BI Should Regulate Foreign Ownership of National Banks

Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Metta Dharmasaputra, executive director of Business Study Institution Katadata (“Katadata”), asserted that it is necessary to revise Law No. 7 of 1992 on Banking as amended by Law No. 10 of 1998 (“Banking Law”) and Government Regulation No. 29 of 1999 on Purchase of Commercial Bank Shares (PP 29/1999) in order to give an opportunity for local banks to improve and protect national interest, especially when it comes the banking industry.

Although recent Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 14/8/PBI/2012 on Commercial Banks Shares Ownership (“BI Regulation”) gives a positive impact on national banking industry, Metta stated that Bank Indonesia (“BI”) should have issued a regulation that limits majority share ownership by single foreign investor in a private national bank.

The BI Regulation only limits the majority ownership of bank shares in banks that have level 3, 4, or 5 bank health rating, where it obliges banks to divest their shares without distinguishing between local or foreign ownership. Therefore, there will be no changes in the ownership status of national banks, which are mostly controlled by foreign investors.

“With the BI regulation, foreign investors will have a great opportunity to acquire shares of those [unhealthy] banks,” he said.

Metta asserted that the new regulation should be able to restructure the ownership status of private national banks. In addition, the new regulation would oblige foreign shareholders to divest their shares to the public.

Furthermore, he explained that the new regulation will provide an opportunity for national banks to grow and will provide protection for national interest on the banking industry. “Chances for foreign investors to make an investment in the national banking industry will still be available,” he said.

In addition, Metta said that policy considerations are needed to support the growth of national banks in order to face the integrated ASEAN economic on 2015. Currently, Indonesian banks are still falling behind compared to their competitors within the ASEAN region. For example, Bank Mandiri, with USD 6.7 billion worth of capital in 2011 and one of the largest bank in Indonesia, is ranked number seven in ASEAN after three Singapore banks (DBS, OCBC, and UOB), two Malaysian banks (Maybank and CIMB), and one Thailand bank (Bangkok bank). DBS is ranked number one with USD 26.3 billion worth of capital.

Moreover, according to BI data, number of foreign banks assets has increased from 11 percent at 2008 to 34 percent at 2011, while the national banks’ assets have declined from 89 percent to 66 percent. The decline is happening as foreign investors acquire more shares with national banks.

“Based on those facts, a restructuring on national banking industry is necessary, considering that the condition of the national banking industry is much different from the condition on the 1998 economic crisis,” Metta said.

The limitation on single foreign investors has been applied by several countries. For instance, China limits share ownership for single foreign investor in a bank, where a single foreign investor can only own 20 percent of the bank shares. In addition, China states that a bank is considered to be a foreign bank if 25 percent of its’ shares are owned by foreign shareholders. Moreover, Singapore set the limit of foreign share ownership at 20 percent, Thailand at 49 percent, and Malaysia set a limit of 20 percent for foreign individual shareholders and 30 percent for foreign institutions.

Meanwhile, Harry Azhar Azis, Deputy Chairman of Commission XI of the House of Representatives (“the House”) said to hukumonline that discussion on the new Draft Bill on Banking will be conducted after the House’s recess period ends.

He explained that the Draft Bill has been finished. However, the discussion will take quite a long time, and if there is need for revision, it will be returned to the Government.

“We cannot say for certain when the Draft Bill will be finished, it could take two or three months after the recess period ends,” he concluded.

(ant/hot/jt)

Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Metta Dharmasaputra, executive director of Business Study Institution Katadata (“Katadata”), asserted that it is necessary to revise Law No. 7 of 1992 on Banking as amended by Law No. 10 of 1998 (“Banking Law”) and Government Regulation No. 29 of 1999 on Purchase of Commercial Bank Shares (PP 29/1999) in order to give an opportunity for local banks to improve and protect national interest, especially when it comes the banking industry.

Although recent Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 14/8/PBI/2012 on Commercial Banks Shares Ownership (“BI Regulation”) gives a positive impact on national banking industry, Metta stated that Bank Indonesia (“BI”) should have issued a regulation that limits majority share ownership by single foreign investor in a private national bank.

The BI Regulation only limits the majority ownership of bank shares in banks that have level 3, 4, or 5 bank health rating, where it obliges banks to divest their shares without distinguishing between local or foreign ownership. Therefore, there will be no changes in the ownership status of national banks, which are mostly controlled by foreign investors.

“With the BI regulation, foreign investors will have a great opportunity to acquire shares of those [unhealthy] banks,” he said.

Metta asserted that the new regulation should be able to restructure the ownership status of private national banks. In addition, the new regulation would oblige foreign shareholders to divest their shares to the public.

Furthermore, he explained that the new regulation will provide an opportunity for national banks to grow and will provide protection for national interest on the banking industry. “Chances for foreign investors to make an investment in the national banking industry will still be available,” he said.

In addition, Metta said that policy considerations are needed to support the growth of national banks in order to face the integrated ASEAN economic on 2015. Currently, Indonesian banks are still falling behind compared to their competitors within the ASEAN region. For example, Bank Mandiri, with USD 6.7 billion worth of capital in 2011 and one of the largest bank in Indonesia, is ranked number seven in ASEAN after three Singapore banks (DBS, OCBC, and UOB), two Malaysian banks (Maybank and CIMB), and one Thailand bank (Bangkok bank). DBS is ranked number one with USD 26.3 billion worth of capital.

Moreover, according to BI data, number of foreign banks assets has increased from 11 percent at 2008 to 34 percent at 2011, while the national banks’ assets have declined from 89 percent to 66 percent. The decline is happening as foreign investors acquire more shares with national banks.

“Based on those facts, a restructuring on national banking industry is necessary, considering that the condition of the national banking industry is much different from the condition on the 1998 economic crisis,” Metta said.

The limitation on single foreign investors has been applied by several countries. For instance, China limits share ownership for single foreign investor in a bank, where a single foreign investor can only own 20 percent of the bank shares. In addition, China states that a bank is considered to be a foreign bank if 25 percent of its’ shares are owned by foreign shareholders. Moreover, Singapore set the limit of foreign share ownership at 20 percent, Thailand at 49 percent, and Malaysia set a limit of 20 percent for foreign individual shareholders and 30 percent for foreign institutions.

Meanwhile, Harry Azhar Azis, Deputy Chairman of Commission XI of the House of Representatives (“the House”) said to hukumonline that discussion on the new Draft Bill on Banking will be conducted after the House’s recess period ends.

He explained that the Draft Bill has been finished. However, the discussion will take quite a long time, and if there is need for revision, it will be returned to the Government.

“We cannot say for certain when the Draft Bill will be finished, it could take two or three months after the recess period ends,” he concluded.

(ant/hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info