Indigenous Land with Nickel Deposit Disputed

 

Ady TD Achmad, Indra A Pambudy

The Lelilef Sawai and Gemaf Villages in Central Halmahera (Halmahera Tengah – Halteng) Regency is a region rich in mineral resources, as demonstrated by the fact that domestic and foreign mining companies are currently exploring for nickel deposits in the area.

One of them is PT Weda Bay Nikel (WBN), which has been exploring and is set to expand into full-blown operation.

Local residents are worried because the French-owned company’s expansion will take over areas used by successive generations of indigenous people who live there.

“The corporation would build a factory over the land to process and explore the indigenous land,” which will affect the local economy and render the land uncultivable, Yosepus Burnama, a villager from Lelilef Sawai, said.

The core issue is not the expansion, but rather the compensation. According to Yosepus, there are lands already flattened by the corporation that have not been properly acquired.

The company offered IDR 8,000 (USD 0.85) per square meter, which is considered too low by some of the villagers. In Yosepus’ opinion, the offered rate should have been IDR 50,000 (USD 5.30) per square meter.

Seeking a Legal Remedy

As the local government was thought to be unable to provide an effective solution, the local residents brought their case to the National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM).

The Commission conducted an investigation in July 2011 and issued a recommendation. Unfortunately, the recommendation was not taken up by the relevant parties.

Not giving up, the parties raised the issue before the People’s Consultative Assembly (DPD). The DPD Committee concluded that the related parties should discuss the issue and reach a consensus, while the DPD will cross check with the Ministry of Forestry and the National Land Registration Office.

The DPD also appealed to WBN not to engage in activities on land that has not been acquired yet. Such conduct is permitted only after the land has been duly acquired.

Ferry J Mainassy, member of Projustisia Legal Aid Foundation, said that resolution would be achieved through litigation means, if necessary, but for now, efforts remain at the non-litigation level.

“The land acquisition should be based on available law, including Law No. 5 of 1960 on Basic Agrarian Law,” Ferry explained.

He argued that the land acquisition is not intended for public interest; therefore the process should be conducted through discussion and negotiation between the prospective buyer and landowners, rather than by eminent domain, which involves the government.

Regent Denied Intervening

Halteng Regent Al Yasin Ali stressed that the local government took no part in the pricing mechanism. He said the compensation was based on two considerations, the price of neighboring lands and negotiations between WBN and the residents, and the role of the local government was purely in socializing the pricing mechanism.

Based on the price of neighboring lands, Yasin said that the going rate was IDR 4,000-9,000 per square meter and up to IDR 15,000 if certified.

When asked if the land had been indigenously owned, he said no. “The land’s status was Forest for Limited Production (Hutan Produksi Terbatas – HPT, ed.), which is under the Ministry of Forestry and categorized as state lands,” Yasin explained.

Asked about WBN’s license, Yasin said that the company had already acquired a license. The land would be used for building a factory and supporting facilities to process nickel. Based on the size of the deposit, the company would be in production for over fifty years.

(hot/am)

 

Ady TD Achmad, Indra A Pambudy

The Lelilef Sawai and Gemaf Villages in Central Halmahera (Halmahera Tengah – Halteng) Regency is a region rich in mineral resources, as demonstrated by the fact that domestic and foreign mining companies are currently exploring for nickel deposits in the area.

One of them is PT Weda Bay Nikel (WBN), which has been exploring and is set to expand into full-blown operation.

Local residents are worried because the French-owned company’s expansion will take over areas used by successive generations of indigenous people who live there.

“The corporation would build a factory over the land to process and explore the indigenous land,” which will affect the local economy and render the land uncultivable, Yosepus Burnama, a villager from Lelilef Sawai, said.

The core issue is not the expansion, but rather the compensation. According to Yosepus, there are lands already flattened by the corporation that have not been properly acquired.

The company offered IDR 8,000 (USD 0.85) per square meter, which is considered too low by some of the villagers. In Yosepus’ opinion, the offered rate should have been IDR 50,000 (USD 5.30) per square meter.

Seeking a Legal Remedy

As the local government was thought to be unable to provide an effective solution, the local residents brought their case to the National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM).

The Commission conducted an investigation in July 2011 and issued a recommendation. Unfortunately, the recommendation was not taken up by the relevant parties.

Not giving up, the parties raised the issue before the People’s Consultative Assembly (DPD). The DPD Committee concluded that the related parties should discuss the issue and reach a consensus, while the DPD will cross check with the Ministry of Forestry and the National Land Registration Office.

The DPD also appealed to WBN not to engage in activities on land that has not been acquired yet. Such conduct is permitted only after the land has been duly acquired.

Ferry J Mainassy, member of Projustisia Legal Aid Foundation, said that resolution would be achieved through litigation means, if necessary, but for now, efforts remain at the non-litigation level.

“The land acquisition should be based on available law, including Law No. 5 of 1960 on Basic Agrarian Law,” Ferry explained.

He argued that the land acquisition is not intended for public interest; therefore the process should be conducted through discussion and negotiation between the prospective buyer and landowners, rather than by eminent domain, which involves the government.

Regent Denied Intervening

Halteng Regent Al Yasin Ali stressed that the local government took no part in the pricing mechanism. He said the compensation was based on two considerations, the price of neighboring lands and negotiations between WBN and the residents, and the role of the local government was purely in socializing the pricing mechanism.

Based on the price of neighboring lands, Yasin said that the going rate was IDR 4,000-9,000 per square meter and up to IDR 15,000 if certified.

When asked if the land had been indigenously owned, he said no. “The land’s status was Forest for Limited Production (Hutan Produksi Terbatas – HPT, ed.), which is under the Ministry of Forestry and categorized as state lands,” Yasin explained.

Asked about WBN’s license, Yasin said that the company had already acquired a license. The land would be used for building a factory and supporting facilities to process nickel. Based on the size of the deposit, the company would be in production for over fifty years.

(hot/am)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info