Local Governments Must Provide Smoking Areas

The Constitutional Court granted a judicial review petition on Article 115 (1) and its elucidation in Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health (Health Law). In the decision No. 57/PUU-IX/2011, the Court declared that the word "may" (dapat) in Article 115 (1) of the Health Law and its elucidation contradicts the 1945 Constitution and is not legally binding.

The Court argued that Article 115 of Health Law and its elucidation control addictive substances, in order to maintain and improve public health. Article 115 ensures that the use of addictive substances will not harm and endanger the health of individuals, families, communities and the environment.

"Local government should create no-smoking areas within their regions, including in work places, public places and the other places," said Hamdan Zoelva, one of the Constitutional Court judges, during the judicial review trial in Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).

The Court asserted that the obligation to create no-smoking areas should be followed by creating smoking areas, which are also a form of protection for the public.

Therefore, the Court agreed with the applicant's argument that the word “may” in Article 115 (1) creates legal uncertainty, which contradicts Article 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution.

"The elucidation of Article 115 of the Health Law, particularly the word 'may', means that the Government may or may not provide a 'smoking area' in workplaces, public places, and other places," said Hamdan again.

The word "may", said the Court, does not accommodate the interests of people who smoke, which is a legal activity, and the interests of the public which wants to avoid the dangers of smoking.

Daru Supriyono, the applicant’s legal counsel, applauded this decision. "This meets our expectations, because the Court granted all of our petitions. From now on, all regional regulations [on the smoking issue] should based on this decision," Daru said.

The judicial review petition was filed by Enryo Oktavian, Abhisam Demosa, and Irwan Sofyan. The applicants are active smokers, who cannot smoke in their offices, because there are no smoking areas.

The applicants argued that Article 115 does not state an obligation to provide smoking areas, because the word “may” is use. The word "may" does not provide legal certainty and violates the constitutional rights of people who smoke.

The applicants asked for the word "may" to be revoked, because it contradicts Article 27 paragraph (1) and 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution. If the word is removed, local government must provide smoking areas.

(Agus Sahbani / Batara Parlindungan)

The Constitutional Court granted a judicial review petition on Article 115 (1) and its elucidation in Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health (Health Law). In the decision No. 57/PUU-IX/2011, the Court declared that the word "may" (dapat) in Article 115 (1) of the Health Law and its elucidation contradicts the 1945 Constitution and is not legally binding.

The Court argued that Article 115 of Health Law and its elucidation control addictive substances, in order to maintain and improve public health. Article 115 ensures that the use of addictive substances will not harm and endanger the health of individuals, families, communities and the environment.

"Local government should create no-smoking areas within their regions, including in work places, public places and the other places," said Hamdan Zoelva, one of the Constitutional Court judges, during the judicial review trial in Jakarta, Tuesday (17/4).

The Court asserted that the obligation to create no-smoking areas should be followed by creating smoking areas, which are also a form of protection for the public.

Therefore, the Court agreed with the applicant's argument that the word “may” in Article 115 (1) creates legal uncertainty, which contradicts Article 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution.

"The elucidation of Article 115 of the Health Law, particularly the word 'may', means that the Government may or may not provide a 'smoking area' in workplaces, public places, and other places," said Hamdan again.

The word "may", said the Court, does not accommodate the interests of people who smoke, which is a legal activity, and the interests of the public which wants to avoid the dangers of smoking.

Daru Supriyono, the applicant’s legal counsel, applauded this decision. "This meets our expectations, because the Court granted all of our petitions. From now on, all regional regulations [on the smoking issue] should based on this decision," Daru said.

The judicial review petition was filed by Enryo Oktavian, Abhisam Demosa, and Irwan Sofyan. The applicants are active smokers, who cannot smoke in their offices, because there are no smoking areas.

The applicants argued that Article 115 does not state an obligation to provide smoking areas, because the word “may” is use. The word "may" does not provide legal certainty and violates the constitutional rights of people who smoke.

The applicants asked for the word "may" to be revoked, because it contradicts Article 27 paragraph (1) and 28D paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution. If the word is removed, local government must provide smoking areas.

(Agus Sahbani / Batara Parlindungan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info