Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Tadjuddin Noersaid, the Chairman of the Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (“KPPU”), stated last month that there may be a cartelization of soybean prices. However, he failed to elaborate on his statement in a discussion with the Ministry of Trade and BULOG (a state-owned enterprise that manages the supply and the logistics of food).
In the discussion, Tadjuddin stated that such an implication must be proven, which is not an easy task. “We will re-evaluate if the cartelization of prices exists,” he said in Jakarta on Tuesday (14/8).
Tadjuddin explained that cartelization might be related to political aspects of the soybeans price increase. Under Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution and Article 51 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopoly Practices and Unfair Business Competition, the Government is allowed to intervene in order to prevent a price hike.
Meanwhile, Ardiansyah Parman, the Secretary General of the Ministry of Trade, stated that the price increased because of natural occurrences, such as the droughts in the United States (“US”) and some areas of Latin America. These droughts decreased the world’s soybean production by 11 percent.
He explained that since 2000, Indonesia, along with China, Mexico, and Japan, imported soybeans from the US. China imported 61,50 percent, while Mexico and Japan imported 8,74 percent and 5,24 percent, respectively. Indonesia came fourth with 5,11 percent of soybeans import, followed by Taiwan (3,57 percent) and Egypt (2,13 percent).
In addition, Ardiansyah explained that between 1993 and 2011, Indonesia’s soybean production has also been decreased. The decrease was noted mainly in Lampung (17,83%), West Sumatera (13,53%), and North Sumatera (10,60%).
The issue is that Indonesian farmers prefer to produce sugarcane, corn, and rice rather than soybeans, because these commodities generate more income. On top of that, there is a problem of land availability. Ardiansyah stated that “100 thousand hectares of farm land are converted to non-farm land every year.”
Furthermore, Ardiansyah mentioned that the soybeans price increase had previously occurred in 2008. At that time, the Government responded to the issue by applying an exemption on soybeans import duty. The Government also reduced the income tax for imported soybeans from 2,5 percent to 0,5 percent. Moreover, the Government awarded IDR 1.000 in subsidies for each kilogram of raw materials for making bean curds and soybean cakes (tempe) (Minister of Finance Regulation No. 1/PMK.011/2008 on Determination of Import Duty on Soy Beans Import).
As a result, Ardiansyah hoped that the Government would provide a mutually beneficial solution for the current price increase issue as well.
Satwiko Darmesto, Directorate of Distribution Statistics of Statistics Indonesia (“BPS”), stated that the price increase occurred due to the insufficient domestic soybeans production and that Indonesia must continue importing soybeans. Consequently, he said that “the Government must investigate whether soybeans cartelization does exist.”
(hot/jt)
Happy Rayna Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Tadjuddin Noersaid, the Chairman of the Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (“KPPU”), stated last month that there may be a cartelization of soybean prices. However, he failed to elaborate on his statement in a discussion with the Ministry of Trade and BULOG (a state-owned enterprise that manages the supply and the logistics of food).
In the discussion, Tadjuddin stated that such an implication must be proven, which is not an easy task. “We will re-evaluate if the cartelization of prices exists,” he said in Jakarta on Tuesday (14/8).
Tadjuddin explained that cartelization might be related to political aspects of the soybeans price increase. Under Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution and Article 51 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopoly Practices and Unfair Business Competition, the Government is allowed to intervene in order to prevent a price hike.
Meanwhile, Ardiansyah Parman, the Secretary General of the Ministry of Trade, stated that the price increased because of natural occurrences, such as the droughts in the United States (“US”) and some areas of Latin America. These droughts decreased the world’s soybean production by 11 percent.
He explained that since 2000, Indonesia, along with China, Mexico, and Japan, imported soybeans from the US. China imported 61,50 percent, while Mexico and Japan imported 8,74 percent and 5,24 percent, respectively. Indonesia came fourth with 5,11 percent of soybeans import, followed by Taiwan (3,57 percent) and Egypt (2,13 percent).
In addition, Ardiansyah explained that between 1993 and 2011, Indonesia’s soybean production has also been decreased. The decrease was noted mainly in Lampung (17,83%), West Sumatera (13,53%), and North Sumatera (10,60%).
The issue is that Indonesian farmers prefer to produce sugarcane, corn, and rice rather than soybeans, because these commodities generate more income. On top of that, there is a problem of land availability. Ardiansyah stated that “100 thousand hectares of farm land are converted to non-farm land every year.”
Furthermore, Ardiansyah mentioned that the soybeans price increase had previously occurred in 2008. At that time, the Government responded to the issue by applying an exemption on soybeans import duty. The Government also reduced the income tax for imported soybeans from 2,5 percent to 0,5 percent. Moreover, the Government awarded IDR 1.000 in subsidies for each kilogram of raw materials for making bean curds and soybean cakes (tempe) (Minister of Finance Regulation No. 1/PMK.011/2008 on Determination of Import Duty on Soy Beans Import).
As a result, Ardiansyah hoped that the Government would provide a mutually beneficial solution for the current price increase issue as well.
Satwiko Darmesto, Directorate of Distribution Statistics of Statistics Indonesia (“BPS”), stated that the price increase occurred due to the insufficient domestic soybeans production and that Indonesia must continue importing soybeans. Consequently, he said that “the Government must investigate whether soybeans cartelization does exist.”
(hot/jt)