Imam Hadi Wibowo, Batara Parlindungan
Anggara, Peradi’s Legal Aid Executive Director, furrowed his brow after reading three letters presented in a juvenile case regarding a defendant named BOW. The first letter is a power of attorney given by BOW to an unnamed advocate to defend him in a narcotics case.
The second is a statement letter stating that BOW was not willing to be represented by an advocate. The third is the official minutes of the proceeding stating that BOW refused to be accompanied by an advocate.
The first irregularity is the power of attorney, as BOW is a minor and is not competent to take a legal action such as giving a power of attorney. Second, the statement letter and the official minutes in which BOW refuses to be accompanied by an advocate were signed on the same day, when BOW was interrogated by police investigators in Central Jakarta.
When viewed together, it makes no sense that BOW would have signed a power of attorney, and then refused counsel a moment later, when facing a serious felony charge.
In Anggara’s many years of experience, he has often encountered such irregularities, usually befalling the less privileged.
Letters like BOW’s statement letter are often fabricated by investigators working under a mutual arrangement with “pocket lawyers” in order to fulfill administrative procedural requirements for cases in which by legislation, legal counsel must be present.
Fabricated letters are regularly produced to show that a suspect’s right to representation has been honored "just to meet the provisions of the Legal Aid Law," said Anggara to hukumonline on Tuesday (15/5).
Alvon Kurnia Palma, Chairman of the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (Yayasan Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Indonesia/YLBHI), said that many lawyers let themselves be used as tools to create the appearance that a suspect’s right to counsel has been honored.
This method is similar to BOW’s case. Alvon said that the practice is commonly called "pocket lawyer," which developed in the Balkans and Eastern Europe. According to Alvon, the practice of pocket lawyering prevents public access to justice. The pocket lawyer only considers formal procedural matters, and often runs counter to professionalism and legal ethics.
Alvon stated that in Indonesia, pocket lawyers are establishing mutually beneficial relationships with law enforcement officials. The officials need legitimacy to fulfill the legal aid requirements, while the pocket lawyer needs clients.
According to Alvon, if pocket lawyers do provide legal assistance, it is not rendered with professionalism. "In the Advocate Law and Advocate code of ethics, lawyers are required to provide the best legal services," said Alvon in a discussion in Jakarta on Tuesday (15/5).
On the same occasion, advocate Tony Budidjaja stated that there are two types of advocates. The first is the one who carries on his responsibilities as an advocate. The second is the opposite.
Alvon stated that pocket lawyer practice must be stopped immediately. In order to do that, advocates’ organizations must exercise greater supervision over their members. "Unfortunately these organizations are more preoccupied with internal disunity problems," said Alvon.
Alvon continued by saying that supervision of law enforcers who use pocket lawyers services must be closely scrutinized "in order to ensure that law enforcement officers meet all legal obligations to carry out their duties."
Anggara expressed similar views. According to him, the advocates’ organizations have an important role in supervising the practice of pocket lawyers "to protect the rights of justice seekers."
Anggara also hoped that courts will pay more attention to procedural irregularities such as BOW’s case. As of now, courts have the tendency to ignore procedural violations.
"The court, through its decision, must stop the practice of pocket lawyers, because if courts are reluctant, such practices will keep on continuing, "he concluded.
(dwas/am)
Imam Hadi Wibowo, Batara Parlindungan
Anggara, Peradi’s Legal Aid Executive Director, furrowed his brow after reading three letters presented in a juvenile case regarding a defendant named BOW. The first letter is a power of attorney given by BOW to an unnamed advocate to defend him in a narcotics case.
The second is a statement letter stating that BOW was not willing to be represented by an advocate. The third is the official minutes of the proceeding stating that BOW refused to be accompanied by an advocate.
The first irregularity is the power of attorney, as BOW is a minor and is not competent to take a legal action such as giving a power of attorney. Second, the statement letter and the official minutes in which BOW refuses to be accompanied by an advocate were signed on the same day, when BOW was interrogated by police investigators in Central Jakarta.
When viewed together, it makes no sense that BOW would have signed a power of attorney, and then refused counsel a moment later, when facing a serious felony charge.
In Anggara’s many years of experience, he has often encountered such irregularities, usually befalling the less privileged.
Letters like BOW’s statement letter are often fabricated by investigators working under a mutual arrangement with “pocket lawyers” in order to fulfill administrative procedural requirements for cases in which by legislation, legal counsel must be present.
Fabricated letters are regularly produced to show that a suspect’s right to representation has been honored "just to meet the provisions of the Legal Aid Law," said Anggara to hukumonline on Tuesday (15/5).
Alvon Kurnia Palma, Chairman of the Indonesian Legal Aid Foundation (Yayasan Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Indonesia/YLBHI), said that many lawyers let themselves be used as tools to create the appearance that a suspect’s right to counsel has been honored.
This method is similar to BOW’s case. Alvon said that the practice is commonly called "pocket lawyer," which developed in the Balkans and Eastern Europe. According to Alvon, the practice of pocket lawyering prevents public access to justice. The pocket lawyer only considers formal procedural matters, and often runs counter to professionalism and legal ethics.
Alvon stated that in Indonesia, pocket lawyers are establishing mutually beneficial relationships with law enforcement officials. The officials need legitimacy to fulfill the legal aid requirements, while the pocket lawyer needs clients.
According to Alvon, if pocket lawyers do provide legal assistance, it is not rendered with professionalism. "In the Advocate Law and Advocate code of ethics, lawyers are required to provide the best legal services," said Alvon in a discussion in Jakarta on Tuesday (15/5).
On the same occasion, advocate Tony Budidjaja stated that there are two types of advocates. The first is the one who carries on his responsibilities as an advocate. The second is the opposite.
Alvon stated that pocket lawyer practice must be stopped immediately. In order to do that, advocates’ organizations must exercise greater supervision over their members. "Unfortunately these organizations are more preoccupied with internal disunity problems," said Alvon.
Alvon continued by saying that supervision of law enforcers who use pocket lawyers services must be closely scrutinized "in order to ensure that law enforcement officers meet all legal obligations to carry out their duties."
Anggara expressed similar views. According to him, the advocates’ organizations have an important role in supervising the practice of pocket lawyers "to protect the rights of justice seekers."
Anggara also hoped that courts will pay more attention to procedural irregularities such as BOW’s case. As of now, courts have the tendency to ignore procedural violations.
"The court, through its decision, must stop the practice of pocket lawyers, because if courts are reluctant, such practices will keep on continuing, "he concluded.
(dwas/am)