Ady Thea Dian Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa
On 4 September 2012 in Jakarta, the Industrial Relations Court (Pengadilan Hubungan Industrial – PHI) rendered a decision that orders Thomson Reuters Indonesia (Reuters) to pay IDR 90 million of severance payment to Maleachi Marinsib Palinggi, a Reuters photographer, who was laid off in February 2011 for the purpose of company efficiency. However, the amount will be reduced because Reuters already provided some monetary compensation to Maleachi, as well as some equipment.
Reuters argued that Maleachi is a freelance photographer and, as a result, he is not entitled to severance payment. In response, Maleachi’s attorney argued that Maleachi should be categorized as a permanent employee because he has been working for Reuters since October 2003.
The Judges Assembly (“Assembly”) rejected Reuters’ argument in favor of Maleachi’s. One of the reasons for the decision was the evidence that showed that Maleachi has been receiving monthly salary on top of the remuneration for the photographs published by Reuters.
Furthermore, Article 57 (1) of Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor(“Labor Law”) states that a fixed-term work contract must be made in a written form, while Article 57 (2) states that an employee is considered to be a permanent employee if there is no written fixed-term contract between the employer and the employee.
There was no written contract between Reuters and Maleachi. As a result, the Assembly found that Reuters violated Article 57 (1) and that Maleachi was a permanent employee.
In addition, based on Article 164 (3) of the Labor Law, the Assembly asserted that an employer must provide severance payment if a layoff was conducted for the purpose of improving efficiency.
Meanwhile, Reuters’ attorney Kenny Macallo refused to give any comment on the case.
(jt/hot)
Ady Thea Dian Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa
On 4 September 2012 in Jakarta, the Industrial Relations Court (Pengadilan Hubungan Industrial – PHI) rendered a decision that orders Thomson Reuters Indonesia (Reuters) to pay IDR 90 million of severance payment to Maleachi Marinsib Palinggi, a Reuters photographer, who was laid off in February 2011 for the purpose of company efficiency. However, the amount will be reduced because Reuters already provided some monetary compensation to Maleachi, as well as some equipment.
Reuters argued that Maleachi is a freelance photographer and, as a result, he is not entitled to severance payment. In response, Maleachi’s attorney argued that Maleachi should be categorized as a permanent employee because he has been working for Reuters since October 2003.
The Judges Assembly (“Assembly”) rejected Reuters’ argument in favor of Maleachi’s. One of the reasons for the decision was the evidence that showed that Maleachi has been receiving monthly salary on top of the remuneration for the photographs published by Reuters.
Furthermore, Article 57 (1) of Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor(“Labor Law”) states that a fixed-term work contract must be made in a written form, while Article 57 (2) states that an employee is considered to be a permanent employee if there is no written fixed-term contract between the employer and the employee.
There was no written contract between Reuters and Maleachi. As a result, the Assembly found that Reuters violated Article 57 (1) and that Maleachi was a permanent employee.
In addition, based on Article 164 (3) of the Labor Law, the Assembly asserted that an employer must provide severance payment if a layoff was conducted for the purpose of improving efficiency.
Meanwhile, Reuters’ attorney Kenny Macallo refused to give any comment on the case.
(jt/hot)