Muhammad Yasin, Mahinda Arkyasa
Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates (“Advocates Law”) may have mandated the establishment of a single bar association. However, the fact remains that there is currently more than one lawyer organization with different agendas. Therefore, some said that Advocates Law revision can be an opportunity to introduce the multiple bar association system.
“Looking back in history and Indonesia’s condition, multiple bar association may be a better policy,” said Todung Mulya Lubis, in a discussion on advocates at Jakarta, Tuesday (12/6).
Todung asserted that the multiple bar association policy is a feasible option to overcome the disputes within the lawyer organizations that have arisen in the last few years. “Continuous disputes between lawyers hindered the associations’ role,” he said. Furthermore, he explained that the bar associations should be united under a federation.
Laica Marzuki, a former constitutional judge, said that a single bar association policy may seem to be the best option while drafting of the Advocates Law. However, the unimaginable disputes between lawyer organizations have rendered the policy ineffective and useless.
The associations or organizations, Laica continued, are merely tools and not the main goal. Therefore, the tools should be designed for the purpose of achieving the goal. “When the members of a single bar association realized that the association can no longer unite them, then they could go and establish an advocates federation,” he explained.
Laica confirmed that the 1945 Constitution has guaranteed the freedom of association and he stated that lawyers have the liberty to decide on the adoption of the form of organizational system.
He said that one of the articles that should be revised is Article 28 (1) of the Advocates Law, which stipulates the single bar association system.
Akil Mochtar, a constitutional judge, said that there were nine review applications received by the Consitutional Court on the Advocates Law. “The [Advocates] Law is a problematic legislation,” he asserted.
Meanwhile, Nudirman Munir, a member of Commission III of the House of Representatives (the House) explained that the Advocates Law revision draft bill was already received by the Legislation Body of the House in 2011. The draft bill, however, was not included in the National Legislation Program of 2012 (Prolegnas 2012), which makes it harder to be revised in the near future.
(hot/jt)
Muhammad Yasin, Mahinda Arkyasa
Law No. 18 of 2003 on Advocates (“Advocates Law”) may have mandated the establishment of a single bar association. However, the fact remains that there is currently more than one lawyer organization with different agendas. Therefore, some said that Advocates Law revision can be an opportunity to introduce the multiple bar association system.
“Looking back in history and Indonesia’s condition, multiple bar association may be a better policy,” said Todung Mulya Lubis, in a discussion on advocates at Jakarta, Tuesday (12/6).
Todung asserted that the multiple bar association policy is a feasible option to overcome the disputes within the lawyer organizations that have arisen in the last few years. “Continuous disputes between lawyers hindered the associations’ role,” he said. Furthermore, he explained that the bar associations should be united under a federation.
Laica Marzuki, a former constitutional judge, said that a single bar association policy may seem to be the best option while drafting of the Advocates Law. However, the unimaginable disputes between lawyer organizations have rendered the policy ineffective and useless.
The associations or organizations, Laica continued, are merely tools and not the main goal. Therefore, the tools should be designed for the purpose of achieving the goal. “When the members of a single bar association realized that the association can no longer unite them, then they could go and establish an advocates federation,” he explained.
Laica confirmed that the 1945 Constitution has guaranteed the freedom of association and he stated that lawyers have the liberty to decide on the adoption of the form of organizational system.
He said that one of the articles that should be revised is Article 28 (1) of the Advocates Law, which stipulates the single bar association system.
Akil Mochtar, a constitutional judge, said that there were nine review applications received by the Consitutional Court on the Advocates Law. “The [Advocates] Law is a problematic legislation,” he asserted.
Meanwhile, Nudirman Munir, a member of Commission III of the House of Representatives (the House) explained that the Advocates Law revision draft bill was already received by the Legislation Body of the House in 2011. The draft bill, however, was not included in the National Legislation Program of 2012 (Prolegnas 2012), which makes it harder to be revised in the near future.
(hot/jt)