Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Another review of Article 7 (6a) of Law No. 4 of 2012 on the Amendment of Law No. 22 of 2011 on 2012 State Budget (2012 State Budget Revision Law) was filed at the Constitutional Court. Petitions for review were previously filed by Yusril Ihza Mahendra, former Minister of Justice and Human Rights, and the Society of People's Lawyers (Serikat Pengacara Rakyat).
This time, review has been requested by M Komarudin, Chairman of the Federation of Indonesian Labor Union Associations (FISBI), and Ahmad Daryoko, Chairman of the National Federation of Unions (KSN).
As previously reported, Article 7 (6a) states that the Government is authorized to adjust subsidized fuel prices if the Indonesian Crude Price (ICP) increases or decreases by more than 15 percent.
“Article 7 (6a) of the 2012 State Budget Revision Law will potentially harm the constitutional rights of the applicant,” said Andi M Asrun, FISBI’s legal counsel, in a preliminary examination at the Constitutional Court (MK), Monday (28/5).
He argued that any adjustment in the price of fuel price should be controlled by the House of Representatives and should not be determined by the free market price.
He added that speculation on the fuel price increase over the next six months will cause uncertainty in the price of basic necessities, which will burden the people.
Therefore, he asked MK to declare Article 7 (6a) in contradiction with the 1945 Constitution – specifically with Articles 1 (3), 23 (1), 28D (1), and Articles 33 (3) and (4).
Furthermore, Asrun asserted that Article 7 (6a) is not in accordance with the philosophical and sociological aspects of the lawmaking process, as stipulated in Law No. 12 of 2011 on Legislative Drafting. According to him, the 2012 State Budget Revision Law abandons the public interest.
In addition, he alleges that Article 7 (6a) violates MK’s Decision No. 02/PUU-I/2003 that repealed Article 28 (1) of Law No 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas—which stated that the domestic fuel price would be determined by free market mechanisms.
Meanwhile, Ahmad Daryoko asserted that Article 7 (6a) will negatively impact low-income workers. “Although we have been given a raise in minimum salary, the Article negates it. Therefore the Article should be repealed because it contradicts Articles 27 (2), and 28H of the 1945 Constitution,” he said.
In response, Akil Mochtar, Chairman of the Panel of judges, explained that the applicant’s arguments on the violation of constitutional rights and contradicting norms have to be improved. Therefore, the Panel gave 14 days to the applicant to revise the application.
(hot/am)
Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Another review of Article 7 (6a) of Law No. 4 of 2012 on the Amendment of Law No. 22 of 2011 on 2012 State Budget (2012 State Budget Revision Law) was filed at the Constitutional Court. Petitions for review were previously filed by Yusril Ihza Mahendra, former Minister of Justice and Human Rights, and the Society of People's Lawyers (Serikat Pengacara Rakyat).
This time, review has been requested by M Komarudin, Chairman of the Federation of Indonesian Labor Union Associations (FISBI), and Ahmad Daryoko, Chairman of the National Federation of Unions (KSN).
As previously reported, Article 7 (6a) states that the Government is authorized to adjust subsidized fuel prices if the Indonesian Crude Price (ICP) increases or decreases by more than 15 percent.
“Article 7 (6a) of the 2012 State Budget Revision Law will potentially harm the constitutional rights of the applicant,” said Andi M Asrun, FISBI’s legal counsel, in a preliminary examination at the Constitutional Court (MK), Monday (28/5).
He argued that any adjustment in the price of fuel price should be controlled by the House of Representatives and should not be determined by the free market price.
He added that speculation on the fuel price increase over the next six months will cause uncertainty in the price of basic necessities, which will burden the people.
Therefore, he asked MK to declare Article 7 (6a) in contradiction with the 1945 Constitution – specifically with Articles 1 (3), 23 (1), 28D (1), and Articles 33 (3) and (4).
Furthermore, Asrun asserted that Article 7 (6a) is not in accordance with the philosophical and sociological aspects of the lawmaking process, as stipulated in Law No. 12 of 2011 on Legislative Drafting. According to him, the 2012 State Budget Revision Law abandons the public interest.
In addition, he alleges that Article 7 (6a) violates MK’s Decision No. 02/PUU-I/2003 that repealed Article 28 (1) of Law No 22 of 2001 on Oil and Gas—which stated that the domestic fuel price would be determined by free market mechanisms.
Meanwhile, Ahmad Daryoko asserted that Article 7 (6a) will negatively impact low-income workers. “Although we have been given a raise in minimum salary, the Article negates it. Therefore the Article should be repealed because it contradicts Articles 27 (2), and 28H of the 1945 Constitution,” he said.
In response, Akil Mochtar, Chairman of the Panel of judges, explained that the applicant’s arguments on the violation of constitutional rights and contradicting norms have to be improved. Therefore, the Panel gave 14 days to the applicant to revise the application.
(hot/am)