Muhammad Yasin, Happy Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Article 5 (1) of Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates (“Advocates Law”) stipulates that lawyers are categorized as independent law enforcers. However, the Article is considered unclear in defining lawyer status as that of a ‘law enforcer’. The uncertainty may lead to the revision of the Advocates Law.
In a discussion on the “Urgency of Lawyers in Legal and Government System in Accordance with the 1945 Constitution” at Jakarta on Tuesday (12/6), Akil Mochtar, a constitutional judge, stated that there should be an elaboration of the ‘law enforcer’ status imposed on lawyers, such as the purpose and the implication on the status of the lawyers itself.
Furthermore, Akil said that the interpretation of the term ‘law enforcer’ should be clarified. “If lawyers are deemed to be ‘law enforcers’, then does this provide them with powers that are equal to those of police, attorneys, or judges?” Akil asked.
To solve this problem, Akil suggested the Advocates Law should be revised and the term “law enforcer”, as it refers to lawyers, should be reviewed. He said that the provision in Article 5 (1) is related to stipulation on ‘single organization’ in Article 28 (1) of the Advocates Law. As an example, police and attorneys are united under an organization – the National Police and District Attorneys; and judges are united under Indonesian Judges Association (IKAHI).
Hasanuddin Nasution, Secretary General of the Indonesian Lawyers Association (PERADI), stated that the status has put lawyers on equal grounds with police and attorneys. He suggested that lawyers must act in accordance and in compliance with prevailing laws and regulations.
However, Hasanuddin confirmed the status contradiction and, as a consequence, lawyers must not defend their clients indiscriminately, due to their obligation to uphold the law as a ‘law enforcer’.
Meanwhile, Nudirman Munir, a Golkar Faction politician, expressed a tone of disagreement. He argued that the Advocates Law has raised the lawyers’ dignity and this condition should be preserved. He added that even with the current condition, lawyers are often being disgraced by other law enforcers.
Nudirman even added that any revisions on Advocates Law should strengthen lawyers’ position by allowing them to take legal action against other law enforcers who violate laws or regulations. “I have a strong conviction that the Advocates Law should be revised [in favor of lawyers],” he said.
(jt/hot)
Muhammad Yasin, Happy Stephany, Mahinda Arkyasa
Article 5 (1) of Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates (“Advocates Law”) stipulates that lawyers are categorized as independent law enforcers. However, the Article is considered unclear in defining lawyer status as that of a ‘law enforcer’. The uncertainty may lead to the revision of the Advocates Law.
In a discussion on the “Urgency of Lawyers in Legal and Government System in Accordance with the 1945 Constitution” at Jakarta on Tuesday (12/6), Akil Mochtar, a constitutional judge, stated that there should be an elaboration of the ‘law enforcer’ status imposed on lawyers, such as the purpose and the implication on the status of the lawyers itself.
Furthermore, Akil said that the interpretation of the term ‘law enforcer’ should be clarified. “If lawyers are deemed to be ‘law enforcers’, then does this provide them with powers that are equal to those of police, attorneys, or judges?” Akil asked.
To solve this problem, Akil suggested the Advocates Law should be revised and the term “law enforcer”, as it refers to lawyers, should be reviewed. He said that the provision in Article 5 (1) is related to stipulation on ‘single organization’ in Article 28 (1) of the Advocates Law. As an example, police and attorneys are united under an organization – the National Police and District Attorneys; and judges are united under Indonesian Judges Association (IKAHI).
Hasanuddin Nasution, Secretary General of the Indonesian Lawyers Association (PERADI), stated that the status has put lawyers on equal grounds with police and attorneys. He suggested that lawyers must act in accordance and in compliance with prevailing laws and regulations.
However, Hasanuddin confirmed the status contradiction and, as a consequence, lawyers must not defend their clients indiscriminately, due to their obligation to uphold the law as a ‘law enforcer’.
Meanwhile, Nudirman Munir, a Golkar Faction politician, expressed a tone of disagreement. He argued that the Advocates Law has raised the lawyers’ dignity and this condition should be preserved. He added that even with the current condition, lawyers are often being disgraced by other law enforcers.
Nudirman even added that any revisions on Advocates Law should strengthen lawyers’ position by allowing them to take legal action against other law enforcers who violate laws or regulations. “I have a strong conviction that the Advocates Law should be revised [in favor of lawyers],” he said.
(jt/hot)