Government Authority Dispute in Newmont Divestment Continues

 

Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Eddy Suratman, a professor from the Economics Faculty of Tanjung Pura University, stated that the Government’s purchase of a seven percent share in PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (NNT) did not have to go through the House of Representatives (House) for approval. He expressed that statement during the trial of the Government Institution Authority Dispute (Sengketa Kewenangan Lembaga Negara – SKLN) at the Constitutional Court (MK) on Tuesday (8/5).

He asserted that the NNT divestment/investment was intended to ensure the company’s compliance in paying taxes and royalties and adhering to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) requirements, and to improve government oversight of NNT.

“The dispute has been going on for more than a year, and we have lost our opportunity to gain economic and social benefit. MK should be more objective in giving instructions to prevent further delay in social welfare improvement,” he stated.

Based on the Contract of Work between the Government and NNT, Agus Martowardojo, the Minister of Finance, also asserted that the divestment was within the Government’s rights, and it was done for national interest and the country’s improvement.

He confirmed that the seven percent divestment has given the Government a strategic position because it helps to achieve 51 percent domestic share ownership. “The divestment fund originated from Government Investment Fund allocations of IDR 1 trillion that were approved by the House, so no more approval was needed,” he explained.

Meanwhile, Nurson Wahid, a member of Commission IX of the House, stated that while the purpose of divestment was to transfer more of the company’s ownership from PT Newmont Mining Company (NMC) to Indonesian owners, based on International Best Practices and Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies (Company Law), the seven percent divestment was not enough to give the Government any meaningful influence as a shareholder.

Based on experience, he said that owning minority shares does not give the Government the right to be involved in strategic decision-making. He cited the Government’s ownership of 9 percent ownership of PT Freeport shares, 41 percent of PT Inalum shares, and 15 percent ownership of PT Indosat shares as examples of State ownership that did not lead to decision-making power.

Hadi Purnomo, Chairman of the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia, stated that the purchase of the divested shares also constituted a government investment in a publicly traded company; therefore, it should have been submitted to the House for approval.

In addition, he argued that the Minister of Finance (Minister) is not authorized to conduct an investment without the House’s approval. As the state’s treasurer, the Minister’s authority is limited to making deposits to banks for treasury management and buying state bonds (surat utang negara).

The SKLN trial addresses a dispute between the government, represented by the Indonesia Investment Agency (Pusat Investasi Pemerintah - PIP), and the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) and the House of Representatives. The House claims that PIP’s purchase of seven percent of NNT shares was illegal.

The government, as the applicant, is asking the Constitutional Court to declare that it had the authority to purchase seven percent of PT NNT shares in accordance with Articles 4 (1), 17 (1), 32C, and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.

(hot/am)

 

Agus Sahbani, Mahinda Arkyasa

Eddy Suratman, a professor from the Economics Faculty of Tanjung Pura University, stated that the Government’s purchase of a seven percent share in PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara (NNT) did not have to go through the House of Representatives (House) for approval. He expressed that statement during the trial of the Government Institution Authority Dispute (Sengketa Kewenangan Lembaga Negara – SKLN) at the Constitutional Court (MK) on Tuesday (8/5).

He asserted that the NNT divestment/investment was intended to ensure the company’s compliance in paying taxes and royalties and adhering to Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) requirements, and to improve government oversight of NNT.

“The dispute has been going on for more than a year, and we have lost our opportunity to gain economic and social benefit. MK should be more objective in giving instructions to prevent further delay in social welfare improvement,” he stated.

Based on the Contract of Work between the Government and NNT, Agus Martowardojo, the Minister of Finance, also asserted that the divestment was within the Government’s rights, and it was done for national interest and the country’s improvement.

He confirmed that the seven percent divestment has given the Government a strategic position because it helps to achieve 51 percent domestic share ownership. “The divestment fund originated from Government Investment Fund allocations of IDR 1 trillion that were approved by the House, so no more approval was needed,” he explained.

Meanwhile, Nurson Wahid, a member of Commission IX of the House, stated that while the purpose of divestment was to transfer more of the company’s ownership from PT Newmont Mining Company (NMC) to Indonesian owners, based on International Best Practices and Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies (Company Law), the seven percent divestment was not enough to give the Government any meaningful influence as a shareholder.

Based on experience, he said that owning minority shares does not give the Government the right to be involved in strategic decision-making. He cited the Government’s ownership of 9 percent ownership of PT Freeport shares, 41 percent of PT Inalum shares, and 15 percent ownership of PT Indosat shares as examples of State ownership that did not lead to decision-making power.

Hadi Purnomo, Chairman of the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia, stated that the purchase of the divested shares also constituted a government investment in a publicly traded company; therefore, it should have been submitted to the House for approval.

In addition, he argued that the Minister of Finance (Minister) is not authorized to conduct an investment without the House’s approval. As the state’s treasurer, the Minister’s authority is limited to making deposits to banks for treasury management and buying state bonds (surat utang negara).

The SKLN trial addresses a dispute between the government, represented by the Indonesia Investment Agency (Pusat Investasi Pemerintah - PIP), and the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK) and the House of Representatives. The House claims that PIP’s purchase of seven percent of NNT shares was illegal.

The government, as the applicant, is asking the Constitutional Court to declare that it had the authority to purchase seven percent of PT NNT shares in accordance with Articles 4 (1), 17 (1), 32C, and 33 (3) of the 1945 Constitution.

(hot/am)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info