The Constitutional Court Decision Paralyzes Deputy Ministers

Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Under decision No. 79/PUU-IX/2011, the Constitutional Court (MK) has declared on Tuesday (5/6) that the elucidation of Article 10 of Law No. 39 of 2008 on State Ministries (State Ministries Law) is unconstitutional. The decision was issued following a judicial review application No. 79/PUU-IX/2011, which was submitted by the National Movement of Corruption Eradication (GN-PK).

The applicant asserted that the elucidation of Article 10 of the State Ministries Law, which defines the position of deputy minister, is unconstitutional because Article 17 of the 1945 Constitution does not stipulate deputy ministers.

“[Constitutionally], deputy ministers are exist, but the appointment of deputy based on Article 10 elucidation is unconstitutional,” said MK’s spokesman Akil Mochtar,  at MK office, Tuesday (5/6).

Therefore, he urged the President to revise any presidential decree related to the position of deputy ministers .

Furthermore, Akil said that deputy ministers will be considered as a vacant position, as long as the decrees have not been revised. “The position exists, but the occupant will be in a status quo until the decrees are revised,” he said.

He explained that the elucidation of Article 10 has created a legal uncertainty because it lacks of provision on giving a recommendation for deputy ministers, the legal standing of the position, and the term of office.

Yusril Ihza Mahendra, State Administrative Law experts from Universitas Indonesia stated, since MK’s decision was issued, deputy ministers are not allowed to conduct any activity, even though they are still allowed to occupy the position. Yusril even suggested that the President should issue a new decree in accordance with MK’s decision.

Meanwhile, Mualimin Abdi, Director of Litigation at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, said that MK’s decision does not have any significant consequence. “[…] there is no problem with the current deputy ministers. However, any presidential decree regarding Deputy Ministerss have to be revised to prevent the absence of deputy ministers,” he said.

 “The new decree should emphasize that deputy ministers are political appointee members of the cabinet, not a bureaucrat,” he said in a press conference received by hukumonline on Tuesday (5/6).

On the other hand, Bukhori Yusuf, member of Commission III of the House of Representatives from the PKS Faction, stated that not all ministries should have deputy ministers. He added that ministries with light workload, tasks, and function do not need deputy ministers, such as Ministry of Law and Human Rights, Ministry of Agriculture, and Ministry of Religious Affairs.

“Take the Ministry of Law and Human Rights for example. Uncertainty of the Deputy Ministers task has caused the Deputy Ministers to conduct sensational actions. Even caused a complication between the Minister and the Deputy Minister,” he said to hukumonline on Tuesday (5/6).

Meanwhile, Denny Indrayana, Deputy Minister of the Minister of Law and Human Rights said, MK’s decision has fulfilled the Government expectation. “The elucidation of Article 10 of the State Ministries Law was indeed problematic, that is why we requested MK to revoke it,” he explains in his office, Tuesday (5/6).

In addition, Deny also explained that MK’s decision has opened the door for anybody to apply for the deputy ministers. “It does not have to be a civil servant. Individual from any background can be a deputy minister,” he said.

(hot/nov/ali/fat)

Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Under decision No. 79/PUU-IX/2011, the Constitutional Court (MK) has declared on Tuesday (5/6) that the elucidation of Article 10 of Law No. 39 of 2008 on State Ministries (State Ministries Law) is unconstitutional. The decision was issued following a judicial review application No. 79/PUU-IX/2011, which was submitted by the National Movement of Corruption Eradication (GN-PK).

The applicant asserted that the elucidation of Article 10 of the State Ministries Law, which defines the position of deputy minister, is unconstitutional because Article 17 of the 1945 Constitution does not stipulate deputy ministers.

“[Constitutionally], deputy ministers are exist, but the appointment of deputy based on Article 10 elucidation is unconstitutional,” said MK’s spokesman Akil Mochtar,  at MK office, Tuesday (5/6).

Therefore, he urged the President to revise any presidential decree related to the position of deputy ministers .

Furthermore, Akil said that deputy ministers will be considered as a vacant position, as long as the decrees have not been revised. “The position exists, but the occupant will be in a status quo until the decrees are revised,” he said.

He explained that the elucidation of Article 10 has created a legal uncertainty because it lacks of provision on giving a recommendation for deputy ministers, the legal standing of the position, and the term of office.

Yusril Ihza Mahendra, State Administrative Law experts from Universitas Indonesia stated, since MK’s decision was issued, deputy ministers are not allowed to conduct any activity, even though they are still allowed to occupy the position. Yusril even suggested that the President should issue a new decree in accordance with MK’s decision.

Meanwhile, Mualimin Abdi, Director of Litigation at the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, said that MK’s decision does not have any significant consequence. “[…] there is no problem with the current deputy ministers. However, any presidential decree regarding Deputy Ministerss have to be revised to prevent the absence of deputy ministers,” he said.

 “The new decree should emphasize that deputy ministers are political appointee members of the cabinet, not a bureaucrat,” he said in a press conference received by hukumonline on Tuesday (5/6).

On the other hand, Bukhori Yusuf, member of Commission III of the House of Representatives from the PKS Faction, stated that not all ministries should have deputy ministers. He added that ministries with light workload, tasks, and function do not need deputy ministers, such as Ministry of Law and Human Rights, Ministry of Agriculture, and Ministry of Religious Affairs.

“Take the Ministry of Law and Human Rights for example. Uncertainty of the Deputy Ministers task has caused the Deputy Ministers to conduct sensational actions. Even caused a complication between the Minister and the Deputy Minister,” he said to hukumonline on Tuesday (5/6).

Meanwhile, Denny Indrayana, Deputy Minister of the Minister of Law and Human Rights said, MK’s decision has fulfilled the Government expectation. “The elucidation of Article 10 of the State Ministries Law was indeed problematic, that is why we requested MK to revoke it,” he explains in his office, Tuesday (5/6).

In addition, Deny also explained that MK’s decision has opened the door for anybody to apply for the deputy ministers. “It does not have to be a civil servant. Individual from any background can be a deputy minister,” he said.

(hot/nov/ali/fat)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info