Leo Wisnu Susapto, Salma Izzatii
The Supreme Court rejected the judicial review of Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (Komisi Pengawas Persaingan Usaha – “KPPU”) Regulation No. 1 of 2010 regarding Case Handling Procedures (“KPPU Regulation”).
The judicial review was filed by the Antimonopoly and Unfair Competition Law Enforcement Advocacy Team in 2010. The Court’s decision, dated on 21 April 2011, affirmed the KPPU Regulation and ended the debate on KPPU’s procedural law.
The Applicant argued that the KPPU Regulation contradicts Law No. 5 of 1999 on Antimonopoly and Unfair Business Competition (“Antimonopoly Law”). The Applicant stated that the Antimonopoly Law does not include a mandate that allows KPPU to create a procedural law on handling cases that deal with monopolies and unfair business competition.
Therefore, the KPPU Regulation also contradicts Law No. 10 of 2004 on The Establishment of Laws and Regulations (“Law 10/2004”), which states that an institution can only create a procedural law if there is legislation that mandates such authority.
The Supreme Court, however, explained that KPPU’s authority to issue its own procedural law is stated under Article 35 (f) of the Antimonopoly Law. The Article states: “Obligations of KPPU include: … establishing a guideline and/or publication related to this Law”.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court pointed out that the Applicant failed to provide which KPPU Regulation articles contradict higher legislation and are detrimental to the Applicant’s interests.
Alfin Sulaiman, member of the Applicant’s team, insisted that KPPU is only authorized to create an internal guideline, which does not have any legally binding power towards parties that undergo a trial in KPPU.
However, KPPU applauded the Supreme Court decision to reject the Applicant’s argument. A. Junaidi, Head of Public Relations and Legal Department at KPPU, stated that the decision ended the debate on KPPU’s procedural law.
(hot/jt)
Leo Wisnu Susapto, Salma Izzatii
The Supreme Court rejected the judicial review of Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (Komisi Pengawas Persaingan Usaha – “KPPU”) Regulation No. 1 of 2010 regarding Case Handling Procedures (“KPPU Regulation”).
The judicial review was filed by the Antimonopoly and Unfair Competition Law Enforcement Advocacy Team in 2010. The Court’s decision, dated on 21 April 2011, affirmed the KPPU Regulation and ended the debate on KPPU’s procedural law.
The Applicant argued that the KPPU Regulation contradicts Law No. 5 of 1999 on Antimonopoly and Unfair Business Competition (“Antimonopoly Law”). The Applicant stated that the Antimonopoly Law does not include a mandate that allows KPPU to create a procedural law on handling cases that deal with monopolies and unfair business competition.
Therefore, the KPPU Regulation also contradicts Law No. 10 of 2004 on The Establishment of Laws and Regulations (“Law 10/2004”), which states that an institution can only create a procedural law if there is legislation that mandates such authority.
The Supreme Court, however, explained that KPPU’s authority to issue its own procedural law is stated under Article 35 (f) of the Antimonopoly Law. The Article states: “Obligations of KPPU include: … establishing a guideline and/or publication related to this Law”.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court pointed out that the Applicant failed to provide which KPPU Regulation articles contradict higher legislation and are detrimental to the Applicant’s interests.
Alfin Sulaiman, member of the Applicant’s team, insisted that KPPU is only authorized to create an internal guideline, which does not have any legally binding power towards parties that undergo a trial in KPPU.
However, KPPU applauded the Supreme Court decision to reject the Applicant’s argument. A. Junaidi, Head of Public Relations and Legal Department at KPPU, stated that the decision ended the debate on KPPU’s procedural law.
(hot/jt)