Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (“Oil and Gas Law”) resulted in a liberalization of the oil and gas management. This is because this law allows foreign parties to dominate 89 percent of the Indonesian oil and gas sector. As a consequence, 32 individuals and 10 religious groups have filed a judicial review petition.
During the judicial review, The Government stated that the petitioners’ claim is incorrect. Hikmahanto Juwana, an expert from the Government, explained that a State may act as a subject to international law or private law in an agreement, depending on the parties to the agreement.
“[…] If the parties are subject to private law, then the State acts as a subject of private law,” he said as an expert witness for the Government, during a judicial review trial on Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas at the Constitutional Court (“MK”), Tuesday (1/8).
He explained that in an oil and gas partnership agreement (Kontrak Kerjasama – “KKS”), the Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (“BP Migas”), which is a State-Owned Legal Entity, acts as a subject to private law. “Usually, BP Migas partners in a KKS with a domestic or international contractor, which is subject to international business contract, not international law,” he stated.
Hikmahanto further added that a KKS would include provisions on dispute settlements (court or arbitration). This means that if there is a breach of contract, BP Migas losses cannot be interpreted as the State’s losses.
Therefore, BP Migas losses in an international arbitration institution do not automatically undermine the State’s sovereignty. “In a KKS, BP Migas acts as a subject of private law, which does not affect the State’s dignity,” he said.
Furthermore, Hikmahanto stated that BP Migas was established to limit the State’s liability. In other words, BP Migas losses will only affect its assets, not the State’s assets. “BP Migas presence is important to mitigate State responsibilities if compensation claims occur,” he stated.
Erman Rajagukguk, also an expert witness for the Government, stated that the Oil and Gas Law does not contradict the 1945 Constitution. Instead, the KKS should be reviewed and improved in order to see whether it benefits the State or not.
The judicial review petition was submitted by a group of 32 individuals and 10 religious organizations. Some of the individual applicants include the Chairman of PP Muhammadiyah, Din Syamsuddin; former Chairman of MUI, Amidhan; former Chairman of PB NU, Achmad Hasyim Muzadi; former Minister of Labor and Transmigration, Fahmi Idris; and the Rector of UIN Syarif Hidayatullah, Komarudin Hidayat.
Meanwhile, the religious groups that are involved in this petition are Lajnah Siyasiyah Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia, Persatuan Umat Islam, Al Irsyad-Al Islamiyah, and the Indonesian Moslem Brotherhood.
The applicants asked the court to review Article 1 (19), Article 1 (23), Article 3 point b, Article 4 (3), Article 6, Article 9, Article 10, Article 11 (2), Article 13, and Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which contradicts Articles 28 D (1), 33 (2), and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
For example, Article 1 (19), which defines work contracts, has the potential to degrade the State’s dignity. This is because, more often than not, contracts between BP Migas (which represents the Government) and corporations include an agreement to international arbitration. This lowers the State’s position against foreign companies. Therefore, the State’s defeat would signify the defeat of the people.
In addition, the applicants argued that Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which states that BP Migas has the authority to represent the State in controlling oil and gas production and reserves, undermines Article 4 (3), which defines BP Migas as a mining authority. Furthermore, BP Migas is not directly involved in oil and gas exploration and exploitation, and it does not have commissioners or supervisors.
(hot/jt)
Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas (“Oil and Gas Law”) resulted in a liberalization of the oil and gas management. This is because this law allows foreign parties to dominate 89 percent of the Indonesian oil and gas sector. As a consequence, 32 individuals and 10 religious groups have filed a judicial review petition.
During the judicial review, The Government stated that the petitioners’ claim is incorrect. Hikmahanto Juwana, an expert from the Government, explained that a State may act as a subject to international law or private law in an agreement, depending on the parties to the agreement.
“[…] If the parties are subject to private law, then the State acts as a subject of private law,” he said as an expert witness for the Government, during a judicial review trial on Law No. 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas at the Constitutional Court (“MK”), Tuesday (1/8).
He explained that in an oil and gas partnership agreement (Kontrak Kerjasama – “KKS”), the Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (“BP Migas”), which is a State-Owned Legal Entity, acts as a subject to private law. “Usually, BP Migas partners in a KKS with a domestic or international contractor, which is subject to international business contract, not international law,” he stated.
Hikmahanto further added that a KKS would include provisions on dispute settlements (court or arbitration). This means that if there is a breach of contract, BP Migas losses cannot be interpreted as the State’s losses.
Therefore, BP Migas losses in an international arbitration institution do not automatically undermine the State’s sovereignty. “In a KKS, BP Migas acts as a subject of private law, which does not affect the State’s dignity,” he said.
Furthermore, Hikmahanto stated that BP Migas was established to limit the State’s liability. In other words, BP Migas losses will only affect its assets, not the State’s assets. “BP Migas presence is important to mitigate State responsibilities if compensation claims occur,” he stated.
Erman Rajagukguk, also an expert witness for the Government, stated that the Oil and Gas Law does not contradict the 1945 Constitution. Instead, the KKS should be reviewed and improved in order to see whether it benefits the State or not.
The judicial review petition was submitted by a group of 32 individuals and 10 religious organizations. Some of the individual applicants include the Chairman of PP Muhammadiyah, Din Syamsuddin; former Chairman of MUI, Amidhan; former Chairman of PB NU, Achmad Hasyim Muzadi; former Minister of Labor and Transmigration, Fahmi Idris; and the Rector of UIN Syarif Hidayatullah, Komarudin Hidayat.
Meanwhile, the religious groups that are involved in this petition are Lajnah Siyasiyah Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia, Persatuan Umat Islam, Al Irsyad-Al Islamiyah, and the Indonesian Moslem Brotherhood.
The applicants asked the court to review Article 1 (19), Article 1 (23), Article 3 point b, Article 4 (3), Article 6, Article 9, Article 10, Article 11 (2), Article 13, and Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which contradicts Articles 28 D (1), 33 (2), and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.
For example, Article 1 (19), which defines work contracts, has the potential to degrade the State’s dignity. This is because, more often than not, contracts between BP Migas (which represents the Government) and corporations include an agreement to international arbitration. This lowers the State’s position against foreign companies. Therefore, the State’s defeat would signify the defeat of the people.
In addition, the applicants argued that Article 44 of the Oil and Gas Law, which states that BP Migas has the authority to represent the State in controlling oil and gas production and reserves, undermines Article 4 (3), which defines BP Migas as a mining authority. Furthermore, BP Migas is not directly involved in oil and gas exploration and exploitation, and it does not have commissioners or supervisors.
(hot/jt)