Fitri Novia Heriani, Indra A Pambudy
On 15 June 2012, the Supreme Court of Indonesia affirmed East Kutai Regent’s decision to revoke the mining licenses of Britain-based Churchill Mining PLC (“Churchill”).
Churchill simultaneously proceeded with an international investment arbitration claim before the International Center for Settlement Dispute (“ICSID”) against the Government of Indonesia on the grounds of asset expropriation.
Churchill claims that it owns four coal mining concessions in the East Kutai Regency, East Kalimantan, through 75% ownership of its subsidiary, Ridlatama. Churchill’s claim before ICSID amounts to USD 2 billion based on an estimate that the concessions would produce up to USD 1 billion in annual revenue for twenty years.
In 2010, the East Kutai Regent revoked Ridlatama’s mining licenses, citing two reasons. First, that the license to own these concessions had been forged. This is based on a 2008 audit by the Supreme Audit Agency (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan – “BPK”).
Second, Churchill never obtained a permit from the Ministry of Forestry. Churchill’s concessions were located within areas “designated as timber-production forest” and the Ministry of Forestry’s permit is necessary to operate a mine in these areas.
The Kutai Regent, Iskan Noor, is convinced that the Indonesian Government would win the case. “On procedure alone, Churchill did not specify in its request for arbitration its ownership of Ridlatama and thus it lacks the standing to file the claim,” Iskan stated.
Ridlatama explained to the East Kutai Regency Government that it is 100% locally owned and its relationship with Churchill was merely based on a Master Service Agreement. On the other hand, the Indonesian Government asserted that Churchill did not own 75% of Ridlatama.
On its part, Churchill had not specified on its website the grounds to substantiate its claim at the time this writing went to publication. It merely stated the Indonesian Government had breached its obligation under a bilateral investment treaty with Britain.
(hot/jt)
Fitri Novia Heriani, Indra A Pambudy
On 15 June 2012, the Supreme Court of Indonesia affirmed East Kutai Regent’s decision to revoke the mining licenses of Britain-based Churchill Mining PLC (“Churchill”).
Churchill simultaneously proceeded with an international investment arbitration claim before the International Center for Settlement Dispute (“ICSID”) against the Government of Indonesia on the grounds of asset expropriation.
Churchill claims that it owns four coal mining concessions in the East Kutai Regency, East Kalimantan, through 75% ownership of its subsidiary, Ridlatama. Churchill’s claim before ICSID amounts to USD 2 billion based on an estimate that the concessions would produce up to USD 1 billion in annual revenue for twenty years.
In 2010, the East Kutai Regent revoked Ridlatama’s mining licenses, citing two reasons. First, that the license to own these concessions had been forged. This is based on a 2008 audit by the Supreme Audit Agency (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan – “BPK”).
Second, Churchill never obtained a permit from the Ministry of Forestry. Churchill’s concessions were located within areas “designated as timber-production forest” and the Ministry of Forestry’s permit is necessary to operate a mine in these areas.
The Kutai Regent, Iskan Noor, is convinced that the Indonesian Government would win the case. “On procedure alone, Churchill did not specify in its request for arbitration its ownership of Ridlatama and thus it lacks the standing to file the claim,” Iskan stated.
Ridlatama explained to the East Kutai Regency Government that it is 100% locally owned and its relationship with Churchill was merely based on a Master Service Agreement. On the other hand, the Indonesian Government asserted that Churchill did not own 75% of Ridlatama.
On its part, Churchill had not specified on its website the grounds to substantiate its claim at the time this writing went to publication. It merely stated the Indonesian Government had breached its obligation under a bilateral investment treaty with Britain.
(hot/jt)