Happy Stephany, Salma Izzatii
Business Software Alliance (“BSA”) denied having blackmailed PT Multisari Langgengjaya’s (“PT Multisari”). BSA also claimed that it has the right to represent copyright owners through their authorization letters. These arguments were delivered by BSA during a trial at Central Jakarta District Court, Monday (9/7).
Prior to this trial, Insan Budi Maulana, PT Multisari’s in-house counsel, stated that BSA has blackmailed PT Multisari by imposing fines on his client without any legal basis. Insan asserted that there have not been any evidence nor court decisions that state that PT Multisari has done any software piracy. PT Multisari also alleged that BSA Indonesia’s address is fictional.
BSA replied to PT Multisari’s first argument stating that imposing fines is not a form of blackmail. As stated in their file, on September 2011 PT Multisari offered conciliation with BSA after admitting to using pirated software. BSA accepted this offer with several conditions, one of them being USD 10,000 compensation, and BSA was open for further negotiation.
BSA also claimed to own the Letter of Authorization (“LoA”) of several copyright owners. BSA further elaborated that Microsoft Corporation has given its LoA on 24 March 2009, Tekla Corporation on 28 October 2009, AutodeskInc. on 29 October 2009, Adobe Systems Incorporated on 9 November 2009, and lastly Siemens Product Lifecycle Management Software Inc on 1 July 2011.
Based on these LoAs, BSA claimed to have the right to act on behalf of these copyright owners to discuss, negotiate, and approve documents. BSA also claimed to have the rights to sue the end-user of these pirated software.
Lastly, BSA asserted that the address of BSA Indonesia is not fictional. BSA Indonesia’s address is written as follows: Sampoerna Strategic Square-Tower B, Lantai 19 Jalan Jenderal Sudirman Kav. 45-46 Karet Semanggi, Setiabudi, Jakarta Selatan.
BSA’s assertion is affirmed with the evidence of Business Permit of Foreign Trade Representatives No. SIT.114/P-4/Nas/P3A/PDN.2/2/2011 dated 23 February 2011, BSA Indonesia Company Registration Certificate No. No.TDP 09.03.6.74.01205, dated 15 Agustus 2007, and Certificate of Domicile issued by PT The Executive Centre Indonesia Ref.TECI/040/SKD/12 dated 14 June 2012.
BSA also submitted a counterclaim for PT Multisari to recover damages of USD 10,800. BSA claimed that PT Multisari has unlawfully reproduced Adobe Photoshop 7.0 and Microsoft Office 97 Professional since 2003, which was a violation of Article 72 (3) of the Law No. 19 of 2002 on Copyright. BSA claimed the loss of profit in amount of USD 1,200 per year for every software.
In addition, BSA also requested the Court to decide that PT Multisari must issue an apology in one full page in national and international newspapers for three days in a row and pay a fine of USD 5000 per day.
On the other hand, Setiawan Adi, another PT Multisari’s in-house counsel, asserted that BSA has blackmailed PT Multisari (13/7). He admitted, however, that BSA’s blackmail is different compared to Indonesian Criminal Code (“KUHP”) concept.
“BSA is asking PT Multisari to pay them money without any legitimate letters. That is essentially blackmail,” explained Setiawan.
Setiawan emphasized that BSA Indonesia’s office is fictional as BSA failed to provide their Taxpayer Registration Number. He claimed that he has checked BSA Indonesia’s office in Sampoerna Strategic and found that there was not even a single employee there. Setiawan claimed that it was a virtual office, which means that BSA basically does not have an office.
Setiawan also criticized BSA’s legal action. As a non-profit organization, Setiawan said, BSA should have promoted and educated (“IPR”), instead of taking legal action.
“I mean, they [BSA] as an American non-profit organization, how could they became a menace in Indonesia? As an Indonesian, I feel like our sovereignty was violated,” said Setiawan.
(hot/jt)
Happy Stephany, Salma Izzatii
Business Software Alliance (“BSA”) denied having blackmailed PT Multisari Langgengjaya’s (“PT Multisari”). BSA also claimed that it has the right to represent copyright owners through their authorization letters. These arguments were delivered by BSA during a trial at Central Jakarta District Court, Monday (9/7).
Prior to this trial, Insan Budi Maulana, PT Multisari’s in-house counsel, stated that BSA has blackmailed PT Multisari by imposing fines on his client without any legal basis. Insan asserted that there have not been any evidence nor court decisions that state that PT Multisari has done any software piracy. PT Multisari also alleged that BSA Indonesia’s address is fictional.
BSA replied to PT Multisari’s first argument stating that imposing fines is not a form of blackmail. As stated in their file, on September 2011 PT Multisari offered conciliation with BSA after admitting to using pirated software. BSA accepted this offer with several conditions, one of them being USD 10,000 compensation, and BSA was open for further negotiation.
BSA also claimed to own the Letter of Authorization (“LoA”) of several copyright owners. BSA further elaborated that Microsoft Corporation has given its LoA on 24 March 2009, Tekla Corporation on 28 October 2009, AutodeskInc. on 29 October 2009, Adobe Systems Incorporated on 9 November 2009, and lastly Siemens Product Lifecycle Management Software Inc on 1 July 2011.
Based on these LoAs, BSA claimed to have the right to act on behalf of these copyright owners to discuss, negotiate, and approve documents. BSA also claimed to have the rights to sue the end-user of these pirated software.
Lastly, BSA asserted that the address of BSA Indonesia is not fictional. BSA Indonesia’s address is written as follows: Sampoerna Strategic Square-Tower B, Lantai 19 Jalan Jenderal Sudirman Kav. 45-46 Karet Semanggi, Setiabudi, Jakarta Selatan.
BSA’s assertion is affirmed with the evidence of Business Permit of Foreign Trade Representatives No. SIT.114/P-4/Nas/P3A/PDN.2/2/2011 dated 23 February 2011, BSA Indonesia Company Registration Certificate No. No.TDP 09.03.6.74.01205, dated 15 Agustus 2007, and Certificate of Domicile issued by PT The Executive Centre Indonesia Ref.TECI/040/SKD/12 dated 14 June 2012.
BSA also submitted a counterclaim for PT Multisari to recover damages of USD 10,800. BSA claimed that PT Multisari has unlawfully reproduced Adobe Photoshop 7.0 and Microsoft Office 97 Professional since 2003, which was a violation of Article 72 (3) of the Law No. 19 of 2002 on Copyright. BSA claimed the loss of profit in amount of USD 1,200 per year for every software.
In addition, BSA also requested the Court to decide that PT Multisari must issue an apology in one full page in national and international newspapers for three days in a row and pay a fine of USD 5000 per day.
On the other hand, Setiawan Adi, another PT Multisari’s in-house counsel, asserted that BSA has blackmailed PT Multisari (13/7). He admitted, however, that BSA’s blackmail is different compared to Indonesian Criminal Code (“KUHP”) concept.
“BSA is asking PT Multisari to pay them money without any legitimate letters. That is essentially blackmail,” explained Setiawan.
Setiawan emphasized that BSA Indonesia’s office is fictional as BSA failed to provide their Taxpayer Registration Number. He claimed that he has checked BSA Indonesia’s office in Sampoerna Strategic and found that there was not even a single employee there. Setiawan claimed that it was a virtual office, which means that BSA basically does not have an office.
Setiawan also criticized BSA’s legal action. As a non-profit organization, Setiawan said, BSA should have promoted and educated (“IPR”), instead of taking legal action.
“I mean, they [BSA] as an American non-profit organization, how could they became a menace in Indonesia? As an Indonesian, I feel like our sovereignty was violated,” said Setiawan.
(hot/jt)