Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Umbu S.Samapaty, defendant in a lawsuit filed by Lion Air, is suspicious in regards to the amount of damages it demands. He stated that the amount does not make any sense. Umbu’s attorney Manuarang Manalu asserted that agrees with his client. “Really? IDR 3 billion for lawyer’s fees?” he asked after a court proceeding on Monday (10/9).
The case itself is part of a chain ofdisputes between Umbu and Lion Air. Prior to Lion Air’s lawsuit against Umbu, the latter sued PT Lion Mentari Airlines (owner of Lion Air) for negligence. Umbu argued that Lion Air caused the loss of his luggage duringone of the flights.
Umbu filed a lawuit against Lion Air inJune 2012 and claimed that the luggage contained his belongings worth IDR 2,9 billion. He demanded that Lion Air pays damages in the exact same amount.
Lion Air, felt that Umbu’s action embarrassed the airline, responded with a lawsuit filed on 3 September 2012, demanding Umbu to pay IDR 3 billion in lawyer’s fees and IDR 500 billionin immaterial damages for defamation.
The demand, according to Manuarang, is unreasonable because Indonesian legal system does not acknowledge lawyer’s fees as damages. Under the Indonesian legal system, he said, the defendant or plaintiff does not have to hire an attorney. Therefore, attorney’s fees should be imposed on those who acquire lawyer’s services.
In addition, Manuarang argued that Lion Air’spetition for immaterial damages is improper, unclear, and has no legal basis. He asserted that Lion Air must first prove that Umbu has committed defamation against the airline. Not only that, Manuarang emphasized that Lion Air is attempting to conceal the facts from Umbu’s lawsuit.
“[Lion Air] hoped that the court would grant its demand for IDR 500 billion in immaterial damages so the airline could purchase a new plane,” Manuarang stated.
Therefore, Manuarang argued that the court must reject Lion Air’s lawsuit based on the Supreme Court Decision No. 582.K/Sip/1973, dated 18 December 1975, which states that a lawsuit cannot be accepted if the petition is unclear.
On the other hand, Nusriwin, PT Lion Mentari Airlines’ attorney, rebutted Manuarang’s argument by stating that his client’s lawsuit was filed for tort, as regulated under Article 1365 of the Indonesian Civil Code, not defamation. Therefore, immaterial damages can be included in the demand.
“And we never claimed that the damages wouldbe used to buy an airplane,” Nusriwin asserted.
(hot/jt)
Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Umbu S.Samapaty, defendant in a lawsuit filed by Lion Air, is suspicious in regards to the amount of damages it demands. He stated that the amount does not make any sense. Umbu’s attorney Manuarang Manalu asserted that agrees with his client. “Really? IDR 3 billion for lawyer’s fees?” he asked after a court proceeding on Monday (10/9).
The case itself is part of a chain ofdisputes between Umbu and Lion Air. Prior to Lion Air’s lawsuit against Umbu, the latter sued PT Lion Mentari Airlines (owner of Lion Air) for negligence. Umbu argued that Lion Air caused the loss of his luggage duringone of the flights.
Umbu filed a lawuit against Lion Air inJune 2012 and claimed that the luggage contained his belongings worth IDR 2,9 billion. He demanded that Lion Air pays damages in the exact same amount.
Lion Air, felt that Umbu’s action embarrassed the airline, responded with a lawsuit filed on 3 September 2012, demanding Umbu to pay IDR 3 billion in lawyer’s fees and IDR 500 billionin immaterial damages for defamation.
The demand, according to Manuarang, is unreasonable because Indonesian legal system does not acknowledge lawyer’s fees as damages. Under the Indonesian legal system, he said, the defendant or plaintiff does not have to hire an attorney. Therefore, attorney’s fees should be imposed on those who acquire lawyer’s services.
In addition, Manuarang argued that Lion Air’spetition for immaterial damages is improper, unclear, and has no legal basis. He asserted that Lion Air must first prove that Umbu has committed defamation against the airline. Not only that, Manuarang emphasized that Lion Air is attempting to conceal the facts from Umbu’s lawsuit.
“[Lion Air] hoped that the court would grant its demand for IDR 500 billion in immaterial damages so the airline could purchase a new plane,” Manuarang stated.
Therefore, Manuarang argued that the court must reject Lion Air’s lawsuit based on the Supreme Court Decision No. 582.K/Sip/1973, dated 18 December 1975, which states that a lawsuit cannot be accepted if the petition is unclear.
On the other hand, Nusriwin, PT Lion Mentari Airlines’ attorney, rebutted Manuarang’s argument by stating that his client’s lawsuit was filed for tort, as regulated under Article 1365 of the Indonesian Civil Code, not defamation. Therefore, immaterial damages can be included in the demand.
“And we never claimed that the damages wouldbe used to buy an airplane,” Nusriwin asserted.
(hot/jt)