Government Should Not Be Involved in Mining Contracts

Fitri Novia Heriani, Hospita Yulima, Mahinda Arkyasa

Said Didu, the former Secretary General of the Ministry of State-Owned Companies, asserted that the current Government practice to act as a party to a mining contract with private entities or foreign parties is inappropriate.

“I do not know why such practice is applied,” he said in a discussion in Jakarta on Monday (6/8).

Said asserted that when the Government is a party to a contract, it is liable for damages if there is a breach of contract. In addition, in Said’s opinion, foreign parties often use the contract in order to take advantage of the loopholes in the Indonesian legal system for the purpose of improving their business.

According to Said, the solution would involve the Government only acting as an overseer, not a party to the contract. This would ensure that the contract is in accordance with the public interest and does not result in any political issues.

He further added that the mining contract should be made between a national private company and a foreign private company without any interference from the Government. For example, in Singapore, a mining contract is made between private companies and the Singaporean Government does not interfere.

Hikmahanto Juwana, an international law expert, proposed an argument that was similar to Said’s opinion. Hikmahanto said that a mining contract usually favors foreign investors. He even explicitly stated that the State loses control over its natural resources after it becomes a party to a contract.  

Hikmahanto put forth the Churchill caseas an example. He stated that the issue in Churchill occurred due to the overlapping licensing authorities between provinces/regencies/cities and the Government.

“What is the benefit of inviting foreign investors when there are no firm policies set in place to regulate the investments. They should follow our rules, not the other way around”, he concluded.

(hot/jt)

Fitri Novia Heriani, Hospita Yulima, Mahinda Arkyasa

Said Didu, the former Secretary General of the Ministry of State-Owned Companies, asserted that the current Government practice to act as a party to a mining contract with private entities or foreign parties is inappropriate.

“I do not know why such practice is applied,” he said in a discussion in Jakarta on Monday (6/8).

Said asserted that when the Government is a party to a contract, it is liable for damages if there is a breach of contract. In addition, in Said’s opinion, foreign parties often use the contract in order to take advantage of the loopholes in the Indonesian legal system for the purpose of improving their business.

According to Said, the solution would involve the Government only acting as an overseer, not a party to the contract. This would ensure that the contract is in accordance with the public interest and does not result in any political issues.

He further added that the mining contract should be made between a national private company and a foreign private company without any interference from the Government. For example, in Singapore, a mining contract is made between private companies and the Singaporean Government does not interfere.

Hikmahanto Juwana, an international law expert, proposed an argument that was similar to Said’s opinion. Hikmahanto said that a mining contract usually favors foreign investors. He even explicitly stated that the State loses control over its natural resources after it becomes a party to a contract.  

Hikmahanto put forth the Churchill caseas an example. He stated that the issue in Churchill occurred due to the overlapping licensing authorities between provinces/regencies/cities and the Government.

“What is the benefit of inviting foreign investors when there are no firm policies set in place to regulate the investments. They should follow our rules, not the other way around”, he concluded.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info