Hospita Yulima S, Indra A. Pambudy
The Indonesian Supreme Court has ordered Singapore Airlines to compensate a passenger injured aboard its aircraft IDR 1.5 billion. In its decision, the Court affirmed the decision of the DKI Jakarta High Court, which had affirmed a South Jakarta District Court decision holding that Singapore Airlines committed willful misconduct resulting in the incident that caused the passenger’s injuries.
The plaintiff, Sigit Suciptoyono, was a passenger onboard a 747 jumbo jet during an incident at Chiang Kai-shek International Airport (now Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport) that occurred on 31 October 2000. It was proven in the South Jakarta District court that the accident resulted from the pilot’s attempt to take off from a runway that was closed for repair. Of the 159 passengers and 20 crewmembers aboard, 83 were killed, and 71 were injured.
Sigit suffered permanent disability in his fingers and right arm. He was traumatized and was unable to travel by plane as a result of the experience, effectively halting his career as a senior manager because he could no longer travel long distances.
Sigit was originally awarded IDR 1.0 billion in damages by the South Jakarta District Court. Upon appeal to the Jakarta High Court, he was awarded IDR 1.5 billion: IDR 504.3 million for his injuries and lost income and IDR 1.0 billion for immaterial losses, such as emotional trauma.
SQ’s Liability for Pilot Conduct
The District Court judgment was grounded on Singapore Airline’s obligation under the Warsaw Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules Relating to International Carriage by Air (Warsaw Convention). Article 17 of the Warsaw Convention provides that the carrier is liable for damages due to death or wounding of a passenger sustained during an onboard accident. Indonesia ratified the Warsaw Convention when it was still under Dutch Colonial rule, and it remains in force by way of the konkordasi doctrine.
Based on a statement issued by the Taiwanese Airport authority, the Court found that the pilot had ignored the airport authority’s warning not to take off. Under the doctrine of vicarious liability embodied in Article 20 of the Warsaw Convention, a carrier is liable for its agent’s failure to take all necessary measures to avoid harm. The pilot was later sacked.
Statute of Limitations Defense Rejected
The Court rejected Singapore Airlines’ defense of expiration of claim under the Warsaw Convention’s statute of limitations. In interpreting Article 29(1) of the Convention, the Court was persuaded by the opinion of aviation law expert K. Martono of Trisakti University. Martono opined that while a 2-year statute of limitations, beginning from when the aircraft arrived or ought to have arrived at its destination, is built into Article 29(1) of the Warsaw Convention, a passenger may claim after that period expires if he has previously initiated a legal action within the statutory period.
Although Sigit only filed the claim in Indonesia in 2007, seven years after the incident, the judgment ruled that the claim was not expired, as he had previously brought claims before US and Singaporean Courts. His claim was rejected in the US because he was not a US citizen, and he could not attend the hearing in Singapore due to his trauma of flying, resulting also in rejection.
(ds/am)
Hospita Yulima S, Indra A. Pambudy
The Indonesian Supreme Court has ordered Singapore Airlines to compensate a passenger injured aboard its aircraft IDR 1.5 billion. In its decision, the Court affirmed the decision of the DKI Jakarta High Court, which had affirmed a South Jakarta District Court decision holding that Singapore Airlines committed willful misconduct resulting in the incident that caused the passenger’s injuries.
The plaintiff, Sigit Suciptoyono, was a passenger onboard a 747 jumbo jet during an incident at Chiang Kai-shek International Airport (now Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport) that occurred on 31 October 2000. It was proven in the South Jakarta District court that the accident resulted from the pilot’s attempt to take off from a runway that was closed for repair. Of the 159 passengers and 20 crewmembers aboard, 83 were killed, and 71 were injured.
Sigit suffered permanent disability in his fingers and right arm. He was traumatized and was unable to travel by plane as a result of the experience, effectively halting his career as a senior manager because he could no longer travel long distances.
Sigit was originally awarded IDR 1.0 billion in damages by the South Jakarta District Court. Upon appeal to the Jakarta High Court, he was awarded IDR 1.5 billion: IDR 504.3 million for his injuries and lost income and IDR 1.0 billion for immaterial losses, such as emotional trauma.
SQ’s Liability for Pilot Conduct
The District Court judgment was grounded on Singapore Airline’s obligation under the Warsaw Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules Relating to International Carriage by Air (Warsaw Convention). Article 17 of the Warsaw Convention provides that the carrier is liable for damages due to death or wounding of a passenger sustained during an onboard accident. Indonesia ratified the Warsaw Convention when it was still under Dutch Colonial rule, and it remains in force by way of the konkordasi doctrine.
Based on a statement issued by the Taiwanese Airport authority, the Court found that the pilot had ignored the airport authority’s warning not to take off. Under the doctrine of vicarious liability embodied in Article 20 of the Warsaw Convention, a carrier is liable for its agent’s failure to take all necessary measures to avoid harm. The pilot was later sacked.
Statute of Limitations Defense Rejected
The Court rejected Singapore Airlines’ defense of expiration of claim under the Warsaw Convention’s statute of limitations. In interpreting Article 29(1) of the Convention, the Court was persuaded by the opinion of aviation law expert K. Martono of Trisakti University. Martono opined that while a 2-year statute of limitations, beginning from when the aircraft arrived or ought to have arrived at its destination, is built into Article 29(1) of the Warsaw Convention, a passenger may claim after that period expires if he has previously initiated a legal action within the statutory period.
Although Sigit only filed the claim in Indonesia in 2007, seven years after the incident, the judgment ruled that the claim was not expired, as he had previously brought claims before US and Singaporean Courts. His claim was rejected in the US because he was not a US citizen, and he could not attend the hearing in Singapore due to his trauma of flying, resulting also in rejection.
(ds/am)