Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
The Constitutional Court (MK) has issued a decision to accommodate two judicial review applications on Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal Mining (Mining Law)—No. 25/PUU-VII/2010, submitted by Fatriansyah Aria and Fahrizan; and No. 30/PUU-VIII/2010, submitted by the Indonesian Lead Businesses Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Timah Indonesia – APTI) and Indonesian Public Mine Association (Asosiasi Pertambangan Rakyat Indonesia – Astrada) of the Bangka Belitung province.
“Partially granted the applicants request […]” said Mahfud MD, Chairman of the Panel of Judges on Monday (4/6).
Fatriansyah and Fahrizan requested MK to revoke Article 22 (e) and (f), and Article 52 (1) of the Mining Law. Meanwhile, Johan Murod, administrator of Astrada requested MK to revoke 11 articles, including Article 22 (a), (c), and (f), Articles 38, 51, 52 (1), 55 (1), 58 (1), 60, 61 (1), 75 (4), 172, and Article 173 (3).
The applicants argued that the articles are discriminatory and harmful to small-medium mining businesses, especially in Bangka Belitung. One of the problems cited is the minimum area of mining permit areas (WIUP) to acquire a mining permit (IUP).
The Mining Law stipulates a minimum WIUP of 5,000 hectares for minerals exploration (Article 52 (1)), 500 hectares for non-metal minerals exploration (Article 55 (1)), and 5,000 hectares for coal exploration (Article 58 (1)).
In the decision’s consideration section for review application No. 25/PUU-VIII/2010, MK asserted that Article 22 (f) of the Mining Law will potentially harm people’s rights to fulfill their economic necessities through mineral and coal mining activities.
Furthermore, the panel stated that Article 52 (1) discriminates against the applicants, who are mostly small-time miners. “The minimum area of 5,000 hectares has the potential to reduce or deprive mining business rights, because it is uncertain whether the 5,000 hectares area is available or not,” said Akil Mochtar, member of the panel of judges.
The same consideration was used to review Article 55 (1) and Article 61 (1) in review application No. 30/PUU-VIII/2010, which challenged the minimum WIUP of 500 hectares for non-metal minerals exploration permit and 5,000 hectares for coal exploration permit.
For application No. 25/PUU-VIII/2010, MK’s decision revoked the “and/or” phrase in Article 22 (e) and (f) and the phrase “with a minimum area of 5,000 hectares” in Article 52 (1).
Meanwhile, for application No. 30/PUU/VIII/2010, MK revoked the phrase “with a minimum area of 500 hectares” in Article 55 (1), the phrase “with a minimum area of 5,000 hectares” in Article 61 (1), and the phrase “through means of general auction” in Articles 51, 60, and 75 (4).
(am/hot)
Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
The Constitutional Court (MK) has issued a decision to accommodate two judicial review applications on Law No. 4 of 2009 on Minerals and Coal Mining (Mining Law)—No. 25/PUU-VII/2010, submitted by Fatriansyah Aria and Fahrizan; and No. 30/PUU-VIII/2010, submitted by the Indonesian Lead Businesses Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Timah Indonesia – APTI) and Indonesian Public Mine Association (Asosiasi Pertambangan Rakyat Indonesia – Astrada) of the Bangka Belitung province.
“Partially granted the applicants request […]” said Mahfud MD, Chairman of the Panel of Judges on Monday (4/6).
Fatriansyah and Fahrizan requested MK to revoke Article 22 (e) and (f), and Article 52 (1) of the Mining Law. Meanwhile, Johan Murod, administrator of Astrada requested MK to revoke 11 articles, including Article 22 (a), (c), and (f), Articles 38, 51, 52 (1), 55 (1), 58 (1), 60, 61 (1), 75 (4), 172, and Article 173 (3).
The applicants argued that the articles are discriminatory and harmful to small-medium mining businesses, especially in Bangka Belitung. One of the problems cited is the minimum area of mining permit areas (WIUP) to acquire a mining permit (IUP).
The Mining Law stipulates a minimum WIUP of 5,000 hectares for minerals exploration (Article 52 (1)), 500 hectares for non-metal minerals exploration (Article 55 (1)), and 5,000 hectares for coal exploration (Article 58 (1)).
In the decision’s consideration section for review application No. 25/PUU-VIII/2010, MK asserted that Article 22 (f) of the Mining Law will potentially harm people’s rights to fulfill their economic necessities through mineral and coal mining activities.
Furthermore, the panel stated that Article 52 (1) discriminates against the applicants, who are mostly small-time miners. “The minimum area of 5,000 hectares has the potential to reduce or deprive mining business rights, because it is uncertain whether the 5,000 hectares area is available or not,” said Akil Mochtar, member of the panel of judges.
The same consideration was used to review Article 55 (1) and Article 61 (1) in review application No. 30/PUU-VIII/2010, which challenged the minimum WIUP of 500 hectares for non-metal minerals exploration permit and 5,000 hectares for coal exploration permit.
For application No. 25/PUU-VIII/2010, MK’s decision revoked the “and/or” phrase in Article 22 (e) and (f) and the phrase “with a minimum area of 5,000 hectares” in Article 52 (1).
Meanwhile, for application No. 30/PUU/VIII/2010, MK revoked the phrase “with a minimum area of 500 hectares” in Article 55 (1), the phrase “with a minimum area of 5,000 hectares” in Article 61 (1), and the phrase “through means of general auction” in Articles 51, 60, and 75 (4).
(am/hot)