Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Aside from the troubled purchase of seven percent of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (Newmont) shares by the Government, Indonesian Corruption Watch (ICW) highlighted yet another issue: the purchase of a 24 percent share of Newmont by local governments.
ICW and several members of the Sumbawa Province local House of Representatives (DPRD) have discovered discrepancies in an agreement between PT Daerah Maju Bersaing (PT DMB)—a local government owned enterprise—and PT Multi Capital.
The agreement stated that PT Multi Capital would provide a USD 4 million advance dividend to PT DMB, but this was really a disguised bailout loan.
“In 2010, PT DMB’s debt was around IDR 26 billion,” said Firdaus Ilyas, a researcher at ICW in a press conference on Thursday (10/5). However, by 2011, PT DMB had accumulated around IDR 241 billion of debt to PT Multi Capital.
According to Fitrah Rino, a member of the Sumbawa DPRD, PT Multi Capital was supposed to be responsible for the purchase of shares, not PT DMB—so how did PTDMB accumulate so much debt?
Firdaus explained that local government was supposed to receive around USD 55 million in dividends in 2010, equal to 25 percent of Newmont’s profit of around IDR 2 trillion.
However, local government only received USD 7.382 millionin dividends for 2011, which derived from USD 34 million reduced by IDR 26.5 billion of the 2011 debt.
He added that the dividend was actually an installment of the bailout received by PT DMB. “So actually there is no dividend, only a debt installment,” he said.
In addition to the dividend problem, the establishment of PT DMB is legally flawed. Firdaus explained that the establishment of a local government owned enterprise should be followed by the issuance of a local government regulation.
However, for PT DMB, the local government regulation was not issued until one year after the company was established.
“Due to the legal flaw, [PT BMD] is not a local government owned enterprise, it is privately owned,” Firdaus explained.
Based on all of these discrepancies, ICW urged the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (BPK) to investigate the purchase of 24 percent of Newmont shares and the agreement between local governments with PT Multi Capital.
ICW also asked the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) to investigate ICW’s report of USD 237 million state losses from 2004-2011 Newmont royalties.
On 18 March 2009, PT DMB was established based on an agreement between the Governor of NTB Province, Western Sumbawa Regency, and Sumbawa Regencyto represent local government ownership of 24 percent Newmont shares.
The establishment was based on a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between PT Bumi Resources (PT BR) and the local government of Nusa Tenggara Barat (NTB) Province and the Sumbawa Regency, dated 16 March 2007.
PT Multi Capital was established based on an agreement between PT DMB and PT BR, as a vehicle for purchasing the shares. On 23 July 2009, an agreement was entered between PT DMB and PT Multi Capital stating that PT DMB only owns 25 percent of Newmont shares, while PT Multi Capital Owns the other 75 percent.
(hot/am)
Fitri Novia Heriani, Mahinda Arkyasa
Aside from the troubled purchase of seven percent of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (Newmont) shares by the Government, Indonesian Corruption Watch (ICW) highlighted yet another issue: the purchase of a 24 percent share of Newmont by local governments.
ICW and several members of the Sumbawa Province local House of Representatives (DPRD) have discovered discrepancies in an agreement between PT Daerah Maju Bersaing (PT DMB)—a local government owned enterprise—and PT Multi Capital.
The agreement stated that PT Multi Capital would provide a USD 4 million advance dividend to PT DMB, but this was really a disguised bailout loan.
“In 2010, PT DMB’s debt was around IDR 26 billion,” said Firdaus Ilyas, a researcher at ICW in a press conference on Thursday (10/5). However, by 2011, PT DMB had accumulated around IDR 241 billion of debt to PT Multi Capital.
According to Fitrah Rino, a member of the Sumbawa DPRD, PT Multi Capital was supposed to be responsible for the purchase of shares, not PT DMB—so how did PTDMB accumulate so much debt?
Firdaus explained that local government was supposed to receive around USD 55 million in dividends in 2010, equal to 25 percent of Newmont’s profit of around IDR 2 trillion.
However, local government only received USD 7.382 millionin dividends for 2011, which derived from USD 34 million reduced by IDR 26.5 billion of the 2011 debt.
He added that the dividend was actually an installment of the bailout received by PT DMB. “So actually there is no dividend, only a debt installment,” he said.
In addition to the dividend problem, the establishment of PT DMB is legally flawed. Firdaus explained that the establishment of a local government owned enterprise should be followed by the issuance of a local government regulation.
However, for PT DMB, the local government regulation was not issued until one year after the company was established.
“Due to the legal flaw, [PT BMD] is not a local government owned enterprise, it is privately owned,” Firdaus explained.
Based on all of these discrepancies, ICW urged the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia (BPK) to investigate the purchase of 24 percent of Newmont shares and the agreement between local governments with PT Multi Capital.
ICW also asked the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) to investigate ICW’s report of USD 237 million state losses from 2004-2011 Newmont royalties.
On 18 March 2009, PT DMB was established based on an agreement between the Governor of NTB Province, Western Sumbawa Regency, and Sumbawa Regencyto represent local government ownership of 24 percent Newmont shares.
The establishment was based on a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between PT Bumi Resources (PT BR) and the local government of Nusa Tenggara Barat (NTB) Province and the Sumbawa Regency, dated 16 March 2007.
PT Multi Capital was established based on an agreement between PT DMB and PT BR, as a vehicle for purchasing the shares. On 23 July 2009, an agreement was entered between PT DMB and PT Multi Capital stating that PT DMB only owns 25 percent of Newmont shares, while PT Multi Capital Owns the other 75 percent.
(hot/am)