House of Representatives Demands Quick Results from Sukhoi Accident Investigation

M Agus Yozami, Mahinda Arkyasa

Commission V (Commission) of the House of Representatives summoned Minister of Transportation (Minister) EE Mangindaan; the National Search and Rescue Agency (Basarnas); the National Transportation Safety Committee (KNKT); the Meteorology, Climatology, and Geophysics Agency; PT Angkasa Pura II; and PT Trimarga Rekatama to a meeting about the Sukhoi 100 Superjet accident, on Monday (28/5).

The Commission lashed out question after question to the summoned institutions to demand faster results from the investigation of the accident, which took the lives of 45 people.

The Minister explained that prior to the flight, the Sukhoi Superjet 100 had secured several licenses from Government officials, including diplomatic clearance from the Ministry of International Affairs (No. 05099/Kons-20/IV/2012 dated 20 April 2012), security clearance from Indonesian Armed Forces (No. UD/0557/SIN.23/IV/2012 dated 23 April 2012), and flight clearance from the Directorate General of Air Transportation (No. 3241/0705/NONSCHED-INT/2012 dated 7 May 2012) for the Saigon-Halim Perdana Kusuma-Vientiane route.

“After the plane gained legal entry to Indonesia, the next phase was a [joy flight],” the Minister said.

The accident happened when the pilot descended the airplane from 10,000 feet to 6,000 and crashed into the face of Salak Mountain, West Java.

Tri S. Sunoko, Chief Executive Officer of PT Angkasa Pura II explained that Atang Sanjaya Airfield air traffic control (ATC) allowed the pilot to descend because the airplane was within the area of Atang Sanjaya Airfield, which is known as a training area, where 383 flight training has been held before.

“The ATC officer gave the instructions according to procedure,” Tri said.

Unsatisfied with Tri’s explanation, Commission member Malkan Amir questioned ATC’s decision to permit the pilot to descend to 6,000 feet when Salak Mountain’s elevation is 7,200.

“Why was permission given? ATC should have known the plane’s coordinates and position [with the help of radar],” he asked.

Commission member Josef A. Nae Soi spoke up to remind the audience that under Law No. 1 of 2009 on Aviation (Aviation Law), a public navigation service institution was supposed to be established by 2012.

Shifting the focus to KNKT, Commission Chairman Yasti Soepredjo Mokoagow and Deputy Chairman Mulyadi urged KNKT Chairman Kurniadi to announce the results of the investigation at a press conference within the next six months. “Not only on the internet,” Mulyadi said.

Responding to the pressure, Tatang Kurniadi, Chairman of KNKT, explained that the accident report cannot be rushed, because doing so will degrade KNKT’s credibility.

“According to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), the Sukhoi accident report should be finished in 12 months,” he said.

He also confirmed that KNKT is currently having a problem making a transcript of the Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) because most of the conversation was in the Russian language. However, KNKT has received some assistance from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to solve this problem.

“We ask the public to be patient, and not to urge [KNKT] to announce the result when the investigation is not finished yet,” Tatang said.

The Commission also summoned PT Asia Ground Utama; Assegaf, Hamzah and Partners Law Firm; and PT Jamsostek related to the joy flight permit, insurance claims, and Jamsostek insurance.

Commission member Ali Wongso Halomoan Sinaga questioned the amount of insurance proceeds that will be distributed to the victims’ beneficiaries, either from PT Trimarga Rekatama or from the Russian Embassy in Indonesia. He explained that the amount has to be in accordance with Minister of Transportation Regulation No. 77 of 2011 on Air Transportation Organizer Responsibilities (Permenhub 77/2011)—IDR 1.25 billion for each victim.

The Minister said that the Sukhoi insurance team will meet with the victims’ families to administer their claims. In addition, the Minster said that, so far, Sukhoi is willing to pay the IDR 1.25 billion amount stipulated in Permenhub 77/2011.

(am/hot)

M Agus Yozami, Mahinda Arkyasa

Commission V (Commission) of the House of Representatives summoned Minister of Transportation (Minister) EE Mangindaan; the National Search and Rescue Agency (Basarnas); the National Transportation Safety Committee (KNKT); the Meteorology, Climatology, and Geophysics Agency; PT Angkasa Pura II; and PT Trimarga Rekatama to a meeting about the Sukhoi 100 Superjet accident, on Monday (28/5).

The Commission lashed out question after question to the summoned institutions to demand faster results from the investigation of the accident, which took the lives of 45 people.

The Minister explained that prior to the flight, the Sukhoi Superjet 100 had secured several licenses from Government officials, including diplomatic clearance from the Ministry of International Affairs (No. 05099/Kons-20/IV/2012 dated 20 April 2012), security clearance from Indonesian Armed Forces (No. UD/0557/SIN.23/IV/2012 dated 23 April 2012), and flight clearance from the Directorate General of Air Transportation (No. 3241/0705/NONSCHED-INT/2012 dated 7 May 2012) for the Saigon-Halim Perdana Kusuma-Vientiane route.

“After the plane gained legal entry to Indonesia, the next phase was a [joy flight],” the Minister said.

The accident happened when the pilot descended the airplane from 10,000 feet to 6,000 and crashed into the face of Salak Mountain, West Java.

Tri S. Sunoko, Chief Executive Officer of PT Angkasa Pura II explained that Atang Sanjaya Airfield air traffic control (ATC) allowed the pilot to descend because the airplane was within the area of Atang Sanjaya Airfield, which is known as a training area, where 383 flight training has been held before.

“The ATC officer gave the instructions according to procedure,” Tri said.

Unsatisfied with Tri’s explanation, Commission member Malkan Amir questioned ATC’s decision to permit the pilot to descend to 6,000 feet when Salak Mountain’s elevation is 7,200.

“Why was permission given? ATC should have known the plane’s coordinates and position [with the help of radar],” he asked.

Commission member Josef A. Nae Soi spoke up to remind the audience that under Law No. 1 of 2009 on Aviation (Aviation Law), a public navigation service institution was supposed to be established by 2012.

Shifting the focus to KNKT, Commission Chairman Yasti Soepredjo Mokoagow and Deputy Chairman Mulyadi urged KNKT Chairman Kurniadi to announce the results of the investigation at a press conference within the next six months. “Not only on the internet,” Mulyadi said.

Responding to the pressure, Tatang Kurniadi, Chairman of KNKT, explained that the accident report cannot be rushed, because doing so will degrade KNKT’s credibility.

“According to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), the Sukhoi accident report should be finished in 12 months,” he said.

He also confirmed that KNKT is currently having a problem making a transcript of the Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) because most of the conversation was in the Russian language. However, KNKT has received some assistance from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to solve this problem.

“We ask the public to be patient, and not to urge [KNKT] to announce the result when the investigation is not finished yet,” Tatang said.

The Commission also summoned PT Asia Ground Utama; Assegaf, Hamzah and Partners Law Firm; and PT Jamsostek related to the joy flight permit, insurance claims, and Jamsostek insurance.

Commission member Ali Wongso Halomoan Sinaga questioned the amount of insurance proceeds that will be distributed to the victims’ beneficiaries, either from PT Trimarga Rekatama or from the Russian Embassy in Indonesia. He explained that the amount has to be in accordance with Minister of Transportation Regulation No. 77 of 2011 on Air Transportation Organizer Responsibilities (Permenhub 77/2011)—IDR 1.25 billion for each victim.

The Minister said that the Sukhoi insurance team will meet with the victims’ families to administer their claims. In addition, the Minster said that, so far, Sukhoi is willing to pay the IDR 1.25 billion amount stipulated in Permenhub 77/2011.

(am/hot)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info