Happy Rayna Stephany, Indra A Pambudy
The Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (“KPPU”) emphasized that the merits of the soybean price hike should be assessed. This should be done especially after seeing that similar hikes happened in 2007 and 2008. Even though it was not proven, hints of cartelization appeared during those years.
Tadjuddin Noer, Chairman of KPPU, stated that based on the pattern of the price rises and drops, there are hints of cartelization this year. “This price rise needs to be studied,” he said.
Based on KPPU’s 2007 data, the soybean import market is categorized as oligopolistic. Two suppliers, namely PT Gerbang Cahaya Utama and PT Cargill Indonesia, supplied 84,63% of the beans in Indonesia. The former imported 830,761,098 kg, while the latter imported 503,426,215 kg.
A third importer, PT Alam Agri Adiperkasa, imported 178,017,892 kg. The three imported over 100 tons of soybeans in a year.
In 2008, PT Gerbang Cahaya Utama and PT Cargill Indonesia continued to dominate the soybean import, with the combined imports of 74.66% of Indonesia’s total import market.
Tadjuddin explained KPPU’s difficulties in gathering evidence to prove cartelization, since Indonesia’s legal system does not approve indirect evidence.
“It is impossible to gather direct evidence when KPPU does not have the authority to investigate and to confiscate the goods. Cartelization won’t be proven if the legal system always asks for direct evidence,” Tadjuddin asserted.
KPPU is now taking measures to monitor price movements in the domestic soybean market, especially in the top five consuming provinces (West Java, Central Java, East Java, Jogjakarta, and Bali), which consume almost 78% of the import.
There are three steps to avert similar soybean crisis in the future, according to Tadjuddin. First, a buffer stock must be set aside to minimize price fluctuation. Setting aside a buffer stock allows the Government to satisfy domestic demands at an equitable price.
He said that a state-owned company should administer the stock, though not necessarily the National Logistics Body (“BULOG”).
The second step would be to increase domestic soybeans production by way of an intensified production program (Intensifikasi Khusus – INSUS), which would be similar to a program implemented in 1982. Lastly, national policy must support KPPU by allowing the admission of indirect evidence under the legal system.
Investigate the Mastermind
Nurdin Tampubolon, Deputy Chairman of Commission VI at the House of Representatives (“DPR”), echoed Tadjuddin’s concern. He stated that it is not impossible that the high soybeans price may have been caused by cartelization, citing market wide seasonal price hikes, for example the Eid and Christmas.
“It is necessary to uncover the mastermind and the KPPU must cooperate with the National Police, Ministry of Trade, and other relevant institutions,” Nurdin asserted.
However, while he agrees with Tadjuddin’s solution on buffer stock, he prioritizes domestic production. He suggests that the Government should allocate 500 thousand hectares of land to plant soybeans.
“This plan will lead to soybean self-sufficiency, negating the need to import. Once this is accomplished, then providing buffer stock may proceed,” he explained.
(hot/jt)
Happy Rayna Stephany, Indra A Pambudy
The Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (“KPPU”) emphasized that the merits of the soybean price hike should be assessed. This should be done especially after seeing that similar hikes happened in 2007 and 2008. Even though it was not proven, hints of cartelization appeared during those years.
Tadjuddin Noer, Chairman of KPPU, stated that based on the pattern of the price rises and drops, there are hints of cartelization this year. “This price rise needs to be studied,” he said.
Based on KPPU’s 2007 data, the soybean import market is categorized as oligopolistic. Two suppliers, namely PT Gerbang Cahaya Utama and PT Cargill Indonesia, supplied 84,63% of the beans in Indonesia. The former imported 830,761,098 kg, while the latter imported 503,426,215 kg.
A third importer, PT Alam Agri Adiperkasa, imported 178,017,892 kg. The three imported over 100 tons of soybeans in a year.
In 2008, PT Gerbang Cahaya Utama and PT Cargill Indonesia continued to dominate the soybean import, with the combined imports of 74.66% of Indonesia’s total import market.
Tadjuddin explained KPPU’s difficulties in gathering evidence to prove cartelization, since Indonesia’s legal system does not approve indirect evidence.
“It is impossible to gather direct evidence when KPPU does not have the authority to investigate and to confiscate the goods. Cartelization won’t be proven if the legal system always asks for direct evidence,” Tadjuddin asserted.
KPPU is now taking measures to monitor price movements in the domestic soybean market, especially in the top five consuming provinces (West Java, Central Java, East Java, Jogjakarta, and Bali), which consume almost 78% of the import.
There are three steps to avert similar soybean crisis in the future, according to Tadjuddin. First, a buffer stock must be set aside to minimize price fluctuation. Setting aside a buffer stock allows the Government to satisfy domestic demands at an equitable price.
He said that a state-owned company should administer the stock, though not necessarily the National Logistics Body (“BULOG”).
The second step would be to increase domestic soybeans production by way of an intensified production program (Intensifikasi Khusus – INSUS), which would be similar to a program implemented in 1982. Lastly, national policy must support KPPU by allowing the admission of indirect evidence under the legal system.
Investigate the Mastermind
Nurdin Tampubolon, Deputy Chairman of Commission VI at the House of Representatives (“DPR”), echoed Tadjuddin’s concern. He stated that it is not impossible that the high soybeans price may have been caused by cartelization, citing market wide seasonal price hikes, for example the Eid and Christmas.
“It is necessary to uncover the mastermind and the KPPU must cooperate with the National Police, Ministry of Trade, and other relevant institutions,” Nurdin asserted.
However, while he agrees with Tadjuddin’s solution on buffer stock, he prioritizes domestic production. He suggests that the Government should allocate 500 thousand hectares of land to plant soybeans.
“This plan will lead to soybean self-sufficiency, negating the need to import. Once this is accomplished, then providing buffer stock may proceed,” he explained.
(hot/jt)