MK: Government Purchase on Newmont Divestment Needs the Approval of the House

Agus Sahbani, Salma Izzatii

The Constitutional Court (Mahkamah Konstitusi – “MK”) rejected the President’s petition on State Institution Authority Dispute against the House of Representatives (“House”) and The Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan - “BPK”). MK, on Tuesday (31/7), stated that the purchase of Newmont’s 7% shares divestment can only be done with the House’s approval.

Minister of Law and Human Rights and Minister of Finance brought this case to MK on behalf of the President. They argued that because the President has the authority to manage the state finance, he also has the constitutional authority to purchase Newmont’s 7% shares divestment without the House’s approval. The claim was based on Article 4 (1), Article 17 (1), Article 23C, and Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.

Furthermore, the President argued that the BPK exceeded its authority when it reported  that the President needs the House’s approval before buying Newmont’s divestment. The purchase of Newmont’s 7% shares divestment was lawful, since it was to create greater benefits for Indonesian people, which is in accordance with the purpose of the country.

However, MK rejected these arguments. “Purchasing 7% shares in Newmont does not create a significant control over Newmont’s management and therefore it is not effective to create greater benefits for Indonesian people,” said Judge Muhammad Alim.

Alim also stressed that the Government can exert control not only through ownership, but can also be done through regulations and various actions of management and supervision.

He went on to state the following:  “If the Government really wishes to effectively control the management of the country’s natural resources, then the President and the House need to make a joint policy so that the Government can hold the majority of all natural resource–related businesses. The purchase can only be done through the State Budget Law mechanism or through specific approval. The purchasing must be done openly and under the House’s supervision.”

However, there are four out of nine MK judges with a dissenting opinion. Maria Farida Indrati, Achmad Sodiki, Ahmad Fadlil Sumadi, and Harjono agreed that the President has the authority to purchase Newmont’s shares using the State’s funds.

“Based on the authority given by the Article 27 (4) of Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance, the President can have parts of Newmont’s shares in accordance with the aim of promoting national interest without the House’s approval but with the House’s endorsement,” maintained Maria.

Minister of Finance, Agus Martowardojo, said that they appreciated the dissenting opinions and respected the MK’s final decision. He assured that the substance of this decision would be further observed with other governmental elements.

(hot/jt)

Agus Sahbani, Salma Izzatii

The Constitutional Court (Mahkamah Konstitusi – “MK”) rejected the President’s petition on State Institution Authority Dispute against the House of Representatives (“House”) and The Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan - “BPK”). MK, on Tuesday (31/7), stated that the purchase of Newmont’s 7% shares divestment can only be done with the House’s approval.

Minister of Law and Human Rights and Minister of Finance brought this case to MK on behalf of the President. They argued that because the President has the authority to manage the state finance, he also has the constitutional authority to purchase Newmont’s 7% shares divestment without the House’s approval. The claim was based on Article 4 (1), Article 17 (1), Article 23C, and Article 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.

Furthermore, the President argued that the BPK exceeded its authority when it reported  that the President needs the House’s approval before buying Newmont’s divestment. The purchase of Newmont’s 7% shares divestment was lawful, since it was to create greater benefits for Indonesian people, which is in accordance with the purpose of the country.

However, MK rejected these arguments. “Purchasing 7% shares in Newmont does not create a significant control over Newmont’s management and therefore it is not effective to create greater benefits for Indonesian people,” said Judge Muhammad Alim.

Alim also stressed that the Government can exert control not only through ownership, but can also be done through regulations and various actions of management and supervision.

He went on to state the following:  “If the Government really wishes to effectively control the management of the country’s natural resources, then the President and the House need to make a joint policy so that the Government can hold the majority of all natural resource–related businesses. The purchase can only be done through the State Budget Law mechanism or through specific approval. The purchasing must be done openly and under the House’s supervision.”

However, there are four out of nine MK judges with a dissenting opinion. Maria Farida Indrati, Achmad Sodiki, Ahmad Fadlil Sumadi, and Harjono agreed that the President has the authority to purchase Newmont’s shares using the State’s funds.

“Based on the authority given by the Article 27 (4) of Law No. 17 of 2003 on State Finance, the President can have parts of Newmont’s shares in accordance with the aim of promoting national interest without the House’s approval but with the House’s endorsement,” maintained Maria.

Minister of Finance, Agus Martowardojo, said that they appreciated the dissenting opinions and respected the MK’s final decision. He assured that the substance of this decision would be further observed with other governmental elements.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info