M Agus Yozami, Mahinda Arkyasa
In July 2012, Renaissance Capital Management Investment Pte. Ltd (“Renaissance”) won a lawsuit in South Jakarta District Court against Merrill Lynch Indonesia (“MLI”) to recover damages Renaissance owed in a Singapore court case filed by Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith (“MLPFS”). The District Court decision has been challenged by MLI in a petition for Case Review by the Supreme Court, based on the fact that MLI and Renaissance had no business relationship.
The legal circus began in 2008, when Prem Ramchand Harjani, owner and Director of Renaissance, ordered MLPFS to purchase 120 million shares of PT Triwitra Lestari through Merrill Lynch International Bank Ltd (“MLIB”). The shares were valued at USD 14.3 million.
At that time, Prem promised to pay MLPFS USD 14.3 million on 26 June 2008 in order to settle the transaction. However, neither Prem nor Renaissance transferred the funds on the agreed date.
As a result, in November 2008, MLPFS filed a lawsuit against Renaissance. In August 2010, the High Court of Singapore ruled that Renaissance owed payment to MLPFS, and Prem was convicted for fraud. The High Court ordered Renaissance and Prem to pay USD 9.4 million, plus interest, in damages to MLPFS.
When MLPFS filed the lawsuit against Renaissance in 2008, Prem countered with a lawsuit in the South Jakarta District Court against MLIB and MLI for tort and defamation. In 2009, the South Jakarta District Court ruled in favor of Prem. While the initial demand was for IDR 1 trillion, the Court ordered MLIB and MLI to pay Renaissance IDR 251 billion. Both the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court affirmed the decision.
Syamsul Maarif, one of the Justices at the Supreme Court, issued a dissenting opinion stating that MLI did not commit any act of tort or defamation against Renaissance.
Frans H. Winarta, attorney for MLI asserted that MLI was not involved when MLPFS sued Renaissance. “How could someone involved in a case against a foreign company in a foreign country file a lawsuit against an Indonesian company because it has a similar name as the foreign company,” he argued.
Based on the above, MLIB and MLI filed a request for review of the Supreme Court decision on 18 August 2012. The request for review was submitted along with new evidence regarding the case.
New evidence includes a recorded telephone conversation in which Prem acknowledged his debt to MLPFS. “We will continue to present new evidence to the Supreme Court in our pursuit to find justice,” Frans said.
Unfortunately, Hartono Tanuwidjaja, one of Prem’s attorneys, cannot be contacted for any comment regarding the case.
M Agus Yozami, Mahinda Arkyasa
In July 2012, Renaissance Capital Management Investment Pte. Ltd (“Renaissance”) won a lawsuit in South Jakarta District Court against Merrill Lynch Indonesia (“MLI”) to recover damages Renaissance owed in a Singapore court case filed by Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith (“MLPFS”). The District Court decision has been challenged by MLI in a petition for Case Review by the Supreme Court, based on the fact that MLI and Renaissance had no business relationship.
The legal circus began in 2008, when Prem Ramchand Harjani, owner and Director of Renaissance, ordered MLPFS to purchase 120 million shares of PT Triwitra Lestari through Merrill Lynch International Bank Ltd (“MLIB”). The shares were valued at USD 14.3 million.
At that time, Prem promised to pay MLPFS USD 14.3 million on 26 June 2008 in order to settle the transaction. However, neither Prem nor Renaissance transferred the funds on the agreed date.
As a result, in November 2008, MLPFS filed a lawsuit against Renaissance. In August 2010, the High Court of Singapore ruled that Renaissance owed payment to MLPFS, and Prem was convicted for fraud. The High Court ordered Renaissance and Prem to pay USD 9.4 million, plus interest, in damages to MLPFS.
When MLPFS filed the lawsuit against Renaissance in 2008, Prem countered with a lawsuit in the South Jakarta District Court against MLIB and MLI for tort and defamation. In 2009, the South Jakarta District Court ruled in favor of Prem. While the initial demand was for IDR 1 trillion, the Court ordered MLIB and MLI to pay Renaissance IDR 251 billion. Both the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court affirmed the decision.
Syamsul Maarif, one of the Justices at the Supreme Court, issued a dissenting opinion stating that MLI did not commit any act of tort or defamation against Renaissance.
Frans H. Winarta, attorney for MLI asserted that MLI was not involved when MLPFS sued Renaissance. “How could someone involved in a case against a foreign company in a foreign country file a lawsuit against an Indonesian company because it has a similar name as the foreign company,” he argued.
Based on the above, MLIB and MLI filed a request for review of the Supreme Court decision on 18 August 2012. The request for review was submitted along with new evidence regarding the case.
New evidence includes a recorded telephone conversation in which Prem acknowledged his debt to MLPFS. “We will continue to present new evidence to the Supreme Court in our pursuit to find justice,” Frans said.
Unfortunately, Hartono Tanuwidjaja, one of Prem’s attorneys, cannot be contacted for any comment regarding the case.