Outsourcing Dilemma Calling For The Right Solution

Fitri Novia Heriani, Salma Izzatii

Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kamar Dagang dan Industri – Kadin) stated that the outsourcing issue in Indonesia needs a right solution that would benefit both parties invoved: the employer and the employees.

During a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (10/7), Haryadi B. Sukamdi, the Vice Chairman of Monetary, Fiscal, and Public Policy Division at Kadin, elaborated that the outsourcing implementation has not reached its objectives of improving the effectiveness of companies.

“There is still ambiguity in determining compensation funds for both fixed-term employment contracts (“PKWT”) and permanent employment contracts (“PKWTT”),” Haryadi said. So far, there is no clearly written stipulation on who is responsible for the payment of the compensation funds.

In addition to that, there is also a discrimination issue between outsourcing and non-outsourcing workers. Haryadi believes there should be a mutual agreement between the outsourcing company and the company that uses outsourcing devices (“user”) to determine compensation funds for both the PKWT and PKWTT workers.

Iftida Yasar, Vice Chairman of Standing Committee of Manpower at Kadin, proposed a solution for the dilemma. The solution involves five parties related to the outsourcing business. First, the Government must establish an oversight system with certified supervisors, along with applicable regulation standard both in central and local levels.

Second, the user must draw a cooperation scheme that protects the rights of workers. Users must keep in mind that outsourcing is not for cost reduction, but to improve effectiveness and productivity that prioritize well-being of workers.

Third, the outsourcing company must show professionalism and its compliance in order to become a reliable business partner with good competency and productivity. Fourth, the workers themselves have to improve their competency to improve their competitiveness. Lastly, Iftida hoped for the establishment of an independent body or provision on determining the amount of compensation fund.

R. Irianto Simbolon, Director-General of Industrial Relations Development and Workers Social Security, explained that outsourcing has been practiced in Indonesia since the issuance of Constitutional Court Decision No. 27 of 2011. Through the Decision, every outsourcing worker has the same rights as non-outsourcing workers.

Irianto suggested that the user has the obligation to improve the quality of human resources and outsourcing workers. Customers have to give a proportional honorarium to the workers according to their working period.

He also suggested that the outsourcing company must set a standard for the workers, ensure the continuance of working relations, and establish an access to monitor the implementation of employment contracts between the workers and the customers.

On the other hand, Chairman of Indonesia Outsourcing Association (“IOA”), Wisnu Wibowo, asserted that all companies in IOA have practiced outsourcing in a good manner. Wisnu highlighted that outsourcing workers received higher bonus and allowances, to balance out the fact that they would not receive any compensation fund at termination of employment.

Wisnu also criticized the Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor. “The Manpower Law does not distinguish the difference in compensation money paid to the worker, even though termination of employment is based on two different bases: disciplinary reasons and crimes that detriment the company,” he explained. “Surely it is not fair not to differentiate between the two. The Law should have covered this issue.”

(hot/jt)

Fitri Novia Heriani, Salma Izzatii

Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kamar Dagang dan Industri – Kadin) stated that the outsourcing issue in Indonesia needs a right solution that would benefit both parties invoved: the employer and the employees.

During a discussion in Jakarta, Tuesday (10/7), Haryadi B. Sukamdi, the Vice Chairman of Monetary, Fiscal, and Public Policy Division at Kadin, elaborated that the outsourcing implementation has not reached its objectives of improving the effectiveness of companies.

“There is still ambiguity in determining compensation funds for both fixed-term employment contracts (“PKWT”) and permanent employment contracts (“PKWTT”),” Haryadi said. So far, there is no clearly written stipulation on who is responsible for the payment of the compensation funds.

In addition to that, there is also a discrimination issue between outsourcing and non-outsourcing workers. Haryadi believes there should be a mutual agreement between the outsourcing company and the company that uses outsourcing devices (“user”) to determine compensation funds for both the PKWT and PKWTT workers.

Iftida Yasar, Vice Chairman of Standing Committee of Manpower at Kadin, proposed a solution for the dilemma. The solution involves five parties related to the outsourcing business. First, the Government must establish an oversight system with certified supervisors, along with applicable regulation standard both in central and local levels.

Second, the user must draw a cooperation scheme that protects the rights of workers. Users must keep in mind that outsourcing is not for cost reduction, but to improve effectiveness and productivity that prioritize well-being of workers.

Third, the outsourcing company must show professionalism and its compliance in order to become a reliable business partner with good competency and productivity. Fourth, the workers themselves have to improve their competency to improve their competitiveness. Lastly, Iftida hoped for the establishment of an independent body or provision on determining the amount of compensation fund.

R. Irianto Simbolon, Director-General of Industrial Relations Development and Workers Social Security, explained that outsourcing has been practiced in Indonesia since the issuance of Constitutional Court Decision No. 27 of 2011. Through the Decision, every outsourcing worker has the same rights as non-outsourcing workers.

Irianto suggested that the user has the obligation to improve the quality of human resources and outsourcing workers. Customers have to give a proportional honorarium to the workers according to their working period.

He also suggested that the outsourcing company must set a standard for the workers, ensure the continuance of working relations, and establish an access to monitor the implementation of employment contracts between the workers and the customers.

On the other hand, Chairman of Indonesia Outsourcing Association (“IOA”), Wisnu Wibowo, asserted that all companies in IOA have practiced outsourcing in a good manner. Wisnu highlighted that outsourcing workers received higher bonus and allowances, to balance out the fact that they would not receive any compensation fund at termination of employment.

Wisnu also criticized the Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor. “The Manpower Law does not distinguish the difference in compensation money paid to the worker, even though termination of employment is based on two different bases: disciplinary reasons and crimes that detriment the company,” he explained. “Surely it is not fair not to differentiate between the two. The Law should have covered this issue.”

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info