Laborers Have Doubts About Government Supervision of Outsourcing Companies

Ady TD Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa

Muhaimin Iskandar, Minister of Labor and Transmigration (“Minister”), has agreed to strengthen the supervision of outsourcing companies, which includes a temporary moratorium on business license issuance.  However, labor unions are doubtful that the Minister will be able to implement such policies.

Timboel Siregar, Secretary General of the All Indonesian Labor Organization (“OPSI”), stated that the Minister made too many promises without actually implementing them. Timboel argued that the Minister should focus on showing his willingness to deal with outsourcing issues.

“The moratorium is merely rhetorical. I am confident that the Minister would not be able to settle the outsourcing issues. He is not brave enough to face the businesses,” said Timboel to hukumonline, Friday (20/7).

Furthermore, Timboel explained that if the Minister is determined to settle outsourcing issues, there are three steps that must be taken. First, a centralized outsourcing business licensing authority should be established at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration. Currently, it is the local governments that handle licensing, which leads to the mismanagement of outsourcing companies in Indonesia.

Next, the Minister should revise Article 6 (3) of the Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. 220 of 2004, because the Article gives the businesses full authority to determine which activities are defined as core or support activities. Timboel stated that the Government should determine what is considered as a core or support activity together with the National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit).

Finally, Timboel suggested that the Government should conduct centralized labor supervision and directly monitor and investigate businesses by involving tripartite supervisors. “Those are the few things the Minister should do,” he said.

Meanwhile, Hasanuddin Rachman, Head of the Industrial Relations and Advocacy of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo), said that the Minister must be cautious if he is about to issue any outsourcing-related regulation. He argued that according to Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor and the Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011, outsourcing is currently legal.

Therefore, Hasanuddin asserted that the moratorium cannot be applied to outsourcing companies that have fulfilled the requirements under the prevailing laws and regulations. He further elaborated that outsourcing companies must be a legal entity, and must be experienced in organizing outsourcing activities.

“I support the moratorium on issuing business licenses for outsourcing companies that do not fulfill such requirements, and are, in other words, illegal,” he said to hukumonline via telephone, Friday (20/7).

In addition, Hasanuddin asserted that the outsourcing problem is caused by the lack of legal enforcement, which allows illegal outsourcing companies to operate even today. “Illegal outsourcing companies should have their business licenses revoked,” he said.

In response to the Minister’s statement, Ruslan Irianto, Director General of the Industrial Dispute Settlement and Social Security at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration, stated that the Government will take firm action against illegal outsourcing companies. “We will revoke their licenses,” said Irianto to hukumonline, Friday (20/7).

Irianto said that the Minister has briefed 33 Ministries about the action and will issue a circular letter to every labor and transmigration offices (dinas tenaga kerja) in Indonesia.

(hot/jt)

Ady TD Achmad, Mahinda Arkyasa

Muhaimin Iskandar, Minister of Labor and Transmigration (“Minister”), has agreed to strengthen the supervision of outsourcing companies, which includes a temporary moratorium on business license issuance.  However, labor unions are doubtful that the Minister will be able to implement such policies.

Timboel Siregar, Secretary General of the All Indonesian Labor Organization (“OPSI”), stated that the Minister made too many promises without actually implementing them. Timboel argued that the Minister should focus on showing his willingness to deal with outsourcing issues.

“The moratorium is merely rhetorical. I am confident that the Minister would not be able to settle the outsourcing issues. He is not brave enough to face the businesses,” said Timboel to hukumonline, Friday (20/7).

Furthermore, Timboel explained that if the Minister is determined to settle outsourcing issues, there are three steps that must be taken. First, a centralized outsourcing business licensing authority should be established at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration. Currently, it is the local governments that handle licensing, which leads to the mismanagement of outsourcing companies in Indonesia.

Next, the Minister should revise Article 6 (3) of the Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. 220 of 2004, because the Article gives the businesses full authority to determine which activities are defined as core or support activities. Timboel stated that the Government should determine what is considered as a core or support activity together with the National Tripartite Cooperation Body (LKS Tripartit).

Finally, Timboel suggested that the Government should conduct centralized labor supervision and directly monitor and investigate businesses by involving tripartite supervisors. “Those are the few things the Minister should do,” he said.

Meanwhile, Hasanuddin Rachman, Head of the Industrial Relations and Advocacy of the Indonesian Business Association (Apindo), said that the Minister must be cautious if he is about to issue any outsourcing-related regulation. He argued that according to Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor and the Constitutional Court Decision No. 27/PUU-IX/2011, outsourcing is currently legal.

Therefore, Hasanuddin asserted that the moratorium cannot be applied to outsourcing companies that have fulfilled the requirements under the prevailing laws and regulations. He further elaborated that outsourcing companies must be a legal entity, and must be experienced in organizing outsourcing activities.

“I support the moratorium on issuing business licenses for outsourcing companies that do not fulfill such requirements, and are, in other words, illegal,” he said to hukumonline via telephone, Friday (20/7).

In addition, Hasanuddin asserted that the outsourcing problem is caused by the lack of legal enforcement, which allows illegal outsourcing companies to operate even today. “Illegal outsourcing companies should have their business licenses revoked,” he said.

In response to the Minister’s statement, Ruslan Irianto, Director General of the Industrial Dispute Settlement and Social Security at the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration, stated that the Government will take firm action against illegal outsourcing companies. “We will revoke their licenses,” said Irianto to hukumonline, Friday (20/7).

Irianto said that the Minister has briefed 33 Ministries about the action and will issue a circular letter to every labor and transmigration offices (dinas tenaga kerja) in Indonesia.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info