IKAHI is preparing for judicial review on the Bill on Juvenile Justice System

Agus Sahbani, Salma Izzatii

Indonesian Judges Association (Ikatan Hakim Indonesia – “IKAHI”) is preparing a judicial review petition on Juvenile Delinquency Justice System Bill (“Bill”), which has just been passed by the House of Representatives on 3 July 2012. IKAHI expressed its disagreement regarding provisions in the Bill that criminalize law enforcement officials, particularly judges.

“Though I agree that the Bill must emphasize on juvenile protection, criminalization on law enforcement officers is too much,” said Djoko Sarwoko, Spokesman of Supreme Court, Monday (9/7).

The Bill itself sets out several criminal sanctions for court officials, including imprisonment, which ranges from two to five years at maximum; and fines, which ranges from IDR 200 million to IDR 500 million at maximum.

These sanctions are imposed in the circumstances where the officials detain a juvenile past a time limit set out in this Bill, fail to give a copy of the decision on the same day the decision was made, or fail to make any effort for diversion.

Djoko believed the administrative sanctions covered in Chapter XI of the Bill are enough and further criminalization on judges is unnecessary. Further, he viewed the criminalization as jeopardicing judges’ independency.

Independency of judges is granted under Article 24 of the 1945 Constitution and it is usually followed by judicial immunity. Djoko considered the Bill’s criminalization on law enforcement officers as legislative tyranny and inconsistent with the 1945 Constitution.

“We are waiting for the Bill to be enacted as law so that we can apply for a judicial review to the Constitutional Court,” Djoko said. He expected fellow law enforcement officials, such as police forces and prosecutors, to join in the Bill’s judicial review lawsuit.

On a side note, Vice President of Judicial Commission Imam Anshori Saleh agreed with IKAHI’s decision to seek remedy. Imam has the same opinion with Djoko that judges deserve judicial immunity in doing their job. “Defiance in detention period is a procedural matter that is tolerable and should not result in criminalization”, he added.

(hot/jt)

Agus Sahbani, Salma Izzatii

Indonesian Judges Association (Ikatan Hakim Indonesia – “IKAHI”) is preparing a judicial review petition on Juvenile Delinquency Justice System Bill (“Bill”), which has just been passed by the House of Representatives on 3 July 2012. IKAHI expressed its disagreement regarding provisions in the Bill that criminalize law enforcement officials, particularly judges.

“Though I agree that the Bill must emphasize on juvenile protection, criminalization on law enforcement officers is too much,” said Djoko Sarwoko, Spokesman of Supreme Court, Monday (9/7).

The Bill itself sets out several criminal sanctions for court officials, including imprisonment, which ranges from two to five years at maximum; and fines, which ranges from IDR 200 million to IDR 500 million at maximum.

These sanctions are imposed in the circumstances where the officials detain a juvenile past a time limit set out in this Bill, fail to give a copy of the decision on the same day the decision was made, or fail to make any effort for diversion.

Djoko believed the administrative sanctions covered in Chapter XI of the Bill are enough and further criminalization on judges is unnecessary. Further, he viewed the criminalization as jeopardicing judges’ independency.

Independency of judges is granted under Article 24 of the 1945 Constitution and it is usually followed by judicial immunity. Djoko considered the Bill’s criminalization on law enforcement officers as legislative tyranny and inconsistent with the 1945 Constitution.

“We are waiting for the Bill to be enacted as law so that we can apply for a judicial review to the Constitutional Court,” Djoko said. He expected fellow law enforcement officials, such as police forces and prosecutors, to join in the Bill’s judicial review lawsuit.

On a side note, Vice President of Judicial Commission Imam Anshori Saleh agreed with IKAHI’s decision to seek remedy. Imam has the same opinion with Djoko that judges deserve judicial immunity in doing their job. “Defiance in detention period is a procedural matter that is tolerable and should not result in criminalization”, he added.

(hot/jt)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info