Former Chief Justice: International Treaty Should Be Acknowledged as Legislation

Pirhot Nababan, Mahinda Arkyasa

The Judicial Review of Law No. 38 of 2008 on ASEAN Charter Ratification (Law 38/2008) submitted by the Alliance for Global Justice in May 2011 has caused significant debate among academics and law practitioners revolving around the status of Indonesia’s consent to be bound by the ASEAN Charter.

Bagir Manan, former Chief Justice, explained that as an agreement between states parties, an international treaty generates certain rights and obligations. The issue of consent arises because a law that ratifies an international treaty is separate from the ratification instrument, which states a country’s consent to be bound by a treaty.

“If the law that ratifies the treaty is annulled and declared not legally binding, then what about other countries subject to the treaty?” he said during a focus group discussion at Universitas Padjadjaran Law School (FH Unpad), Bandung, Tuesday (17/7).

To prevent similar debate in the future, Bagir suggested that ratification should not be stipulated under a law anymore. “Ratification is ratification. An international treaty is legally binding if a country has stated its ‘consent to be bound’. So there is no need for further ratification by issuing a law,” he opined.

However, Etty R. Agoes, international law professor from FH Unpad questioned Bagir’s statement. “If not ratified by a law, how can the treaty be domestically binding?” she asked.

Bagir responded by suggesting that international treaties should be included in the hierarchy of laws and regulations, which is currently regulated under Law No. 12 of 2011 on Establishment of Laws and Regulations. “International treaties must be classified as a form of legislation. Then, a treaty would not need a law to ratify it,” he said.

He added that by classifying international treaties as a form of legislation, implementing laws and regulations could use it as a consideration. Bagir explained that an international treaty can be above or on the same level as a law. “In many countries, international treaties are on a higher level than laws,” he said.

Mieke Komar, former justice and international law professor of FH Unpad supported Bagir’s statement, citing an example where a judge relied on an international treaty in rendering a judgment.

“In the human rights case of East Timor, ad hoc judge Sumaryo Suryokusumo used the humanitarian law convention and its protocol, which has not been ratified by Indonesia,” she stated. By classifying international law as a form of legislation, issues such as the current judicial review may be prevented, she added.

“If the Constitutional Court decides to grant the judicial review, and Indonesia declares its resignation from the ASEAN Charter, it will disturb the stability of the Southeast Asia region and disrupt the ASEAN members’ trust, and Indonesia’s international reputation will be degraded,” she said.

(hot/am)

Pirhot Nababan, Mahinda Arkyasa

The Judicial Review of Law No. 38 of 2008 on ASEAN Charter Ratification (Law 38/2008) submitted by the Alliance for Global Justice in May 2011 has caused significant debate among academics and law practitioners revolving around the status of Indonesia’s consent to be bound by the ASEAN Charter.

Bagir Manan, former Chief Justice, explained that as an agreement between states parties, an international treaty generates certain rights and obligations. The issue of consent arises because a law that ratifies an international treaty is separate from the ratification instrument, which states a country’s consent to be bound by a treaty.

“If the law that ratifies the treaty is annulled and declared not legally binding, then what about other countries subject to the treaty?” he said during a focus group discussion at Universitas Padjadjaran Law School (FH Unpad), Bandung, Tuesday (17/7).

To prevent similar debate in the future, Bagir suggested that ratification should not be stipulated under a law anymore. “Ratification is ratification. An international treaty is legally binding if a country has stated its ‘consent to be bound’. So there is no need for further ratification by issuing a law,” he opined.

However, Etty R. Agoes, international law professor from FH Unpad questioned Bagir’s statement. “If not ratified by a law, how can the treaty be domestically binding?” she asked.

Bagir responded by suggesting that international treaties should be included in the hierarchy of laws and regulations, which is currently regulated under Law No. 12 of 2011 on Establishment of Laws and Regulations. “International treaties must be classified as a form of legislation. Then, a treaty would not need a law to ratify it,” he said.

He added that by classifying international treaties as a form of legislation, implementing laws and regulations could use it as a consideration. Bagir explained that an international treaty can be above or on the same level as a law. “In many countries, international treaties are on a higher level than laws,” he said.

Mieke Komar, former justice and international law professor of FH Unpad supported Bagir’s statement, citing an example where a judge relied on an international treaty in rendering a judgment.

“In the human rights case of East Timor, ad hoc judge Sumaryo Suryokusumo used the humanitarian law convention and its protocol, which has not been ratified by Indonesia,” she stated. By classifying international law as a form of legislation, issues such as the current judicial review may be prevented, she added.

“If the Constitutional Court decides to grant the judicial review, and Indonesia declares its resignation from the ASEAN Charter, it will disturb the stability of the Southeast Asia region and disrupt the ASEAN members’ trust, and Indonesia’s international reputation will be degraded,” she said.

(hot/am)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info