M Yasin, Yudo Tunggul Baskoro, Mahinda Arkyasa
Wahidudin Adams, Director General of Laws and Regulations at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, confirmed that the Government is preparing a draft bill (“Draft Bill”) on Private Partnerships (Persekutuan Perdata), Firms (Firma), and Limited Partnerships (Commanditaire Vennootschaap – “CV”). Under the Indonesian legal system, these business entities are not considered to be legal entities.
Wahidudin asserted that the Draft Bill was in preparation for the last 12 years and the Government will announce it this year. “We have been preparing the Draft Bill since 1990,” he said to hukumonline.
The Draft Bill, according to Wahidudin, is important because the abovementioned forms of business entities are still present in the society. He said that the Draft Bill would adopt provisions from the Indonesian Commercial Code (“KUHD”). “There will be modifications to 28 to 30 articles, however, only essential things will be changed,” he said.
Wahidudin further explained that the Draft Bill was discussed among his directorate, academics, and law practitioners. The discussion, which was organized last June, involved Munir Fuady, a lawyer, and Yetty Komalasari Dewi, an academic from Universitas Indonesia (“UI”).
In that discussion, Munir Fuady said that the provisions regarding private partnerships, firms, and CVs that fall under the KUHD and the Indonesian Civil Code (“KUHPdt”) are not suitable anymore. “These forms of business entities are being disregarded,” Munir said.
As a comparison, Munir took an example from limited liability companies (perseroan terbatas – “PT”). He explained that the structure of PTs has been “upgraded” twice. They were regulated under Law No. 1 of 1995, which was replaced by Law No. 40 of 2007.
Munir also emphasized that the distinction between private partnerships and CVs needs to be clarified. As an example, he stated that law firms commonly form under private partnerships, while there are no laws or regulations that define a law firm as a private partnership.
“The draft bill”, said Munir, “is not yet sufficient due to the lack of CV-related provisions compared to firm-related provisions”. He recommended the adoption of several provisions from Law No. 40 of 2007 in order to regulate passive corporations formed under CVs.
Yetty, who wrote a dissertation on CVs in Indonesia, said that CVs are commonly used to form medium-small businesses. She explained that there is a debate on whether CVs can be considered as a legal entity. Yenny recommended that partners’ responsibilities in a partnership should be elaborated in the Draft Bill.
(hot/jt)
M Yasin, Yudo Tunggul Baskoro, Mahinda Arkyasa
Wahidudin Adams, Director General of Laws and Regulations at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, confirmed that the Government is preparing a draft bill (“Draft Bill”) on Private Partnerships (Persekutuan Perdata), Firms (Firma), and Limited Partnerships (Commanditaire Vennootschaap – “CV”). Under the Indonesian legal system, these business entities are not considered to be legal entities.
Wahidudin asserted that the Draft Bill was in preparation for the last 12 years and the Government will announce it this year. “We have been preparing the Draft Bill since 1990,” he said to hukumonline.
The Draft Bill, according to Wahidudin, is important because the abovementioned forms of business entities are still present in the society. He said that the Draft Bill would adopt provisions from the Indonesian Commercial Code (“KUHD”). “There will be modifications to 28 to 30 articles, however, only essential things will be changed,” he said.
Wahidudin further explained that the Draft Bill was discussed among his directorate, academics, and law practitioners. The discussion, which was organized last June, involved Munir Fuady, a lawyer, and Yetty Komalasari Dewi, an academic from Universitas Indonesia (“UI”).
In that discussion, Munir Fuady said that the provisions regarding private partnerships, firms, and CVs that fall under the KUHD and the Indonesian Civil Code (“KUHPdt”) are not suitable anymore. “These forms of business entities are being disregarded,” Munir said.
As a comparison, Munir took an example from limited liability companies (perseroan terbatas – “PT”). He explained that the structure of PTs has been “upgraded” twice. They were regulated under Law No. 1 of 1995, which was replaced by Law No. 40 of 2007.
Munir also emphasized that the distinction between private partnerships and CVs needs to be clarified. As an example, he stated that law firms commonly form under private partnerships, while there are no laws or regulations that define a law firm as a private partnership.
“The draft bill”, said Munir, “is not yet sufficient due to the lack of CV-related provisions compared to firm-related provisions”. He recommended the adoption of several provisions from Law No. 40 of 2007 in order to regulate passive corporations formed under CVs.
Yetty, who wrote a dissertation on CVs in Indonesia, said that CVs are commonly used to form medium-small businesses. She explained that there is a debate on whether CVs can be considered as a legal entity. Yenny recommended that partners’ responsibilities in a partnership should be elaborated in the Draft Bill.
(hot/jt)