informatika (PT PJI) and that it ignored several material facts when rendering the bankruptcy decision.

Ricardo argued that it was incorrect for the Panel of Judges to use Article 1458 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPer) as the legal basis for confirming Telkomsel’s debt to PT PJI.

Article 1458 of KUHPer stipulates that “a purchase exists between parties to the agreement if there is a consensus over the goods and price, notwithstanding that the goods have not been rendered or that payment has not been made.”

In order to have a valid purchasing agreement, both parties have to reach a consensus, which is established under Article 1457 of KUHPer. Ricardo argued that Telkomsel never agreed to render goods (e.g special edition telephone credit vouchers) to PT PJI. Therefore, the consensus required under Article 1457 was never established.       

Furthermore, Ricardo said that Commercial Court ignored certain provisions in the agreement when examining the case. He said that based on the agreement, if PT PJI failed to carry out its obligations, Telkomsel preserved the rights to evaluate, apply restrictions, or even cancel the agreement.

 “The panel of judges considered selective statements and information that justified bankruptcy,” he stated.

On another note, even though Telkomsel has been declared bankrupt, Ricardo explained that the company will continue to operate. The only difference is that any activities conducted by the company, such as entering into an agreement or contract with a third party, will be supervised by an administrator (Kurator).

Asli Brahmana, Head of Corporate Secretary of Telkomsel Group, also hoped that Supreme Court will examine the case in a fair manner. He stated that Telkomsel is determined to provide the best service to its customers and investors.

“We will remain operational regardless of the current situation,” he said.

(ds/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info